- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GASP, a framework for predicting spatial gene expression from histology images. The authors argue that existing approaches mainly follow a vision-centric paradigm, where visual representations are extracted and mapped to gene expression through shared decoders, which overlooks the heterogeneous morphological dependencies of different genes. To address this issue, GASP introduces learnable gene queries that interact with multi-scale visual contexts through a vision-gene cross-attention mechanism. Furthermore, a gene-specific residual decoding strategy is proposed to model gene-level variations. The paper evaluates GASP on several spatial transcriptomics benchmarks and reports improvements over existing approaches. While the motivation of modeling gene-specific morphology relationships is interesting, I have concerns regarding the fundamental novelty, biological interpretation of the proposed query mechanism, and the completeness of experimental validation.
Critical strengths
1.The paper identifies an important limitation of existing spatial transcriptomics prediction methods. Different genes may indeed correspond to different morphological patterns, and modeling such heterogeneity is a meaningful direction. The idea of moving beyond a shared decoder toward gene-conditioned prediction is intuitively appealing. 2.The proposed use of multi-scale visual contexts, including local morphology, neighborhood information, and global tissue structures, is reasonable for spatial transcriptomics prediction. The cross-attention mechanism provides a flexible way to integrate gene representations with visual features.
Critical weaknesses
1.The paper describes gene queries as actively retrieving preferred morphological cues. However, these queries are randomly initialized learnable embeddings optimized only through downstream prediction loss. Without explicit biological priors, pathway information, or structural constraints, it remains unclear whether these queries represent meaningful biological entities or simply task-specific latent variables. The authors should provide stronger evidence demonstrating that the learned queries capture genuine gene-specific morphological dependencies. 2.The design assigns an independent learnable query to each target gene. However, it remains unclear whether this leads to meaningful specialization or simply introduces redundant parameters. Many genes share related biological pathways and morphological patterns, suggesting that independent queries may not be the optimal representation strategy. A more principled design might require modeling relationships among genes rather than learning isolated gene-specific embeddings.
Questions for authors
The central claim of GASP is that gene queries can actively retrieve gene-specific morphological cues. However, these queries are learned solely through the downstream gene expression prediction objective without explicit biological priors or semantic constraints. How do the authors demonstrate that the learned gene queries represent genuine biological morphology–gene relationships?