- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In this submission the authors propose Horizon, an FM algorithm that regresses onto an adapted version of the Wasserstein-Fisher-Rao equation -- the adaptation accounts for artifacts that distorts the alignment of temporally ordered spatial transcriptomics slides. Using closed-form WFR targets, the method can thus be trained efficiently and can be used to align temporally ordered ST sections. Using multiple datasets for evaluation, Horizon outperforms the baselines on temporal tissue reconstruction tasks.
Critical strengths
Relevance: As is clear not least from the references in the paper, studying WFR is currently of interest to the community (a missing reference to add evidence to the relevance of the topic is [1]), and flow matching models are increasingly being applied to spatial transcriptomics data (another missing reference in my opinion is [2], which to my knowledge is the first paper to apply FM to ST data. Thus, adapting the WFR equation to alignment of temporally evolved ST data is a highly relevant problem to solve.
Exposition and validation There are some non-crucial references missing in my opinion, but overall the landscape appears to have been quite extensively covered and sensible baselines are used in the experiments. Although I did not scrutinize the equations of the closed-form bridge in §4.2, I appreciate the inclusion of the equations in the main text.
[1] Ying et al., (2026) "Beyond Continuity: Simulation-free Reconstruction of Discrete Branching Dynamics from Single-cell Snapshots" [2] Kviman et al. (2026) "Multi-marginal flow matching with adversarially learnt interpolants"
Critical weaknesses
The only weakness I could identify was that the writing and presentation style was slightly on the opaque, jargon side. That is, there are multiple instances where I had some issues understanding or parsing sentences, which overall made it difficult to properly understand the proposed method. A way to circumvent this would be to give some examples and dummy down presentations. As an instance of where this would be nice, consider the transition from Eq. 1 to Eq. 2 in Sec. 3.2: ideally I would like to understand the difference between these two equations, but I am only provided with wordings such as orbits, rigid motions/frames. Surely the adaptation of Eq. 1 can be explained in practical, exemplifying terms. This would help the presentation of the paper.
Minor:
Comparing Eq 1 and 2, the got lost.
"SE" undefined in Sec. 3.2.
Questions for authors
What are the implications of the adaptation of the WFR in Eq. 2 vs. Eq. 1 in terms of runtime and implementation complexity?
Dear Reviewers,
Now that the authors have responded, please review what they have said and give consideration to whether they have adequately addressed your concerns.
-The AC