- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposed a flow matching based method for spatial multi-omic clustering.
Critical strengths
This paper proposed a flow matching based method for spatial data integration while the idea is interesting.
Critical weaknesses
This paper proposed a flow matching based method for spatial data integration while the idea is interesting, I’m doubting usability of method and the definition of problems.
- Special multi-omic data is known with high noise level, but the authors do not discuss them. Please design experiments to justify the data quality and human annotation match your expectation and standard for computational method, if not, all learned signals can be noise.
- Clustering is a very trivial problem, and PRAGA shows very similar performance FlowMOS, and thus the method contribution seems not informative and helpful. I’m also doubting the performances of other baselines. Do you tune their method to achieve the best performances? If not, this is an unfair comparison.
- Ablation study is also very weird. If the authors remove the reconstruction loss, then the performance is quite close, compared with FlowMOS. Can the authors explain the reasons are how to justify the loss function is optimal setting?
- These UMAPs also cannot distinguish their methods versus other baselines, every distribution seems very similar to me and biologists
- There is no biological interpretation about cluster labels and how do the authors justify the method and preserve the biological information such as gene pathway?
Questions for authors
See my questions above, mainly related the definition of problem and soundness of method.