- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents a super-resolution method for spatial transcriptomics. The main contribution is the Dual-Adaptive Spatial Transcriptomics which jointly adapts multiscale context integration and expression mapping to predict superpixel-level gene expression under spot-aggregated supervision. The method is evaluated on VisiumHD and Xenium datasets, showing improved performance over compared approaches.
Critical strengths
-
Overall relatively simple methods, which focused on cross-attention between modalities and multiscale contexts with dynamic fusion.
-
Results on 10 datasets show consistent improvements over existing methods.
Critical weaknesses
-
The spatial context modelling is rather simple, and the overall method is extended from HISTEX, which proposed the BCA module that is heavily used in this proposed approach. The paper shows relatively minor insights into the method design or theoretical foundations.
-
It's not clear how results of compared methods in Table 1 were obtained. The numbers do not follow the original paper either. Were the comparison fair? What experimental setup and features were used for the compared methods?
-
The use of UNI features could be very important to obtain the reported results. How would the approach work with other features?
-
It's not clear to me what was the training/testing protocol. Was the model trained and tested on each individual dataset? What was the training/testing split?
-
Visual results in Figure 3 show that the output from the proposed method is actually not very good, with lots of noise in certain regions and the boundaries between regions are noisy too. Did the improvement in numerical results mainly super-resolution or actual spatial prediction? If it's super-resolution, then if evaluation was conducted on down-sampled images, the comparative results could be quite different.
Questions for authors
Please address the weaknesses.
6 comments
2. Sources of the baseline results and fairness of the experimental comparison (W2)
We appreciate why differences from the published scores raise questions about the comparison conditions. Table 1 reports results obtained by running the authors’ public implementations on the datasets evaluated here, following the training methods and configurations in their papers and code. The scores correspond to these tissue sections and target gene sets, rather than being copied from the original publications.
For HISTEX and scstGCN, we retain UNI features, 500 training epochs, and median ensembling over five model states. HISTEX’s official example specifies --epochs 500 --n-states 5; scstGCN uses the same defaults, and both prediction implementations take the median across states. DAST follows the same training duration and ensembling strategy.
For each dataset, DAST, HISTEX, and scstGCN directly reuse the same pre-extracted UNI feature file, together with the same low-resolution expression, spatial coordinates, and target genes. UNI is already used by these baselines, so sharing the file preserves their feature source while ensuring identical histological inputs. Each baseline retains its publicly released architecture and training configuration; the GPU hardware differs from that used in the original work.
Evaluation follows a common procedure: predictions and references are aligned by gene and location, independently min–max normalized per gene, and assessed using tissue-masked RMSE and whole-map SSIM with non-tissue locations set to zero, followed by aggregation across genes. HISTEX’s public evaluation scripts use this normalization and masking procedure.
Thus, the reported comparisons use common data and evaluation conditions, while preserving the methods’ original training procedures.
3. Contribution of UNI features and applicability to other histological representations (W3)
UNI is an important component of the pipeline, and your question helps distinguish its contribution from that of the downstream model. DAST, HISTEX, and scstGCN share the exact same UNI feature files across all datasets, so their performance differences are measured under identical histological representations. Tables 2 and 3 likewise hold the histological features and expression inputs fixed when evaluating the proposed components.
The pipeline arranges frozen UNI tokens at their tissue locations to form a spatial feature map. DAST’s subsequent modules operate on spatially aligned feature tensors; other encoders could be accommodated by adapting the input dimensions and spatial sampling to their feature dimensions and token spacing, followed by retraining. A controlled comparison would supply the same alternative features to DAST and the main baselines.
We have not completed that experiment, which requires new feature extraction and model training within the limited time and computational resources available during rebuttal. The current evidence supports the contribution of DAST’s downstream design under shared UNI features; performance with other encoders remains an empirical question.
4. Section-specific training, supervision, and the training/testing protocol (W4)
The key distinction is that DAST performs reconstruction within each section: a separate model uses that section’s low-resolution expression and H&E image, and its fine-grained predictions are evaluated against the high-resolution reference. Section 4.1 introduces this setting.
We construct an 8 μm reference grid from Visium HD or Xenium data and aggregate expression within circular spots to obtain low-resolution observations. During training, superpixel predictions are averaged within each spot and compared with its normalized observed expression. Individual high-resolution superpixel labels are not training targets. After training, whole-section predictions are evaluated against the reference using RMSE and SSIM.
All valid low-resolution spots are observations available for reconstructing the section, so there is no separate spatial train/validation/test split. The ten datasets are trained and evaluated independently. This protocol assesses recovery of fine-grained expression from the observed spot aggregates, rather than prediction on held-out sections.
As specified in Appendix D.2, DAST and its trained controls use 500 epochs and five independent initializations with seeds 0–4. We retain each run’s final checkpoint and take the median prediction at every location and gene; checkpoint selection does not use high-resolution validation metrics. High-resolution data are used for benchmark construction, evaluation, and Visium HD highly variable gene selection, while model optimization uses spot-level supervision.
5. Spatial-domain quality and the effect of comparing results at a common resolution (W5)
Your observations about local noise and boundaries raise a useful question about how the spatial-domain results should be compared. We have added two complementary views: regional enlargements of the original Figure 3 comparison, and a separate comparison at a common spot resolution.
First, Table 1 evaluates spatial gene-expression reconstruction. Predictions from all methods are aligned to the same high-resolution reference grid and evaluated after gene-wise normalization. RMSE measures expression errors at corresponding tissue locations, while SSIM measures local spatial structural similarity. The improvements therefore indicate closer agreement with measured reference expression on a common grid, beyond an increase in output density.
Figure 3 examines how the learned fine-grained representations support spatial-domain analysis. DAST clusters its pre-decoder multimodal representations, whereas STAGATE and GraphST identify domains from the original spot data. The colors denote cluster labels, so the local noise and boundaries concern their spatial distribution, rather than the continuous expression values evaluated in Table 1.
To examine local structures, we enlarged the hippocampal region in the original spatial-domain comparison and displayed it alongside the histological and anatomical references from the Allen Brain Atlas. These enlargements retain the original display resolution of each method.
Separately, we aggregated DAST’s superpixel cluster labels by majority voting within each spot and compared the resulting labels at exactly the same 2,896 spot locations used by STAGATE and GraphST. This whole-section comparison aligns the sampling locations and display resolution, allowing the spatial-domain patterns to be examined at a common scale.
The spot-level comparison concerns the cluster labels in Figure 3. Jointly downsampling predicted and reference expression would instead assess expression agreement at a coarser scale; Table 1 evaluates recovery at the measured high-resolution reference scale.
We will include both the regional enlargements of the original Figure 3 comparison and the separate whole-section comparison after aggregation to the spot level in the revised manuscript. We appreciate your suggestion, which provides a more direct basis for examining local structure and the effect of display resolution on the spatial-domain comparison.
Thank you for examining both the methodological contribution and the experimental basis of our work so closely. Your concerns highlight the importance of explaining what the adaptive design contributes, how the comparisons were conducted, and what the evaluation establishes. We appreciate the opportunity to address these points, as well as your recognition of the consistent improvements across ten datasets.
Below, we explain the design motivation and existing ablation evidence, the shared inputs and baseline configurations, the role of UNI features, and the section-specific training protocol. To address your observations about Figure 3, we have added regional enlargements of the original spatial-domain comparison and a separate whole-section comparison after aggregating DAST’s labels to the spot level. We will include both additions in the revised manuscript.
We understand your concern about what DAST contributes beyond the cross-modal interaction used in previous methods. Building on prior work, including the BCA module introduced by HISTEX, DAST connects location-dependent context composition with location-dependent expression mapping.
The biological motivation comes from the role of the tissue microenvironment in gene expression: local cellular composition and surrounding tissue organization can provide relevant information over different spatial ranges. DAST lets each histological scale interact with the same local expression context and learns how much each scale contributes at each location.
The next design question is how to map this varying context to expression. DAST uses both the fused content and its scale weights to select among experts with different hidden widths. The scale weights therefore serve two connected purposes: they organize the context and inform the subsequent mapping choice. Under spot-aggregated supervision, where one observation can correspond to multiple within-spot expression distributions, these coupled adaptations provide learnable structural constraints for reconstruction.
The existing comparisons in Table 2 examine this connection using four combinations of context integration and expression mapping, with approximately matched total decoder parameter counts and the same training and evaluation protocol. On HBC_S1R1:
On this dataset, multiscale context alone does not improve the dense mapping, whereas combining it with heterogeneous experts gives the best results. Across ten datasets, replacing dense mapping with experts yields larger gains under multiscale representations on 9/10 datasets for RMSE and 8/10 for SSIM.
Table 3 further shows that the full model outperforms equal-weight fusion, homogeneous experts, and the variant without a shared expert. Permuting fusion weights or content-routing logits, or forcing any single expert, also reduces reconstruction quality. These comparisons support the contribution of jointly adapting the context and the mapping that uses it.