- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose PhyDiM, a physics-guided diffusion model for continuous spatio-temporal LST reconstruction from sparse satellite observations. Physical priors are integrated into both the forward diffusion and reverse sampling processes. The method supports both temporal interpolation and extrapolation, enabling reconstruction at arbitrary target times. Experiments on MODIS LST datasets across three European regions demonstrate improved reconstruction performance over existing methods.
Critical strengths
1.Physical priors are integrated into both the forward diffusion and reverse sampling processes, improving reconstruction performance.
2.The conditional denoising architecture enable flexible reconstruction at arbitrary target times, supporting both temporal interpolation and extrapolation.
Critical weaknesses
1.The justification for adopting the heat equation to represent LST dynamics is insufficient. Moreover, the PDE parameters are empirically selected, raising concerns about the physical validity of the proposed PDE-based formulation.
2.The reason behind the PDE-based forward process in Eq. (5) is unclear. If the heat equation represents the actual LST dynamics, applying it to the temperature field at the target timestamp in fact advances the field by an additional , causing it to deviate from the target physical state.
3.The proposed method achieves modest improvements over standard DDPM, raising concerns about whether the additional complexity of the physics-guided components is justified.
4.The methodological novelty is limited, as the proposed framework largely combines existing diffusion modeling techniques with PDE-based smoothing and sampling guidance.
Questions for authors
The PDE-based operations in both the forward and reverse processes appear to primarily introduce spatial smoothing. Can the authors demonstrate that these operations provide physically meaningful benefits beyond conventional smoothing? Could alternative smoothing methods achieve similar improvements?
9 comments
Response to Reviewer uYEb (2/4)
Weakness 2: Clarification of the Physical-Time Advancement Introduced by the PDE-Based Forward Process
The evolution in Eq. (5) does not advance the target field in physical time. Rather, it acts along the diffusion (corruption) axis, indexed by , with pseudo-time . It is part of the corruption operator, in the same way as the Gaussian noise, and is not intended to model how LST evolves between satellite acquisition hours. Physical time is handled separately through conditioning on the acquisition hours and the target hour . To avoid confusion between these two notions of time, we now use exclusively for the diffusion timestep, for physical hours, and for the heat-equation pseudo-time.
The target physical state is not altered by this construction. The evolved field satisfies , meaning that the clean target corresponds to , whereas for represents an intermediate corrupted state, just as represents a noisy version of the target in a standard DDPM.
We acknowledge that the previous version of Algorithm 2 did not invert the forward heat evolution, resulting in an output that was one Euler step away from . This inconsistency was also raised by Reviewers GmWZ (Weakness 2) and W6p8 (Question 3). In the revised sampler, we apply the exact inverse heat operator at each reverse step, thereby preserving the forward marginals (see the revised Sec. 3.4 and the derivation in App. B). The final iterate therefore estimates , corresponding to the target physical state without any additional drift.
The motivation for this corruption process is that, unlike isotropic Gaussian noise, it degrades spatial structure in a coupled manner through the smoothing behavior of the heat operator. This encourages the denoiser to learn to reverse a structured degradation. Its benefit is supported empirically by the ablation results in Table 2.
Revised sampling procedure (Algorithm 2):
- Initialize the noisy field: .
- Compute the Fourier-domain heat operator: .
- For :
- Predict noise: .
- Estimate the physically evolved field: .
- Apply inverse heat evolution: .
- Compute the DDPM posterior variance: .
- Sample Gaussian noise: .
- Perform the reverse diffusion update: .
- Compute the physical constraint: .
- Apply physics guidance: .
- Return the reconstructed field: .
All PhyDiM results have been regenerated using the consistent sampler, including Table 1, the qualitative figures, the diurnal curves, and the appendix results. In the ablation study (Table 2), the previous sampler is retained as Config 3 (without the inverse heat operator), while the new sampler is reported in the last row. The gains over DDPM have increased. Averaged across regions, PhyDiM now improves RMSE by 4.53% and SSIM by 20.47%, compared with the previous improvements of 2.1% and 12%, respectively. The abstract and conclusion have also been updated accordingly. We will also update the associated code to reflect these corrections in the camera-ready version, if accepted.
Response to Reviewer uYEb (3/4)
Weakness 3: Performance Improvements and Computational Overhead of the Physics-Guided Components
We believe this weakness is partially addressed by the revised physics-guided sampling procedure, as suggested by the reviewers. With the revised sampler, PhyDiM improves over DDPM by an average of 4.53% in RMSE and 20.47% in SSIM, compared to 2.1% and 12% with the previous sampler. The gains increase in all three ROIs. For example, the SSIM gains over DDPM at - rise from 7.32%, 14.55%, 11.67%, 13.33% to 26.32%, 25.45%, 18.33%, 26.67% in ROI$_1$, from 8.51%, 5.80%, 7.25%, 12.77% to 19.15%, 13.04%, 11.59%, 23.40% in ROI$_2$, and from 15.15%, 12.50%, 11.67%, 12.90% to 30.30%, 21.43%, 20.00%, 19.35% in ROI$_3$. RMSE improves in every setting except in ROI$_1$ and ROI$_2$, where DDPM remains slightly better (the gap narrows from 0.07 to 0.06 in ROI$_1$ and from 0.07 to 0.02 in ROI$_2$).
Regarding computational complexity, PhyDiM adds an average of only 1.19 s to standard DDPM inference (3.93s vs. 2.74s, see the ablation study in Sec. 4.4). To quantify this trade-off, we define the gain efficiency as the relative improvement over DDPM (%) divided by the additional inference time (s). For PhyDiM, the 4.53% RMSE reduction and 20.47% SSIM improvement correspond to gain efficiencies of approximately and % per second, respectively. In other words, each additional second of inference yields, on average, an approximately 3.8% reduction in RMSE and a 17.2% improvement in SSIM relative to DDPM. This analysis has been added to the ablation study in Sec. 4.4.
Weakness 4: Methodological Novelty
PhyDiM does use known building blocks (DDPM, the heat equation). Our contribution lies in how physical information is incorporated into the diffusion process, which distinguishes PhyDiM from existing physics-informed diffusion models in three main aspects.
-
First, existing physics-informed diffusion models, such as [4], incorporate PDE residuals as training losses, while DiffusionPDE [5] uses PDE-residual guidance during sampling. In both approaches, the forward corruption process remains standard (We have expanded the comparison with these methods and clarified the methodological novelty of PhyDiM in the third paragraph of the Introduction). In contrast, PhyDiM modifies the corruption operator itself, , so that the denoiser learns to reverse a spatially coupled and structured degradation. This modification leaves the standard noise-prediction objective unchanged, as shown in Appendix A, and avoids introducing additional physics-based training losses and their associated loss-balancing requirements. Moreover, this formulation is independent of the denoiser architecture and can be used with different denoising networks.
-
Second, modifying the forward process requires a mathematically consistent reverse process, which cannot be obtained simply by combining existing components. As highlighted by the reviewers' comments on the reverse transition, a standard DDPM reverse step is not consistent with the time-dependent heat evolution introduced in the forward process. We therefore derive a reverse update that applies the exact inverse of the discretized heat operator, implemented as element-wise division in the Fourier domain (Appendix B), while preserving the forward marginals. We further provide a theoretical analysis of the physics-guidance step in Appendix C. The ablation study in Table 2 isolates the contributions of the different components and shows that the full model improves over the variants.
-
Third, we design a conditional multi-temporal architecture that maps three acquisitions and a continuous target hour to the field at that hour. It handles both interpolation and extrapolation, which goes beyond standard video frame interpolation and is important for real-world monitoring of the spatio-temporal evolution of image sequences. We evaluate it on LST, and the framework can be adapted to other systems by replacing the heat equation with a PDE whose discretized step is invertible (Algorithms 1 and 2).
[4] Jan-Hendrik Bastek, WaiChing Sun, and Dennis Kochmann. Physics-informed diffusion models. In International Conference on Learning Representations, volume 2025, pp. 3360–3385, 2025.
[5] Huang, Jiahe, et al. Diffusionpde: Generative pde-solving under partial observation. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 37 (2024): 130291-130323.
Response to Reviewer uYEb (1/4)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful assessment of our manuscript and the constructive feedback.
We would like to highlight that Weakness 2, which was also raised as Weakness 2 by Reviewer GmWZ and Question 3 by Reviewer W6p8, identified an important methodological concern regarding the reverse sampling process. Addressing this issue strengthened the theoretical validity of the reverse transition and improved PhyDiM's performance over DDPM in both RMSE and SSIM (see our response to Weakness 3). Accordingly, we report the updated results throughout our responses. For ease of navigation, all text added to the revised manuscript has been highlighted in red.
Weakness 1: Physical Relevance of the Heat Equation to LST Dynamics
We clarify that the heat equation is not intended to capture the full dynamics of LST. A complete surface energy balance involves processes such as radiation, soil moisture, thermal inertia, and turbulent heat fluxes, which cannot be fully characterized using the MODIS observations available at inference time. Incorporating these processes would require additional parameters and input variables that may not be observable. We therefore adopt spatial heat diffusion as a simplified physical prior, since it operates directly on the observed temperature field and requires only a single effective diffusion coefficient.
This choice is motivated by three considerations. First, heat diffusion is a physical mechanism that smooths spatial temperature gradients at the surface and has been used in LST modeling [1]. Second, LST fields show spatial structures, including coherent warm and cold regions with smooth transitions, that the heat operator helps preserve while attenuating high-frequency variations [2]. Third, MODIS LST retrievals have errors of approximately 2∘C [3]. A prior that suppresses potentially non-physical high-frequency fluctuations while preserving large-scale spatial patterns is therefore well suited to these data. The aspects of LST dynamics not captured by the heat equation, particularly diurnal forcing, are not imposed by the physical prior but are learned by the denoiser network. We have revised the text accordingly in Sec. 3.2.
Regarding the PDE parameters (we changed the notation from t to τ following the remark of Reviewer W6p8 to avoid confusion with the diffusion timestep t), κ and Δτ cannot be independently determined for each pixel from satellite imagery, as they depend on ground thermal properties that are not directly observed. We therefore treat their product, κΔτ, as a single effective diffusion strength and select its value using the validation set (Sec. 4.4). The case κΔτ=0 corresponds to Config. 2, which obtains an RMSE of 1.82 and an SSIM of 0.56 on ROI$_1$, compared with 1.78 and 0.61 for PhyDiM at κΔτ=2×10−4, showing that heat evolution brings a measurable gain over the no-physics case.
The table below presents a comparison between Config. 2 and PhyDiM for ROI$_1$. For the full ablation comparison, including the other configurations, please refer to Table 2 in Sec. 4.4:
[1] Saeid Asadzadeh and Carlos Roberto Souza Filho. Numerical modeling of land surface temperature over complex geologic terrains: A remote sensing approach. Remote Sensing, 15(19):4877, 2023.
[2] Song, J., Du, S., Feng, X., & Guo, L. (2014). The relationships between landscape compositions and land surface temperature: Quantifying their resolution sensitivity with spatial regression models. Landscape and urban planning, 123, 145-157.
[3] Si-Bo Duan, Zhao-Liang Li, Hua Li, Frank-M Gottsche, Hua Wu, Wei Zhao, Pei Leng, Xia Zhang, and Cesar Coll. Validation of collection 6 modis land surface temperature product using in situ measurements. Remote sensing of environment, 225:16–29, 2019.