- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Diffusion Waltz (DW), an MCMC framework for Bayesian inverse problems with learned diffusion or flow-matching priors. Its basic proposal combines forward noising with conditional denoising and uses a Metropolis–Hastings correction that does not require evaluating the prior density. With an exact, compatible conditional denoiser, the proposal is prior-reversible; in the Gaussian mirror setting, it recovers preconditioned Crank–Nicolson. Evaluation includes checkerboard and Gaussian-process examples, Navier–Stokes and Darcy inverse problems, and hierarchical 3D inverse design.
Critical strengths
-
A coherent prior-density-free sampling framework. The prior-reversibility construction and the auxiliary-variable correction for conditional noising provide a useful mechanism for posterior sampling with implicit generative priors. The explicit pCN connection clarifies the method’s relationship to established Bayesian sampling algorithms.
-
Meaningful controlled validation and relevant scientific applications. The exact-denoiser Gaussian-process experiment provides a valuable check of the ideal conditional-noising construction, including comparison with an analytically available posterior. The nonlinear PDE and 3D applications address practically relevant settings, including derivative-free inference and hierarchical generation.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient qualification of the denoising construction and endpoint treatment. Proposition 1 specifies a particular SDE realization of , not a unique conditional-sampling algorithm; the subsequent uniqueness claim therefore needs a precise scope. The treatment of the inner reverse process at zero noise, including any cutoff or final denoising step, is also unclear; clipping the outer noising level does not resolve this issue.
-
Strong assumptions and unclear practical applicability of Theorem 2. The informal statement does not adequately convey the restrictive assumptions in Appendix B.2, particularly full-support positive densities, the strict condition , far-field rejection control, and uniform control of averaged denoising errors. Their applicability to the learned priors and experiments is not established. The authors should align the two statements and provide verifiable sufficient conditions, while clarifying that fixed nonzero denoising error leaves a residual perturbation term rather than guaranteeing exact posterior recovery.
-
Insufficient support for the mixing advantage of conditional noising. Section 3.2 motivates observation-informed proposals, but faster reduction of data misfit does not establish faster posterior mixing. There is no mixing-rate improvement or a corresponding perturbation bound for the evaluated conditional-noising algorithms. In particular, the acknowledged EKCN interaction bias and adaptive updates are not covered by the fixed-RWMH analysis. More convincing evidence of posterior exploration under matched computational budgets is needed.
-
Insufficient differentiation from existing posterior samplers. Remark 1 and Section 4 acknowledge DAPS, PnP/split-Gibbs methods, and concurrent noising–denoising proposals, but the comparison remains too qualitative to assess incremental novelty. The paper should distinguish their target distributions, observation-conditioning mechanisms, correction steps, residual approximation biases, and computational requirements. Without this comparison, it is difficult to separate new contributions from mechanisms already used in related conditional-sampling frameworks.
-
Limited empirical support for generality and practical advantage. Both PDE evaluations use only five test cases, while the 3D distributional metrics assess mass rather than the full geometry posterior. The absence of standard image inverse-problem evaluations using pretrained priors on datasets such as FFHQ or ImageNet also leaves broader applicability insufficiently tested. Additional validation or appropriately narrower claims would strengthen the empirical conclusions.
Questions for authors
See Critical Weaknesses
Dear Reviewer X6AT,
We greatly appreciate the reviewer's time and constructive feedbacks that have significantly improved the quality of the paper. During the discussion period, we have continued to strengthen the paper in our updated manuscript with new results that we believe addresses most of the reviewer's concerns. This includes:
Considering these additions, we kindly ask whether you might consider revisiting your score. If any concerns remain, we would be happy to address them in the remaining time.
Best regards,
The Authors