- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces HyBoxST, a method for predicting spatial gene expression from H&E images. Built upon HyperST, HyBoxST incorporates a pathway-guided decoder. Specifically, the method involves representations for both pathways and genes. Reactome/Hallmark pathways are represented as learnable axis-aligned boxes, while genes are represented as points, with a membership constraint encouraging genes to fall within the boxes of their respective pathways. To generate a correction for pathway scores, a "query box" is derived from spot and niche image features; the smooth overlap between this query box and each pathway box is mapped to an additive correction applied to the directly predicted pathway score (trained to match the mean log-expression of member genes). These corrected pathway scores are aggregated into gene-level predictions using non-negative weights constrained by membership masks, followed by gated fusion with a branch that directly predicts gene expression. Experiments were conducted on four tissue types from the HEST-1K dataset (kidney, colorectum, skin, and lung) using 200 genes per tissue and five random data splits. Performance was evaluated using metrics such as PCC@200, MSE, and MAE, with comparisons made against baseline results from the original HyperST paper; additional analyses included component ablation studies, pathway mask shuffling experiments, and an examination of pathway scores in kidney tissue.
Critical strengths
The inductive bias is natural, and the internal control experiments show consistent trends. Using box embeddings to represent the concept that a single gene can belong to multiple overlapping pathways, and then matching this against queries generated from image features, is a natural and somewhat novel design; furthermore, component ablation and mask-shuffling control experiments yield consistent results across four tissue types. This is likely the paper's only methodological innovation that could justify its acceptance.
The code is relatively complete, allowing key details to be verified. Based on the released code, inference-time predictions rely solely on image features, while the measured expression of test spots enters only the evaluation, ensuring no label leakage occurs; additionally, checkpoints are selected based strictly on the validation set. This rules out test-label leakage during training and inference, a common pitfall in this type of work, and the results are verifiable within the authors' own pipeline.
Critical weaknesses
- The contributions are meager, and the distinction from existing work is unclear. The three claimed contributions (the overall method, a specific module within it, and the experiments) effectively boil down to one.
The combination of "pathway scores as intermediate variables + membership-masked decoding + residual branches" follows the same logic as MSGR and PEaRL, yet neither was used as a baseline for comparison; the hyperbolic alignment is inherited from HyperST. The only truly novel elements are the box query correction and the learned static weights . Consequently, the vast majority of components are unremarkable.
The impact of the new components is minimal. In Appendix D.4, the box geometry outperforms an MLP query with matched parameter counts by only 0.006–0.013 (PCC@200). No ablation study compares against uniform averaging. Both and the gating mechanism are global parameters, which contradicts the stated motivation of "allowing the contributions of functional groups to gene prediction to reflect local tissue context."
The relationship with HyperST is inadequately explained, potentially misleading readers. The main text contains only a single sentence stating "follow the spatial alignment framework of Zhang et al. (2026)," and Appendix A.1 mentions "inherited" in two places, yet it never explicitly clarifies that this framework is the very same HyperST listed as a baseline in Table 1. Neither the abstract nor the introduction states that "HyBoxST = HyperST framework + new decoder," even though the title foregrounds "Hyperbolic Spatial Representations" and no ablation study is provided for the hyperbolic component. The code and README also fail to mention HyperST.
Appendix B contains mathematical redundancies. The 21 equations mostly cover elementary facts, such as the invariance of Pearson correlation to positive affine transformations, Jensen's inequality, expansion of squares, the triangle inequality, and operation counts; none of these support the core claims. Conversely, the analysis actually needed regarding the inductive bias introduced by boxes is missing.
For a top-tier deep learning/representation learning conference like ICLR, the methodological contribution here is incremental and lacks a clear distinction from existing work. While the paper possesses some novelty with experiments, I believe it would be more suitable for submission to journals such as BIB or Bioinformatics.
- The main conclusions lack controlled comparisons, making it impossible to attribute the performance gains to the proposed method.
HyBoxST employs UNI (ViT-L, ~300M parameters, pre-trained on large-scale pathology tiles) with LoRA fine-tuning; in contrast, the original papers for StNet, BLEEP, and TRIPLEX utilized ImageNet-pre-trained DenseNet-121, ResNet-50, and self-supervised ResNet-18, respectively. The paper fails to specify the encoders used for the baselines in Table 1, whereas the HEST-Benchmark has demonstrated that simply changing the encoder can lead to significant score improvements.
Relying solely on the UNI foundation model (FM) makes it impossible to determine whether the gains from the decoder are independent of the encoder. The only evidence from a controlled setting is weak; gains observed in the internal ablation study range from approximately 0 to 0.05, falling within the margin of standard deviation. Each split contains only 1–2 test slides (5 for the Skin dataset), and the five random splits overlap with one another. Furthermore, the 200-gene panel was selected using the entire dataset, including the test slides.
On the Colorectum dataset, HyBoxST underperforms compared to HyperST and TRIPLEX in PCC@200, contradicting the abstract's claim that HyBoxST "consistently improves gene expression prediction."
Based on the information currently presented in the paper, I cannot determine whether the improvements stem from the pathway decoder or from the stronger backbone and distinct training pipeline.
Questions for authors
All baseline numbers in Table 1 are quoted from Zhang et al. (2026). The HyBoxST pipeline uses EMA, data augmentation, additional loss terms and post-hoc calibration, and the paper acknowledges that the quoted baselines are not guaranteed to follow the same pipeline. However, Figure 4 (Appendix D.6) shows per-spot predictions of HyperST, StNet, BLEEP, Stem and TRIPLEX on NCBI704, which indicates that the authors are able to run these baselines. Please report the following results under an identical pipeline (same gene panel and data splits, LoRA-tuned UNI, EMA, data augmentation, loss terms and post-hoc calibration).
- (a) HyperST;
- (b) the
hyboxst_basevariant in the released code, which does not include the pathway decoder; - (c) TRIPLEX, BLEEP and StNet using UNI features, or at least a UNI + MLP/ridge baseline following the HEST-Benchmark protocol.
Does the gain of HyBoxST over hyboxst_base persist when UNI is replaced by at least two other encoders (e.g., an ImageNet-pretrained ResNet-50 and another pathology foundation model), or when UNI is frozen?
Under the same setting, how does HyBoxST compare with MSGR and PEaRL? What happens if the learned weights W are replaced by uniform averaging over the pathways a gene belongs to? Since W and the gene gates are shared across all spots, how does the model realize the stated motivation that pathway contributions vary with local tissue context, beyond the additive correction to the pathway scores?
Please state explicitly in the abstract and introduction which of the following components are inherited from HyperST, namely the image encoder and LoRA setup, hyperbolic alignment, niche construction, gene selection, data splits, and the training and evaluation pipeline. Please also report results with the hyperbolic alignment removed; if it is not essential, the title and the framing of the contributions should be revised accordingly.
Since the current five random splits overlap with each other, disjoint folds or leave-one-slide-out evaluation would be preferable. Please also report results with the gene panel selected from training slides only. Finally, the abstract claims consistent improvement, but HyBoxST underperforms HyperST and TRIPLEX in PCC@200 on Colorectum; please revise this claim or explain the result.
If the authors address these questions thoroughly in the rebuttal, I will consider raising my score to 2.