- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
COSMIC presents a framework for learning a unified latent representation from multi-slice spatial multi-omics data, while preserving biological structure and reducing batch effects.
It uses target-conditioned cross-modal interaction (TCCI) to integrate complementary information across modalities and cluster-guided conditional alignment (CGCA) to selectively align reliable biological structures. COSMIC is evaluated using four datasets, and with ablations showing generally modest contributions from its proposed TCCI and CGCA components.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well motivated to jointly address cross-modal fusion and cross-slice alignment instead of treating them as two independent problems.
- The evaluation is performed against seven existing methods, in Table 1 and 2, although I have some concerns about the reported results, please see weakness section.
Critical weaknesses
- From table 1 and 2, I can see that COSMIC is not always the best for many individual metrics yet achieves the best Total score through a custom Total metric defined 0.6 times conservation + 0.4 times batch correction. I cannot see any justification or sensitivity analysis for this weighting and raises concerns about whether the reported overall ranking is robust to alternative weighting choices.
- The paper content is difficult to follow with several technical abbreviations are introduced without being explicitly defined, such as MNN, and FFN. Also, some terminologies are inconsistent for example, E(m) is referred to as both the “topology-aware representation” and “target representation,” making the method unnecessarily confusing.
- There are also inconsistencies while describing the results where the numbers in the text do not match with the tables, for example In table-3, text states that removing TCCI reduces “Bio Conservation and Total from 0.618 to 0.600”; however, Table 3 shows that Bio Conservation decreases from 0.485 to 0.464, while only the Total score decreases from 0.618 to 0.600.
Questions for authors
- What is the rational of using Total metric as 0.6 times conservation + 0.4 times batch correction?
- Would the relative ranking of methods will remain same under different alternative weighting choices?
- Is the unified joint multi-slice topology graph is constructed only once and fixed during training or it is dynamically updated during optimization?