- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This is paper adds diffusionPDE with an additional dynamics guidance.
Critical strengths
The paper is easy to follow. The method is intuitive. The targeting problem is important for diffusion model.
Critical weaknesses
See questions.
Questions for authors
- If we are already able to train a dynamics model, why not just use this model to do generation/inpainting. Why using diffusion model?
- The method is slower than baselines methods because additional per-step gradient calculation. It also needs to train an additional model.
- The novalty is limited. It adds an extra guidance term in DiffusionPDE.
Response to Reviewer P69V
Thank you for raising the roles of the diffusion prior, computational overhead, and the relationship to DiffusionPDE.
1. Why use diffusion if a dynamics model is available?
A dynamics model predicts evolution from an initial state. Recovering that state from sparse observations across space and time is still an inverse problem that may be ambiguous, ill-conditioned, or difficult to optimize. The diffusion model supplies a learned prior over complete trajectories for this reconstruction problem.
We added a dynamics-only baseline with access to the true equations (Appendix D.3). A GP conditioned on the available context initializes the initial field, which is optimized through differentiable rollout to match the observations, with a spatial smoothness penalty.
In Table S10, the errors of this baseline are approximately 1.6 and 2.3 times those of DiffSINDy on Burgers with 2.5% and 5% context, respectively, and 3.0 times on KS with 5% context. However, the baseline fits the observed context points less closely on KS than on Burgers' equation. The results support the value of a learned trajectory prior relative to this dynamics-only baseline.
2. Computational overhead
We agree that DiffSINDy requires additional surrogate training and inference-time integration and differentiation. It is slower than observation-only DPS and the cheaper discrete-time guidance variants.
The diffusion model is trained once per dataset and reused across guidance methods; neural-surrogate methods also require an additional trained dynamics model, whereas DPS and the oracle variants do not. The method is most appropriate when improved physical consistency justifies this cost.
3. Relationship to DiffusionPDE and novelty
DiffusionPDE is an important related work, and we build on the established idea of guiding diffusion sampling with observations and dynamics constraints. However, we would like to point out that the distinction concerns both the information required to construct the dynamics guidance and how its consistency is evaluated.
DiffusionPDE constructs its physics guidance from a supplied PDE form, even if quantities like coefficient fields or initial conditions may remain unknown. In practice, DiffusionPDE typically assumes that the underlying PDE equations are known. In our setting, the governing operator is not supplied. Instead, we identify a (shared) PDE from training trajectories using SINDy within a predefined candidate library. The latter provides structural assumptions, but the active terms and their coefficients are learned from data.
Our contribution is to learn continuous-time dynamics using SINDy and guide reconstruction through a differentiable MoL solver. This enforces consistency between reconstructed snapshots without requiring temporal derivative estimates from sparsely sampled data.