- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Context-aware Synchronization for Spatial Multi-omics Representation Learning (CSR), which formulates spatial multi-omics representation learning as a context-regulated synchronization process on a hyperspherical representation space. CSR constructs location-specific contextual references by integrating multimodal representations with multiscale graph contexts via a graph scattering transform, and uses these references to guide hyperspherical synchronization dynamics under graph-based relational constraints. The authors establish energy descent of the continuous synchronization dynamics and characterize context-regulated stationary states.
The main contributions are: (1) formulating spatial multi-omics representation learning as a context-regulated synchronization problem on a hyperspherical representation space; (2) introducing location-specific contextual references that integrate multimodal representations with multiscale graph contexts to provide continuous location-dependent guidance; (3) providing theoretical analysis establishing energy descent and characterizing context-regulated stationary states; and (4) achieving strong clustering performance on five spatial multi-omics datasets.
Validation includes experiments on five datasets across RNA+ATAC, RNA+ADT, and RNA+ADT+ATAC settings, comparisons with eight representative baselines, nine evaluation metrics, ablation studies on key components, sensitivity analysis on context strength and synchronization steps, and runtime/memory comparisons. CSR generally outperforms representative baselines such as SMART, SpatialGlue, COSMOS, and ProtoPSR on clustering metrics.
Critical strengths
-
The paper formulates spatial multi-omics representation learning as context-regulated synchronization on a hyperspherical space. Section 4 provides a unified formalization of relation-guided regularization (Eq. 3) and a gradient constraint (Proposition 1), which clearly identifies the gap that existing relation-guided methods do not treat location-specific context as an independent component of geometry optimization.
-
CSR generally leads across five datasets, eight baselines, and nine metrics, with particularly clear margins on Mouse Embryonic Brain E15.5 (ARI 70.94 vs. 61.39 for SMART) and Human Lymph Node A1 (ARI 38.13 vs. 35.23 for SMART). The ablation study (Fig. 5) covers five key components, and the dynamics analysis (Fig. 4) intuitively shows how contextual regulation promotes intra-domain synchronization while preventing excessive cross-domain synchronization.
Critical weaknesses
-
Appendix C.3 states the contextual strength α = [0.01], while the sensitivity analysis in Fig. 6 uses γ as the context strength and shows that γ = 0.1–0.5 is favorable. If α and γ are the same parameter, the default setting contradicts the sensitivity conclusion. If they are different, their relationship is not clarified.
-
The proofs of Theorem 1 and Proposition 2 are correct but are routine properties of Riemannian gradient flows. The paper does not provide convergence rates, finite-time guarantees, or a deeper characterization of the interaction between the graph spectrum and contextual references. Moreover, the proposed dynamics have no formal connection to classical synchronization theory such as the Kuramoto model.
Questions for authors
1.Relationship between α and γ. Is α = [0.01] in Appendix C.3 the same parameter as γ in Fig. 6, where the favorable range is 0.1–0.5? If so, why does the default value deviate from the favorable range in the sensitivity analysis? If not, please clarify the definitions and the basis for each value.
2.Please provide clustering performance and modality-specific information preservation after removing the reconstruction objective (Eq. 15). The absence of this ablation prevents me from assessing the actual contribution of the claim that the reconstruction objective preserves modality-specific information.
3.Please provide a sensitivity analysis for the number of scales (currently two) and the maximum scattering order (currently two).
4.Proposition 2 characterizes the stationary condition for a fully synchronized state, but representations of different spatial domains in real data are not fully synchronized. Please discuss the implications of this theoretical result for practical synchronization trajectories that are not fully synchronized, or provide a more general characterization of stationary states.
5.On HLN A1 and Mouse Brain, CSR’s sLISI is lower than some baselines. Please analyze the source of this trade-off (e.g., whether it is related to contextual strength or graph construction) and discuss in which application scenarios spatial coherence should be prioritized.
2 comments
Rebuttal Part 2: Q4, Q5
Q4. Implications of Proposition 2 for partially synchronized states.
R5. Proposition 2 identifies when complete synchronization cannot be a stationary state; it does not assume that representations in real spatial data become fully synchronized.
For partially synchronized states, Eq. 10 requires relational coupling and contextual guidance to satisfy the projected force-balance condition:
More specifically, Appendix F.2 establishes that, under small nonuniform contextual perturbations, nearby stationary states retain location-dependent representation differences. Thus, contextual guidance can sustain distinct representations while relational coupling promotes coherence.
Consistently, Fig. 4 shows increasing intra-domain similarity while reducing inter-domain similarity during synchronization.
Q5. Spatial coherence trade-off and application-specific priorities.
R6. Following your suggestion, we have conducted additional experiments to investigate whether contextual strength or graph construction contributes to CSR's lower sLISI on HLN A1 and Mouse Brain. We also clarify when spatial coherence should be prioritized.
1. Source of the discrepancy. In the main results, CSR achieves lower sLISI than COSMOS on HLN A1 (88.99 vs. 93.06) and Mouse Brain (90.12 vs. 96.04), despite substantially higher ARI. We further varied and compared union-graph with spatial-only coupling across five datasets. The results show that coupling-graph construction has a more pronounced effect, particularly on Mouse Brain, while contextual-strength effects vary across datasets. At α = 0.01, spatial-only coupling increases mean sLISI from 88.39 to 96.30 but reduces mean ARI from 36.83 to 29.28 on Mouse Brain (Figs. 7–8 and Tab. 10, Appendix H).
2. Application-specific priorities. Spatial coherence should be prioritized when identifying large, contiguous tissue compartments or reducing spatially isolated assignments. In contrast, preserving molecular distinctions is important for heterogeneous tissues and small cellular niches, where excessive spatial smoothing may obscure meaningful domain boundaries.
These results indicate that higher spatial coherence does not necessarily imply more accurate spatial domain identification. Additional visual comparisons are provided in Fig. 6 (Appendix H).
Rebuttal Part 1: W1/Q1, W2, Q2, Q3
R1. We thank the reviewer for identifying this inconsistency. The symbols α and γ refer to the same contextual-strength parameter, which has been standardized to α throughout the revised manuscript.
Regarding the parameter settings, the contextual strength is dataset-specific, rather than fixed across all datasets. The settings used in our experiments are summarized in Appendix D(Training and Evaluation Protocol). The sensitivity analysis evaluates α∈{0.01,0.05,0.1,0.5,1,2}, covering all the settings above. The sensitivity analysis shows dataset-dependent behavior rather than a universally favorable range (Fig. 9).
R2. We have strengthened the theoretical analysis in three aspects: finite-time stationarity, graph–context interactions, and the connection to classical synchronization theory. These results extend the original energy-descent and stationary-state analysis with quantitative characterizations of the proposed dynamics.
1. Finite-time stationarity guarantee. We have established that the continuous synchronization dynamics satisfy
min0≤t≤τ∥gradE(Z(t))∥F2≤τE(Z(0))−Einf
This provides an O(1/τ) finite-time bound on the minimum squared Riemannian gradient norm, under fixed graph and contextual references (Appendix F.1).
2. Interaction between graph spectrum and contextual guidance. We have derived a local spectral characterization around a synchronized configuration. For ci=ru+δi, where r>0 and δi is a sufficiently small tangent perturbation, the stationary response satisfies
\frac{\alpha}{\beta\lambda_k+\alpha r}\hat\delta_k +O(\|\Delta\|_F^2).$$ **This quantifies how graph Laplacian eigenvalues and contextual strength jointly influence local representation differences**, with higher-frequency contextual variations more strongly attenuated by graph coupling (Appendix F.2). **3. Connection to classical synchronization theory.** We have established an exact reduction to Kuramoto-type dynamics in the two-dimensional case: $$\dot\theta_i= \beta\sum_j A_{ij}\sin(\theta_j-\theta_i) +\alpha r_i\sin(\phi_i-\theta_i).$$ **The first term represents Kuramoto-type phase coupling, while the second introduces location-specific contextual forcing.** This establishes a formal connection to classical synchronization theory (Appendix F.3). The detailed assumptions, theoretical results, and proofs are provided in **Appendix F.1–F.3**. The practical interpretation of Proposition 2 is addressed separately in our response to Q4. > Q2. Contribution of the reconstruction objective to modality-specific information preservation. R3. Based on your suggestion, we have conducted modality-specific reconstruction ablations to evaluate the contribution of reconstruction supervision to both clustering performance and modality-feature recoverability. Each reconstruction term is removed separately while retaining all input modalities and the remaining reconstruction objectives. 1. **Clustering performance**. Removing each modality-specific reconstruction term reduces ARI, NMI, and FMI relative to Full CSR across the tested datasets, demonstrating the contribution of reconstruction supervision to spatial domain identification (Fig. 10). 2. **Modality-specific information preservation.** We further evaluated MSE and R² between each modality’s original features and the corresponding reconstructions from the learned representations, using independently trained evaluation decoders under the same protocol. Reconstruction supervision generally improves the recoverability of modality-specific information from the learned representations, which supports the role of the reconstruction objective in preserving modality-specific information(Fig. 11). Together, these results demonstrate that reconstruction supervision improves clustering performance and generally enhances modality-feature recoverability. The experimental details are provided in Appendix J. > Q3. Sensitivity to graph-scattering hyperparameters. R4. According to your advice, we have conducted sensitivity experiments on the maximum wavelet scale $H\in{1,2,3,4,5}$ and maximum scattering order $\nu\in{1,2,3,4}$. The experiments cover Human Lymph Node A1, Human Tonsil Section 1, and Mouse Brain, reporting ARI and NMI. **As shown in Fig. 9, CSR exhibits relatively stable performance across the tested configurations**, although the sensitivity varies by dataset, particularly on Human Tonsil Section 1.