- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper extends convergent cross mapping (CCM) from dynamical and geometric perspectives. While conventional CCM infers causal relationships through directional predictive skill, this paper introduces an aligned stable dynamical factor as its central concept. The main idea is that, when a smaller system () drives a larger system (), the latter should not only predict the former but also consistently represent its dynamical evolution.
The proposed aligned stable-factor relation is formalized in Definition 4.3. It requires dynamics compatibility between two systems through a factor map satisfying this condition. Under appropriate submersion/constant-rank assumptions, the tangent space naturally decomposes into the kernel/vertical directions (which do not change the factor state to first order) and their orthogonal complement, the horizontal directions (which change ). The authors focus on defining a stable dynamical factor map by constraining the horizontal mapping to be neither excessively contractive nor expansive (horizontal geometric stability).
The existence of such a stable factor map indicates directional dynamical information containment, which can be interpreted as causal ancestry under additional structural assumptions. As in conventional CCM, the framework operates on delay-reconstructed state spaces, with observationally indistinguishable latent states identified through observable quotients.
For implementation, the authors propose two estimators: Atlas GCCM-BCD and Neural GCCM. Their objectives incorporate required state alignment, dynamical compatibility, and additional geometric regularizers for the stable-factor relation. Several synthetic experiments are presented to evaluate factor recovery, directional identification, and robustness.
Critical strengths
The paper makes an interesting attempt to incorporate dynamical and geometric structures into CCM. Although related ideas have been explored in previous work (please see Q5), this paper provides a particularly detailed geometric formulation, such as the vertical-horizontal decomposition. I find this decomposition of the factor map particularly insightful, as it provides a geometric perspective on distinguishing dynamically preserved information from directions eliminated by the projection. This framework could serve as a foundation for further geometric investigations into the relationships between dynamical systems.
Critical weaknesses
W1. I believe the Introduction would benefit from a more reader-friendly and motivating explanation. Currently, the Introduction focuses more on describing what the authors have done than on explaining what problems they aim to solve, presenting their contributions through highly technical terminology. This makes it difficult for readers to understand the motivation behind the work. Even after carefully reading the paper and revisiting the Introduction, I still find it too condensed and abstract, particularly for material presented on the very first page. Similarly, the related work section mainly lists previous studies without clearly discussing what existing methods have achieved and what limitations remain. As a result, it is difficult to understand the specific gap this work aims to address and its main contributions.
W2. The paper does not adequately discuss or compare several closely related CCM-based methods, particularly those incorporating dynamical and geometric structures (please see Q4 and Q5). Although the proposed geometric formulation is elaborate, it remains unclear whether these additional structures are necessary or provide substantial advantages over existing methods. Without appropriate comparisons and ablation studies, it is difficult to evaluate the practical significance of the proposed framework.
Questions for authors
Q1. It seems that the horizontal stability is one of the notable contributions of this paper; I have two questions regarding its practical significance:
Q1-1. Under the submersion assumption, the horizontal singular values are already positive and finite pointwise. What additional practical benefits arise from explicitly controlling these bounds? Specifically, could the authors provide empirical evidence that better horizontal conditioning of the factor map improves the identifiability of the dynamical relationship, or at least the accuracy of factor map reconstruction, as motivated by Theorem 6.1?
Q1-2. How can the appropriate lower and upper bounds ( and in Eq. 16) be determined in practice? Are there theoretical or algorithmic procedures for estimating these bounds?
Q2. How does the choice of metric and horizontal connection affect the proposed framework? The horizontal subspace is defined as the -orthogonal complement of the vertical subspace, with the metric currently chosen as Euclidean in delay coordinates. How sensitive is the proposed method to this choice? More generally, any complementary subspace to the vertical distribution can define a horizontal distribution, corresponding to a choice of Ehresmann connection. Is there a particular theoretical reason to prefer the metric-orthogonal connection? Does this choice provide any specific advantage for identifying dynamical factor relations?
Q3. It seems that the tangent identity in Eq. 17 appears to be the differential counterpart of the dynamical compatibility condition in Definition 4.3. Thus, the tangent loss and dynamical compatibility loss appear to enforce closely related constraints at different implementation levels. Is there a particular reason for including both losses?
Q4. What practical advantages does the proposed framework provide over conventional CCM? I may be overlooking relevant results, as I am not an expert in CCM. However, the current experiments do not seem to clearly demonstrate the motivating case: where conventional CCM produces incorrect causal predictions due to its reliance on predictive skill, while the proposed framework successfully identifies the correct relationship owing to the additional geometric structure. Most experiments appear to focus on characterizing the behavior of the proposed methods on selected dynamical systems. Direct comparisons with conventional CCM and recent CCM-based methods would substantially strengthen the paper's main motivation.
Q5. Two particularly relevant papers [1, 2] appear to be missing from the discussion or experimental comparisons. First, Latent CCM [1] combines CCM with latent neural ODEs for causal discovery, making it closely related to the proposed framework.
More importantly, Tangent Space Causal Inference (TSCI) [2] shares a substantial part of the paper's central motivation: improving CCM by explicitly incorporating dynamical structure. In particular, TSCI uses a pushforward relation between vector fields, which can be understood as the infinitesimal form of flow semiconjugacy; the dynamical compatibility condition used in the present paper can be understood as the discrete version of flow semiconjugacy. Thus, both methods essentially exploit the same underlying dynamical compatibility principle, although the present paper additionally introduces vertical-horizontal structures and corresponding stability conditions.
Therefore, I believe a more detailed discussion of these connections, especially with TSCI, is essential to clarify the novelty of the proposed framework. A direct experimental comparison would also help establish whether the additional geometric constraints provide meaningful advantages beyond existing geometric methods.
[1] De Brouwer, E., Arany, A., Simm, J., & Moreau, Y. (2020). Latent convergent cross mapping. In International Conference on Learning Representations.
[2] Butler, K., Waxman, D., & Djurić, P. M. (2024). Tangent space causal inference: Leveraging vector fields for causal discovery in dynamical systems. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 37, 120078-120102.
Minor comment: Author-defined acronyms, such as Atlas-GCCM-BCD, frequently appear without being defined. Please spell out each acronym upon its first occurrence.
Response to Reviewer ahfJ
Thank you. We rewrote the motivation and now foreground two controlled diagnostic findings while directly testing the structural terms.
Two nonlinear factors, strong paired/kernel baselines, matched 8000-update training, and a disclosed post-hoc matched-16000 check show no consistent structural-loss advantage. Full and No-geometry nearly coincide. We do not establish that enforcing better horizontal conditioning improves identification or recovery.
The fixed-library CCM-style diagnostic attains reverse rho≈1 and NRMSE≈.002 at L=768 on the clean double cover although no global inverse factor exists (Appendix N.4). This illustrates prediction versus factor existence; it is neither a full CCM causal benchmark nor a demonstrated GCCM correction.
TSCI and related methods (Q5; Related Work, Appendix O). We explicitly acknowledge that TSCI shares dynamical intertwining, Jacobian pushforward, and non-invertible cross-maps. Its default official-style forward cosines are .9748/.9339 clean and .9444/.9027 noisy; Neural scores are higher, but paired regression matches Full. Official-style TSCI uses the paired query target to estimate its Jacobian. The train-only adaptation above is separately labeled, not evidence that the official estimator fails at factor recovery. Latent CCM is discussed but was not experimentally run.
Bounds and metric (Q1-Q2; Proposition M.1, Appendix A.3). A C1 submersion on a compact source with smooth source and target metrics already has uniform positive/finite horizontal bounds; their existence is not new. Our quantitative margin specifies tolerated derivative error. Training endpoints m0=.05 and M0=20 are heuristic soft barriers, not estimates of true bounds; we establish no calibrated procedure for selecting them. Given the source metric, the orthogonal lift is the unique minimum-norm preimage. Transporting both metrics preserves coordinate invariance. We establish neither an identification advantage of this connection nor robustness to changing the metrics.
Two compatibility losses (Q3; Table 1). The tangent identity differentiates semiconjugacy, but finite value fitting need not recover derivatives. This motivates separate diagnostics; the ablations do not establish universal necessity or superiority of both penalties.