- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces TP-DATE, which incorporates pairwise structure into continuous transport paths and uses analytical paths for flow matching training. I find this a promising and useful approach. The rotation experiments clearly illustrate the motivation, while the theoretical development and scalable implementation give the method substance. My overall impression is positive, and I would welcome clarification on the scope of the theoretical guarantees and the interpretation of the empirical results.
Critical strengths
1.The rotation experiments make the motivation easy to understand and clearly demonstrate why intermediate paths matter for preserving structure.
2.The analytical paths directly provide position and velocity targets, making them a practical contribution. Comparing different paths under the same coupling also helps isolate the contribution of path design.
Critical weaknesses
1.The connection between the theory and the final implementation remains somewhat unclear. The experiments learn a single-particle velocity field, which the paper acknowledges cannot generally recover the full two-particle dynamics. I would appreciate clarification on which structural and action guarantees carry over to the generated trajectories.
2.The experiments leave the broader applicability uncertain. The synthetic tasks focus on rigid rotation, and each real dataset mainly tests one held-out snapshot. Additional nonrigid transformations and held-out positions would help establish when the structural prior is beneficial and how far the trajectory and 3D reconstruction claims extend.
3.One aspect of the path ablation deserves further explanation. Under the reported weights, the conditional paths for Mouse Brain and ARTISTA appear close to straight lines, yet some expression metrics improve noticeably. Could the authors clarify how the weights enter the implementation and how the resulting supervision differences explain these gains?
4.The efficiency results are encouraging, but the comparison protocol needs clarification. Please specify which stages are included in the timing and report the training budgets for all methods. This would help readers assess the practical computational cost.
Questions for authors
1.Which pairwise structural guarantees remain valid for the single-particle implementation, and how does it relate to the BB optimum?
2.Do the gains remain consistent across additional held-out positions and nonrigid transformations?
3.How different are the position and velocity targets from those of straight paths, and can these differences explain the ablation gains?
4.Does the timing include graph construction and coupling optimization, and are the training budgets comparable across methods?
Thank you for the rebuttal and substantial revisions. I appreciate the authors' efforts in addressing my concerns through additional experiments, clearer theoretical explanations, and more detailed implementation analyses. These additions strengthen the empirical evidence and help clarify the scope and practical significance of the proposed framework. While some aspects could still benefit from further discussion, I consider my main concerns to have been satisfactorily addressed. Overall, I remain positive about the theoretical and methodological contributions of this work and will maintain my original rating of 3.