- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors proposed a simulation-free method to handle both entering and existing in an unbalanced SB problem under killed BM reference with Poisson process on killing event. The main idea is to have a lifted cemetery state and reduce things to balanced SB with this somewhat data augmentation approach, and simulation free could be handled by properties of the BM reference.
Critical strengths
- There is no need to forward or backward simulate any SDEs during training.
- Handles entering and exiting naturally.
- Relatively well written
Critical weaknesses
I consider these not to be critical weakness for rejection but unidentified limitations worth discussing. All related to previously identified strengths.
- I think the simulation free nature relies on BM reference with homogeneous waiting time for killing event. It might be extended to linear reference though.
- I have a bit difficulty mapping entering and exiting to biological processes. See question for more details.
Questions for authors
- I suspect the method can be extended to handle linear drift in the reference. The difficulty is usually not the bridge conditioning on matched particles but solving the static coupling problem. This maybe done by things like Zhang et al. 2025. What do the authors think?
- Is a homogeneous exponential waiting time necessary? How much of the simulation-free nature relies on the existing having an exponential waiting time across all time? Is the exponential waiting time also needed so that time reversal makes physical sense?
- A subquestion is that I think the existing event have be memoryless (o.w. time reversal will definitely be problematic, as the particles will have to remember the future). Does this imply we can only do exponential waiting time?
- Re: exiting and entering. Unlike balanced SB, the method could have some particles from match with multiple particles in through branching or match to none of the particles through exiting, both handled in lifted, cemetery state. (Please correct me if I misunderstood this part). I can understand it mathematically but I have some difficulty mapping it back into biology: all the cells are different cells as they are killed to see what is inside. So matching is a modeling need, not what happened physically. How should we understand the entering and existing physically/biologically?
Zhang, S. and Stumpf, M., 2026. Learning non-equilibrium diffusions with schrödinger bridges: from exactly solvable to simulation-free. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 38, pp.119861-119898.