- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Numerically Calibrated Physics Guidance (NCPG) to address the, possible, mismatch between a diffusion prior's training data and some physics guidance.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
I have to emphasize that this paper is poorly written with unnecessary complications (e.g., "numerical realization" for "discretization", "numerical provenance" for "data-generating numerical method", etc.). This makes reading and assessing the paper and its contributions difficult.
Other major issues:
- The setting is poorly motivated. The paper does not discuss when one might have access to a diffusion prior, its training data, the PDE, but not able to sample the entire observation during inference. Also, if the PDE is known, then one can generate their own training data and diffusion prior so there should never be a "mismatch."
- The paper assumes that the training data is ground truth--this assumption does not hold in many cases.
- There are many missing details of the method and the implementation, and without these details (or code), I cannot adequately evaluate some of the results. For example, how long was the diffusion prior trained for? Currently, the results point towards the diffusion prior being poorly trained (Table 1 shows the ""no-physics" model scores a ~30-70% error for the only non-linear PDE).
- There are no baselines from prior work. I would expect that the paper would include at least one baseline like DiffusionPDE, showing the problem and their proposed solution.
Questions for authors
Can you include one baseline from prior work, e.g., DiffusionPDE, and show the mismatch problem and whether NCPG fixes it?