- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2(−1)
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies how to relate an imperfect numerical model F to the system it describes, M, when the two are observed only through unpaired trajectories and settle on different invariant measures µ_X and µ_Y. The authors seek a map T that transports µ_X onto µ_Y and approximately commutes with the dynamics, T ∘ F ≈ M ∘ T. When the commutation is exact and T is invertible, T is a conjugacy.
They define a discrepancy D_Ω: the smallest commutation residual achievable by a measure-transporting map in an admissible class Ω. Ω = {Id} recovers the direct forecast error, and richer classes forgive coordinate changes. Their main technical step (Prop. 1) bounds the map-dependent residual by a pairwise cost that does not depend on T: c(x, y) = ‖Ψ(y) − GΨ(x)‖ + ‖Ψ(My) − GΨ(Fx)‖, where Ψ is a feature dictionary and G is a feature-space alignment. Minimizing this bound over couplings is a linear OT problem. G is learned from unpaired transitions with "intertwining EDMD" (iEDMD), which sets K_U = G⁻¹K_V G and fits each system to its own transitions, plus an MMD penalty. Minibatch Sinkhorn plans under this cost supervise simulation-free Flow Matching. The learned map is used for transport–solve–transport forecasting, T(F_t(T⁻¹y₀)), around an unchanged solver.
Experiments cover Lorenz-63, Chen, Rössler and Lorenz-96 pairs under parameter shifts and/or constructed coordinate deformations, cylinder-wake and fluidic-pinball flows with separate POD bases, and a full-state to delay-embedding transport. The iEDMD coupling reduces conjugation error by 43–62% relative to Euclidean OT on deformed ODE pairs and by 32–74% on fluids. It gives little or no gain, and sometimes harm, when coordinates are shared.
Critical strengths
-
Removing the cost of enforcing dynamical consistency. Enforcing T ∘ F ≈ M ∘ T directly requires integrating and differentiating through the learned transport. Proposition 1 replaces this with a pairwise cost evaluated on recorded states and their successors (or reduced-model predictions, in the operator form), so that minimizing an upper bound on the residual becomes a linear OT problem and Flow Matching stays simulation-free. The two-sided result in Prop. 3 (cross-moment lower bound, successor-cost upper bound) is a helpful certificate. The reported diagnostic places learned-map residuals between the two bounds on all thirteen ODE pairs.
-
A useful conceptual reframing. The discrepancy D_Ω, with Ω = {Id} recovering ordinary forecast error, makes precise the idea that a model with poor direct forecasts can still be close to the observed system once its states are correctly identified. Figure 1 illustrates this cleanly: under an exact nonlinear conjugacy, direct error and W₂ grow while the residual over residual MLPs stays at the fitting floor. A genuine change of dynamics (ρ from 28 to 40) raises it.
-
Learning the alignment without pairs. Defining K_U := G⁻¹K_V G builds the intertwining relation into the parameterization, so G can be learned from each system's own transitions without any correspondence. This is a sensible extension of EDMD to two systems.
-
The paper explicitly reports cases where transport hurts (Lorenz-96, native Rössler, longer-horizon parametric wake) and where simpler maps win (affine on Chen b, GW + Procrustes on pure rotation).
-
On the structural wake, where the source misplaces the cylinder by two diameters and the POD bases are unregistered, conjugated forecasting reduces quarter-period error from 0.325 (true state in the wrong model) to 0.074. Euclidean coupling visibly fails: its conjugation error is 0.441 vs. 0.114 for iEDMD (Fig. 2), and its pushforward contracts inside the target cycle (Fig. 4).
Critical weaknesses
1. The contribution of the dynamical (successor) term is not isolated. The paper's central claim is that pairing by dynamical compatibility, not proximity, drives the gains. The cost has two parts: an endpoint term ‖Ψ(y) − GΨ(x)‖ (OT in G-aligned coordinates) and a successor term ‖Ψ(My) − GΨ(Fx)‖. The paper's own evidence suggests much of the gain may come from the learned alignment G rather than from the successor term: i) On ring-deformed Lorenz-96, K = 1 orbit coupling (no successor term) gives 3.892 vs. 3.883 for the full statewise cost. The authors state there is no measurable contribution from the successor term on this pair. ii) On the structural wake, adding raw successors to the Euclidean cost barely changes the result (0.441 → 0.429), while a learned linear intertwiner recovers about a third of the gap (0.305).
An ablation of endpoint-only cost vs. full cost, with the same G, on all ODE and fluid pairs is necessary. Without it, the method may be mostly "learn a nonlinear alignment, then do Euclidean OT in aligned space." That is a substantially weaker claim than the one made.
2. Missing related work and baselines on OT with transformation invariances. Aligning unpaired point clouds up to a transformation class is an established problem (https://arxiv.org/abs/1806.09277, https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.11222, https://proceedings.mlr.press/v97/bunne19a.html). Structurally, D_Ω is the same kind of object, a minimum over transformations in a class jointly with a marginal-respecting coupling (cf. Eq. 21), but with a dynamical residual in place of a geometric cost. None of these works are cited or compared. The paper does show that geometric invariance is insufficient under nonlinear deformations: GW recovers only 14% of the known correspondence, and FM trained on GW plans reaches 9.02 vs. 0.87 for oracle pairs. However, the only invariance-based baselines are GW and rigid Procrustes alignment, which are mismatched to nonlinear deformations by construction.
3. Baselines are weakest where the method wins. The headline gains (43–62% on deformed ODEs, 32–74% on fluids) are relative to Euclidean OT in unregistered coordinates, where proximity is meaningless by construction. Euclidean coupling sometimes performs worse than random pairing. The dynamical-systems literature the paper cites offers stronger natural comparisons that are not evaluated (https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/17M116207X, https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-01228-1_8).
In addition, on the wakes the Euclidean baseline uses ε = 0.5 × median cost, while iEDMD uses ε = 0.02 × mean cost. The authors partly control for this (iEDMD at the matched scale gives 0.161 vs. 0.441), but the main table should use a common protocol.
4. Coupling-only training is not the strongest variant, and the simulation-free benefit is not quantified. On deformed Lorenz-63, random pairing with the cost used as a generated-state penalty beats coupling-only iEDMD (2.06 vs. 2.995). The solver-in-the-loop reference is better still on most pairs (Table 11). The case for the coupling therefore rests on the training-cost savings of staying simulation-free, but beyond a qualitative count of integrations per regularized batch, the paper does not compare wall-clock or compute costs of coupling-only, penalized, and solver-in-the-loop training.
5. Evaluation is restricted to constructed, noise-free settings. The motivation is a model compared with real observations: noisy, partial, short records, and unknown observation operators (Gulf Stream separation, initialization shocks). All experiments are noise-free. The limitations section acknowledges this, but at least one experiment with observation noise or short records would substantially strengthen the claims.
6. The forecasting comparison omits standard alternatives. The only non-transport baseline is the true state fed into the wrong model, plus nearest-neighbour and known-translation controls on one wake. Learned model-error correction (https://rmets.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/qj.4116) and simple statistical bias correction are natural competitors for "making an imperfect model more useful," and neither is evaluated. As the authors acknowledge, transport also degrades accurate models (Lorenz-96: 0.488 direct vs. 1.230 conjugated; native Rössler a: 0.070 vs. 0.131; parametric wake: 0.118 vs. 0.204 at 1T).
Questions for authors
Please see "Critical Weaknesses" section of the review above. The paper is interesting and approaches the problem in a different way. I am keen to see the authors' response and am eager to revise my rating if the response addresses all my concerns.
We thank the three reviewers for their time and their comments. the revised manuscript is now uploaded and we answered each of you in your own thread, so this message is only a short summary.
what the paper does. to our knowledge it is the first work that turns the dynamical alignment of two systems, known only through unpaired trajectories, into a pairwise optimal transport cost. compared with a standard Flow Matching training it adds a single stage: we train an iEDMD model, and its cost gives the coupling through a linear transport problem. Training stays simulation-free, and since the dynamics sit in the coupling and not in the loss, Flow Matching keeps its original objective (Lipman et al., 2023), so the marginals are transported as usual.
positioning. the paper is first of all about measure transport: mapping the invariant measure of a model onto that of the observed system, without pairs, as in unpaired domain translation. generative transport methods (Flow Matching, OT-CFM) and OT with invariances do transport the measure, but they pair states by geometric proximity. the conjugacy methods cited in the reviews go the other way: they align the dynamics with a prototype system, from a trajectory residual or from velocities, and their objective is that residual, not the transport of a measure. similarity scores such as DSA compare dynamics but return no map. we do both at once: the measure is transported exactly as in Flow Matching, and the dynamical alignment enters through the transport cost.
update of the manuscript. most of your points led to new experiments, now in appendices J to O (direct minimisation of the residual, invariant structures, ablation of the cost, noise and short records, compute cost). several answers were already in the submitted appendices and are now pointed to from the main text. as announced to reviewers Mdmh and RDme we also added a realistic experiment (Sec. 4.3): a quasi-geostrophic model of the north atlantic against a finer one observed only through its sea surface height, where the iEDMD coupling still improves on a euclidean coupling defined on the same physical field.
we believe the revised manuscript addresses the main concerns, and we invite you to have a look at it and to reconsider your assessment. thanks again.