The following two points affect my soundness score, the third point concerns presentation and the last point concerns informativeness.
(1) Baselines I appreciate that the authors compare their NCA-based REGIS against multimarginal FM and SB methods in Sec. 3.1, but I am wondering what motivated the choice of MMSFM? The method does not appear to have strong results in its publication and is not standard. Two more natural competitors are either OT-CFM (Tong et al. (2024)) which is the go-to FM method, or the adversarial one referenced in your manuscript (Kviman et al. (2026)) as it shares the same marginal-distribution fitting engine. I am not saying that the results of the baselines would change drastically, but I believe that the choice requires a motivation.
(2) Interpolant vs. prior For transparency, I am not an expert on NCAs (the authors did a good job of introducing the methodology in Sec. 2.2, however). I was surprised that REGIS wasn't more extensively compared to the ALI-CFM multimarginal flow matching (MMFM) method (Kviman et al. (2026)). In the intro, the argumentation is that the choice of the interpolation scheme in MMFM methods bias the ability to study the underlying evolutionary system, but in a sense, an interpolant is a prior that can be corrected based on the observations in the marginals.
To make the statement that distances REGIS to MMFM more exact, I would thus use ALI-CFM to concretely explain how the methodologies differ. That is, I would use ALI-CFM as it also uses the adversarial objective. As the manuscript reads now, I find the distancing of REGIS from e.g. ALI-CFM hand-wavy -- yes, the learning frameworks are different, but what fundamentally separates these methods in terms of what you can infer from the learned dynamics? ALI-CFM doesn't interpolate between marginal samples, it fits a distribution of interpolants to the marginal distributions.
Computational burden A standard question when seeing a GAN-like method being proposed is of course wrt the hyperparameter tuning efforts required; do you need many to do hyperparameter sweeps to find a working parameterization? Although standard, I think addressing this is relevant.
A more critical and measurable question that has not been investigated in the paper is the complexity of using R3GAN. From my experience this GAN version is considerably slower to run and adds additional hyperparameters to tune. I think the following two studies are missing:
- An ablation where R3GAN is compared to the vanilla GAN in REGIS
- A computational complexity study of REGIS in contrast to it's competitors
(3) The experiment subsections and the learning rule There are a lot of analyses of the experimental results, which is positive of course, however I find the information difficult to parse as the text is rolled out at lengths without headings. I would suggest introducing some paragraph headings that capture what aspects of the experiment are discussed in that particular paragraph. This would improve the exposition of the paper.
Regarding the learning rule, this seemingly key object is discussed in the abstract and at multiple places in the text but I am still unsure exactly what it is. Is the learning rule Eq. (5)?
These two concerns render a lower presentation score.
(4) Informativeness This is probably my main concern sits. I agree with the narrative of the paper in terms of the need for methods to learn evolutionary dynamics and how priors are important to guide the learning. However, in the end I found all argumentation for REGIS as a superior approach to learning dynamics to be merely supported empirically.
There are indeed many experimental details provided from the three conducted experiments, but without a fundamental break-down of what REGIS is actually doing in contrast to, for example, multimarginal flow matching methods, I find the evidence supporting the method quite thin and ad hoc -- why is REGIS inherently a better option than the used baselines? Or, why is an MMFM method inherently not able to solve the experimental problems considered in the paper? Right now I read the results here as REGIS outperforming the implementations of MMSFM and MMtSBM etc., not the other methodologies.
This resonates with my earlier concerns, and is fixable by a more in-depth non-empirical comparison of the methodological differences, however the required work might be quite significant.
Minors:
Fig. 1 bottom left plot: the ∼pobs and "gen" are difficult to map to any shape in the figure. I.e. it is not clear what is simulated
from these distributions.
In line 189 xtbobs is simulated from ptb --- this seems to be inconsistent notation from the use of pobs in Fig. 1.
We thank the reviewer for the comments.
We agree that unpaired snapshots do not contain any information about the dependency structure in time. As the reviewer notes, a DDPM conditioned on time can reproduce and interpolate the marginals, but nothing in its training links samples at different times. Trajectories produced that way therefore wouldn’t capture the true underlying dynamics – as we showed for other transport-based baselines (MMSFM and MMtSBM). For clarity, the DDPM in our Ising comparison is a different model, conditioned on the previous state and trained on true pairs.
As the reviewer suspects, the temporal information in REGIS comes from the model’s formulation rather than from the data alone. There are two factors in play:
Empirically, this is sufficient for the problems we tested the framework on. In Ising model experiments, REGIS recovers spin-flip probabilities close to the simulator’s. In the zebrafish heart regeneration dataset, it reproduces known dependencies between cell types under knock-outs. Consistent with the intuition above, ablated models with relaxed constraints also fit the marginals but perform worse at recovering the mechanism.
We have added a paragraph at the end of section 2.3 to communicate this intuition more clearly.
“Note that observed and generated images are compared only at the distribution level, so the data do not specify which state at one time corresponds to which state at a later time. Many different trajectories are consistent with the observations. Restricting the generator to a single local, time-invariant rule that must reach every observed distribution through repeated application narrows this space to trajectories that such a rule can produce. Provided the true trajectory satisfies the chosen constraints and is thus retained while many alternatives are removed, recovering this trajectory from the observations becomes more likely.”
Regarding the bolding rule in Table 5: we bold all values where the mean absolute deviation from 1 (the ground truth value) across all seeds does not exceed 0.025. We have clarified this in the table legend.
Please let us know if we interpreted your concerns about the temporal dependencies correctly and whether our response addresses them.