- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
NicheTime proposes a framework for modeling cellular microenvironment evolution using dual-scale optimal transport and pseudotime-guided graph flow matching. It extends niche-level OT with cell-level correspondence estimation and introduces a graph-based architecture that models cellular neighborhoods and developmental directionality. Experiments on three spatial transcriptomics datasets show improvements over NicheFlow on several metrics.
Critical strengths
- Biologically motivated optimal transport. The proposed dual-scale OT formulation is well motivated. Matching microenvironments first and then refining correspondences at the cellular level reflects the hierarchical organization of tissues. Semi-relaxed OT is also a sensible choice, as cellular populations change over time and strict source marginal constraints may be inappropriate. Table 2 provides a useful comparison of transport formulations with different marginal constraints at both scales.
- Explicit modeling of cellular neighborhoods. The PTG architecture incorporates spatial relationships between neighboring cells and uses pseudotime to guide directional message passing. These inductive biases are relevant for modeling tissue development, where local cellular interactions and developmental ordering matter. Tables 3 and 4 provide convincing ablations showing improvements in expression reconstruction over standard graph architectures and variants without pseudotime guidance.
Critical weaknesses
- The contribution of cell-level OT is not sufficiently isolated. The architectural ablations provide strong evidence for PTG, but Tables 1–4 do not evaluate PTG with niche-level OT alone. Consequently, it remains unclear how much the additional cell-level transport stage contributes to the reported improvements. This is an important missing comparison given that dual-scale OT is a central contribution of the paper.
- Unclear evaluation protocol and incomplete spatial evaluation. Appendix C defines the evaluation metrics but provides limited details about the held-out observations and whether evaluation is performed on individual microenvironments or complete tissue reconstructions. Furthermore, although PSD and SPD are reported for internal ablations, a direct comparison against NicheFlow is missing. This is particularly relevant because Figure 5 shows that PTG improves spatial precision but substantially reduces tissue coverage compared with standard graph architectures on ABD and MBA.
- Insufficient methodological details. The Post-GNN refinement used in the main experiments is not described in the main methodology, and its contribution is not isolated through an ablation. This makes it difficult to assess how much the refinement contributes to the reported improvements.
Questions for authors
- Contribution of cell-level OT. Could the authors provide an ablation retaining niche-level OT and the PTG architecture, but omitting the additional cell-level OT stage? For example, source and target cells could be sampled independently within matched niches rather than according to a cell-level transport plan, while retaining the same architecture and conditioning mechanism. This would help isolate the contribution of cell-level OT.
- Evaluation protocol and spatial reconstruction. Appendix C states that metrics are computed on held-out target snapshots using a shared OT matching protocol. Could the authors clarify which observations are used during training and which are held out for evaluation? How are generated microenvironments assembled into complete tissue predictions? Are MSE, MAE, and 1NN-F1 computed on complete reconstructed tissue slices or individual generated microenvironments? Could the authors also report PSD and SPD against NicheFlow and clarify whether the baseline was retrained or evaluated using existing checkpoints?
- Post-GNN refinement. Appendix F mentions Post-GNN refinement using a dynamic k-NN graph, and Table 9 indicates that it is enabled in the main experiments. Could the authors specify its architecture, neighborhood size, and graph-rebuilding frequency? Since this component is part of the final model, an ablation without Post-GNN refinement would help establish how much it contributes to the reported improvements.
2 comments
Thank you for the additional experiments and clarifications!
The new Tables 1 and 3 provide convincing evidence that both cell-level OT and the Post-GNN refinement contribute meaningfully to the overall improvements. I also appreciate the clarification of the evaluation protocol and the additional spatial comparison with NicheFlow.
Overall, I believe my main concerns have been addressed, and I have raised my score to 3.
Response to Reviewer McGN
We appreciate the reviewer's specific suggestions. The revised manuscript includes both requested component ablations and a direct spatial comparison with NicheFlow.
Cell-level OT ablation. Table 1 provides the requested controlled comparison between dual-scale OT and niche-only OT. Both variants retain niche-scale SemiOT, PTG, Post-GNN, and the same training settings; only the full model additionally enables cell-level SemiOT. On ABD, adding cell-level OT reduces MSE from 1.5989 to 1.4189 and increases 1NN-F1 from 0.4736 to 0.6659. All nine reported metric estimates favor the full model, although the magnitude of improvement varies across datasets. This supports a contribution from cell-level OT beyond niche-level alignment under the same graph architecture.
Evaluation and spatial reconstruction. Appendix C now clarifies the evaluation protocol. Training uses online spatially balanced niche sampling, whereas evaluation uses fixed grid centers. Both access the same observed snapshots, so the experiments assess observed-stage reconstruction rather than generalization to independently held-out tissues. At inference, target niche cardinality determines the generated cell count, but target expression and coordinates are not used as generator conditioning. MSE/MAE are computed index-wise without additional OT matching at evaluation time.
NicheFlow was trained from scratch on the same preprocessed datasets. Both methods share identical evaluation centers, generated cell counts, and metric implementations, while retaining model-specific training configurations. Spatial predictions are aggregated without deduplication; PSD uses the complete observed target snapshot as reference, whereas SPD uses observed evaluation-niche coordinates. Table 5 shows lower PSD for NicheTime on ABD and MBA, but higher SPD across all three datasets, indicating weaker coverage of the sampled evaluation niches.
Post-GNN refinement. Section 3.4 and Appendices F–G detail the one-layer Post-GNN with k=10 spatial neighbors and hidden dimension 128. The target-side backbone graph is refreshed every five Euler steps, whereas Post-GNN rebuilds its spatial graph from the current decoder predictions at each forward pass. Table 3 directly isolates the refinement effect: removing Post-GNN increases ABD MSE from 1.4189 to 1.5996 and reduces 1NN-F1 from 0.6659 to 0.4122. All nine reported metric estimates favor the inclusion of Post-GNN.