- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposed ARCADE for mosaic spatial deconvolution, where different tissue sections profile disparate subsets of molecular modalities. By integrating multi-relational graph learning, bridge section-guided cross-modality alignment, and reference-guided NB likelihood, ARCADE demonstrates superior performance on two real-world datasets.
Critical strengths
Inferring the cell-type composition of spots in spatial multi-omics is an important and timely task. In the context of mosaic spatial multi-omics, the formulation of deconvolution via joint representation learning is both novel and practically significant.
The article is well-motivated, the writing is well-organized, and the model design is very clear and easy to follow.
The paper also presents a highly detailed ablation and sensitivity analysis of the model, clearly demonstrating the design rationale and function of each component. The authors also provide well-organized codes to reproduce the results.
Critical weaknesses
My primary concern lies in the author's evaluation: the use of non-standard metrics, insufficient datasets, and the absence of a synthetic gold standard. (That's why I gave a low soundness score)
- All eight quantitative evaluation metrics in the paper (LISI, SC, PAS, CHAOS, SMS, BEAR, ARI, NMI) seem to evaluate hard, discrete partition accuracy after reducing the continuous proportion vector to a single dominant cell type, which may induce severe bias. If an algorithm predicts pure hard 0-1 assignments, it may also achieve superior ARI or boundary agreement scores while failing as a reliable proportion estimator. In fact, they're more like evaluating spatial clustering instead of deconvolution.
- As real-world spatial spots lack ground-truth cellular mixture proportions, why not benchmarking on synthetic pseudo-spots generated by mixing known single-cell profiles, like what did in CARD [1], cell2location [2], RCTD [3], and benchmark article [4]? The authors only evaluate on two real datasets with eight spatial-clustering style metrics, and it is insufficient to show that ARCADE can accurately estimate mixing proportions.
In addition, the method proposed in this paper also has several theoretical flaws.
- In section 2.2, the authors claim that constraining the cell-type size factor vector to have a unit geometric mean ensures model identifiability, but provide no theorectical justification. In fact, I believe it theoretically flawed: remains unidentifiable because the uncentered nuisance parameters and the convex cone induce a scale-shift gauge symmetry that permits non-trivial affine deformations of within the simplex while preserving identical NB likelihood.
- While the intuition that "direction u reflects relative proportions and magnitude r reflects molecular abundance" seems reasonable, It's not clear for me why GNN and MLP processed graph representation can automatically achive this. Did the authors consider principled disentangled representation learning to achieve this?
Reference:
[1] Ma, Y., Zhou, X. Spatially informed cell-type deconvolution for spatial transcriptomics. Nat Biotechnol 40, 1349–1359 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-022-01273-7
[2] Kleshchevnikov, V., Shmatko, A., Dann, E. et al. Cell2location maps fine-grained cell types in spatial transcriptomics. Nat Biotechnol 40, 661–671 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-021-01139-4
[3] Cable, D.M., Murray, E., Zou, L.S. et al. Robust decomposition of cell type mixtures in spatial transcriptomics. Nat Biotechnol 40, 517–526 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-021-00830-w
[4] Li, H., Zhou, J., Li, Z. et al. A comprehensive benchmarking with practical guidelines for cellular deconvolution of spatial transcriptomics. Nat Commun 14, 1548 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-37168-7
Questions for authors
When evaluating the deconvolution performance on sections without RNA data, why not compare the results obtained with and without the inclusion of RNA measurements on paired data to better demonstrate the model's performance on RNA-missing section? For example, compare the deconvolution results on slice 3 obtained by training on RNA+protein data from slice 1 and protein data from slice 3 of the human tonsil dataset, against the results obtained by using both modalities from both slices 1 and 3.
ARCADE aggregates modality-specific representations using unweighted average. Why not using a weighted one to accounting for the different different signal-to-noise ratios, capture efficiencies, biological informativeness or uncertainties of different modalities?
Also, the authors need to provide more justifications on the identifiability and direction-magnitude representation disentanglement (either theorectical or empirical).
Some of my concerns remain unresolved after the authors’ response, so I am maintaining my original rating.