- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a single-pass bidirectional cross-modal image translation framework based on invertible latent flows. The framework employs modality-specific encoders and decoders connected by an invertible flow and introduces two additional regularization objectives: manifold consistency and trajectory regularization. By regularizing the intermediate representations of the invertible flow, the authors argue that the model can produce smooth and interpretable domain transition trajectories without iterative inference. Experimental results on synthetic MNIST, Cityscapes, and brain MRI demonstrate competitive translation fidelity and inference efficiency compared to existing adversarial, diffusion, and flow-matching approaches, while maintaining exact invertibility in the latent space.
Critical strengths
- The proposed framework demonstrates competitive translation performance across three diverse datasets, including synthetic imaging, Cityscapes, and brain MRI. The deterministic inference and low computational cost also suggest practical advantages over iterative diffusion and flow-matching approaches.
Critical weaknesses
- The technical novelty of the proposed framework is limited. The core architecture, consisting of modality-specific encoders/decoders and an invertible latent flow, is already well established in prior work. Exact reversibility and single-pass inference are inherent properties of discrete normalizing flows rather than novel technical contributions. Therefore, the main methodological differences appear to be the proposed manifold-consistency and trajectory regularization losses.
- The paper lacks comparisons with closely related flow-based translation methods. While extensive comparisons are provided against diffusion and continuous flow-matching approaches, directly relevant normalizing-flow-based translation methods, such as AlignFlow [1], are missing. Given the substantial architectural similarities, these comparisons are essential to establish the actual methodological and empirical contributions of the proposed framework.
- The effectiveness of the proposed regularization losses is not convincingly demonstrated. In Table 2, removing TR actually improves 8 out of 12 reported SSIM/PSNR metrics. Furthermore, Appendix A indicates that both the manifold-consistency and trajectory-smoothness losses are disabled simultaneously in this ablation. Consequently, the individual contributions of these two regularization terms remain unclear. Considering that these losses constitute the main methodological additions, the lack of convincing empirical improvements significantly weakens the paper's technical contribution.
- The claimed interpretability and smoothness of the intrinsic trajectories are insufficiently validated. Intermediate states naturally exist in any multi-layer invertible flow, but their existence does not necessarily imply meaningful semantic interpolation. In Figure 4, particularly for Cityscapes, the decoded trajectories do not clearly exhibit smooth transitions between domains. Although the authors suggest a trade-off between translation fidelity and trajectory stability, no direct quantitative comparison between the regularized and unregularized trajectories is provided to support this claim.
[1] Grover et al., "AlignFlow: Cycle Consistent Learning from Multiple Domains via Normalizing Flows," AAAI, 2020.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors clarify the fundamental technical differences between FlowCycle and existing invertible flow-based translation frameworks, and provide comparisons with closely related methods such as AlignFlow?
- Could the authors provide independent ablations for the manifold-consistency and trajectory-smoothness losses? The current ablation disables both simultaneously, making it difficult to identify their respective contributions.
- Given that TR degrades most endpoint-fidelity metrics, could the authors provide quantitative evidence demonstrating the benefits of trajectory regularization, particularly regarding trajectory smoothness, semantic consistency, or topological stability?
- What evidence supports the interpretation of intermediate coupling states as meaningful domain transitions, rather than arbitrary intermediate representations of an invertible network?
6 comments
W3 / Q2 / Q3: Effect of the regularization losses.
Response. We thank the reviewer for asking what each regularization term contributes; the revision now makes this explicit. TR is designed for latent consistency and for the trajectory, not for endpoint fidelity, and it delivers both with endpoint fidelity essentially unchanged (SSIM differs by about 0.02 at most; Ours remains best or second-best in SSIM in all six directions of Table 2). The roles of its two terms follow from the round-trip decomposition (new Prop. 1, App. E), which separates them:
- L_lat is exactly the condition-(ii) term of the bound. Its effect is measured directly: the test residual of condition (ii) drops from ≈1 without TR to 0.10 / 0.57 / 0.35 on MNIST / Cityscapes / ADNI.
- L_traj acts only on the path between fixed endpoints and leaves the bound unchanged. Among the many flows with the same endpoints, it selects the one whose successive states change least, which is what makes the raw states progress toward the target (Figs. 9, 14).
Because the two terms act on different quantities, one on the latent residual and one on the path, their contributions are separable by construction, and each is measured on the quantity it acts on. [Revised: Table 2; Sec. 3.3; App. E, Prop. 1; App. C, D.]
W4 / Q4: Are the intermediate states meaningful transitions?
Response. We agree that the existence of states alone does not imply semantic interpolation, and have accordingly revised "interpretable" to "inspectable". What distinguishes the states of FlowCycle is measured rather than assumed: they are the operator's own states, both directions share them exactly (Table 4, Fig. 14), and they progress toward the target in the raw decoded images without any post-processing (Figs. 9, 14), unlike the oscillating states of RevGAN and the noise-like states of AlignFlow and diffusion (Figs. 10–12). For Cityscapes, Fig. 14 shows the raw Labels→Photo states, which change progressively toward the target scene. We will further validate their clinical meaning through biomarker annotation by medical experts along the trajectory and a test against real disease progression on longitudinal data. [Revised: Sec. 3.4; App. C, D; Sec. 5.]
We hope the added comparison and analysis clarify both the novelty and the role of the losses. If any concern remains, we would be glad to address it during the discussion phase, and we would be grateful if the reviewer would take the revision into account in the final assessment.
I thank the authors for their detailed responses and additional experiments. I consider W2 and W4 sufficiently addressed. While I remain unconvinced that the intermediate states represent semantically meaningful transitions, I acknowledge their visual coherence compared to the baselines and appreciate the clarification from "interpretable" to "inspectable."
Regarding W1 and W3, my main concern remains. FlowCycle shares the general encoder–invertible core–decoder structure with prior work such as RevGAN, which also supports paired translation. This makes empirical validation of the proposed regularization terms particularly important for establishing the methodological contribution.
I appreciate the additional analysis and clarifications, including that TR is not intended to improve endpoint fidelity. However, my central concern regarding W3 remains unresolved, as the requested independent ablations have not been provided. Specifically:
-
Latent consistency: The reported reduction in latent residuals is encouraging, but it remains unclear whether this translates into improved image-space cycle consistency without a direct with/without TR comparison.
-
Trajectory quality: The intermediate states appear visually coherent, but the effect of TR on trajectory smoothness or progression has not been isolated through a with/without TR comparison.
-
Independent contributions: Although the two losses target different quantities, they update shared parameters and may interact during optimization. Their mathematical distinction does not replace independent ablations of and .
Since these were central concerns in my original review and remain insufficiently addressed, I will maintain my original rating for now.
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading, and in particular for raising the comparison with flow-based translators, which led directly to the AlignFlow experiments now in Table 2 and Fig. 12. Table and section numbers refer to the revised PDF, where all changes are in red.
W1 / Q1: Limited novelty; differences from invertible flow-based translators.
Response. We thank the reviewer for the opportunity to clarify this. Exact invertibility is shared with normalizing flows, but FlowCycle is fundamentally different from AlignFlow and other flow-based translators in both the problem it solves and its mathematical structure:
Against a capacity-matched non-invertible bridge trained with the same losses, only FlowCycle keeps the latent round trip and the forward/return path exact, at no cost in fidelity (App. D, Table 4, Fig. 14). Table 1 summarizes these differences across all methods. [Revised: Sec. 1; Table 1; Sec. 3.3; App. D, E.]
W2: Comparison with AlignFlow.
Response. Thank you for this suggestion. Although AlignFlow targets a different, unpaired setting (W1), it is the closest flow-based translator, and the comparison makes the fundamental differences concrete. It is now in Table 2 under the same splits and protocol and in the property comparison of Table 1, and its native states are shown in new Fig. 12. For a comparison within the paired setting, Table 2 also includes the supervised pix2pix and per-direction U-Net baselines. It trails FlowCycle in all six directions (e.g. SSIM 0.17 vs. 0.71 on Photo→Labels, 0.49 vs. 0.75 on T1→FA), and its states pass through noise-like patterns of its Gaussian latent, whereas the states of FlowCycle progress toward the target. [Revised: Table 1; Table 2; App. C, Fig. 12.]