- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 3(+1)
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the problem of identifying the structural roles of latent factors in dynamical systems. A central difficulty is the correspondence problem: the relevant structural components can be recovered only up to an arbitrary permutation of the latent coordinates, precluding unambiguous role assignment without an explicit alignment procedure. The authors establish the joint identifiability of the three roles up to a shared permutation at each time step, contingent on specified structural assumptions and variability conditions. They subsequently propose ROLETRACE, a method for role estimation that leverages Jacobian and cross-Hessian derivatives of an encoder–decoder architecture, and evaluate its performance on both synthetic benchmarks and the AMI meeting corpus.
Critical strengths
-
The paper tackles a well-motivated and comparatively underexplored question in the representation learning literature: how to systematically characterize the structural role of each latent factor in terms of where it is expressed.
-
This study presents a principled formalization of structural role identification in grouped sequential data, wherein each latent coordinate is systematically characterized along three orthogonal dimensions: group-specific expression, incoming temporal influence, and outgoing temporal influence. This tripartite decomposition furnishes a unified, interpretable framework for elucidating the contribution of latent factors to group dynamics.
-
The authors develop ROLETRACE, a theory-guided framework that estimates structural roles ensuring that the estimator directly instantiates the theoretical definitions. The framework is validated on both controlled synthetic settings and the real-world AMI meeting corpus, demonstrating that the identified roles carry meaningful structure in naturalistic sequential interactions.
Critical weaknesses
-
The empirical validation on real-world data is limited to a single dataset — the AMI meeting corpus — which raises concerns about the generalizability of the identified roles across different domains and interaction types. Moreover, the linkage between the theoretical identifiability guarantees and the empirically observed behavior on real-world data is not adequately substantiated, rendering it uncertain whether the practical performance of ROLETRACE is in fact supported by the proposed theoretical framework.
-
The empirical comparison is underwhelming given the framework’s complexity: the gains over baselines don’t convincingly justify ROLETRACE’s theoretical and computational overhead. Notably, the quantitative comparisons are confined to the appendix rather than integrated into the main text, which may indicate that the observed performance differences are not sufficiently robust or consequential to warrant emphasis as a principal result.
-
The paper lacks any discussion of computational complexity, which is a notable omission given the derivative-based role estimation procedures. Without a clear characterization of computational efficiency, it is difficult to assess whether the proposed framework is practically viable.
(minor) Deferring all related work discussion to the appendix is a notable structural weakness, as it prevents readers from clearly situating the proposed framework within the broader literature without leaving the main body.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide additional evidence or analysis demonstrating that the synthetic data generation process adequately reflects the structural properties of the real-world settings?
-
The proposed framework is evaluated primarily on small-scale synthetic data. Can the authors provide experiments on larger synthetic datasets to assess whether ROLETRACE scales gracefully as the number of latent factors, group size, or sequence length increases?
-
As shown in Table 4, the performance gains of ROLETRACE over traditional baselines are not particularly striking. Given that classical methods were likely not subject to extensive hyperparameter tuning, is it possible that a well-tuned baseline could match or even outperform the proposed method? How robust are the reported results to this concern?
5 comments
Q2. How does RoleTrace scale with the number of latent factors, group size, or sequence length?
A6. Thank you for emphasizing the value of evaluating larger systems. We would first like to highlight that Figure 6 already evaluates sample-size scaling from to training sequences. To further investigate scalability, we conducted additional experiments varying latent dimension , group dimension , and sequence length , with eight independently sampled mechanisms per setting. For brevity, we present the results of RoleTrace with the two strongest baselines, with the full comparisons provided in Figure 9 of the revised manuscript.
-
(a) Scaling Latent Dimension. We evaluate the settings from to :
RoleTrace No-refit ThoughtComm-adapted 4 0.844 ± 0.066 0.719 ± 0.120 0.812 ± 0.091 6 0.812 ± 0.058 0.667 ± 0.109 0.771 ± 0.070 8 0.906 ± 0.039 0.844 ± 0.061 0.828 ± 0.058 10 0.775 ± 0.041 0.650 ± 0.057 0.750 ± 0.065 12 0.781 ± 0.044 0.802 ± 0.044 0.750 ± 0.039 14 0.741 ± 0.038 0.661 ± 0.044 0.625 ± 0.052 16 0.766 ± 0.052 0.664 ± 0.062 0.672 ± 0.054 18 0.799 ± 0.044 0.771 ± 0.045 0.750 ± 0.038 20 0.744 ± 0.026 0.694 ± 0.041 0.706 ± 0.037 -
(b) Scaling observation structures. We further vary the group dimension :
RoleTrace No-refit ThoughtComm 6 0.812 ± 0.058 0.667 ± 0.109 0.771 ± 0.070 9 0.792 ± 0.076 0.708 ± 0.082 0.708 ± 0.093 12 0.708 ± 0.076 0.625 ± 0.093 0.729 ± 0.070 15 0.708 ± 0.061 0.688 ± 0.066 0.604 ± 0.070 -
(c) Scaling Sequence Length. We additionally extend the sequence length from to :
RoleTrace No-refit ThoughtComm 5 0.812 ± 0.058 0.667 ± 0.109 0.771 ± 0.070 10 0.896 ± 0.044 0.875 ± 0.061 0.854 ± 0.058 15 0.938 ± 0.044 0.917 ± 0.045 0.875 ± 0.061 20 0.938 ± 0.044 0.917 ± 0.063 0.917 ± 0.045
Overall, RoleTrace achieves the highest joint accuracy in most settings. We hope these additional experiments help address your concerns and provide a clearer picture of RoleTrace's scalability. Thanks again and we sincerely appreciate the opportunity to better understand how RoleTrace scales in practice.
Q3. Could better hyperparameter tuning allow baselines Table 4 to match or outperform RoleTrace? How robust are the reported results to this concern?
A7. Thank you for highlighting the importance of baseline tuning. We would like to clarify that the baselines were indeed tuned, as confirmed by our experiment records. In particular,
(a) SVM: We searched with an RBF kernel.
(b) XGBoost: We searched tree depths , with 300 estimators, learning rate 0.05, and row/column subsampling of 0.8.
(c) PCA and TS2Vec: Their downstream predictors were selected from three logistic regression and four MLP configurations.
Moreover, all results in Table 4 are evaluated across five team-disjoint folds and five random seeds, following the same evaluation protocol. We have made these details clearer in the revised version (L1911-1915). Thanks again for the careful attention to our baselines.
We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful suggestions and engagement with our work! In light of your feedback, we have expanded the discussion of computational complexity (L345–348), added related work to the main text (Section 6), included larger-scale synthetic experiments (Figure 9, L1598–1603), and provided further experimental details (L1911–1915) in the revised manuscript. Thank you again and we would be happy to discuss any further questions.
Dear Reviewer pK7E,
Thank you again for your thoughtful review and constructive suggestions. We would like to briefly follow up and share a short summary of the main clarifications and revisions:
- Theory and real-world relevance: Clarified the complementary purposes of synthetic and AMI experiments, and explained how our structural assumptions relate to real-world interactions.
- Scalability: Conducted additional experiments varying latent dimension, group dimension, and sequence length (Figure 9, L1598–1603).
- Computational complexity and related work: Added complexity analysis (L345–348) and added the related work discussion into the main text (Section 6).
- Experimental comparisons: Clarified the main quantitative results (Tables 1–2) and provided further details on baseline tuning and evaluation fairness (L1911–1915).
We would be grateful for any further thoughts you might have after reviewing our responses. Please feel free to let us know if anything needs clarification. Thank you again for your time and consideration!
Best regards,
Authors
Thank you for sharing your thoughtful feedback. We appreciate the opportunity to address your concerns below.
W1. Real-world generalizability and connection to theory.
A1. We appreciate the reviewer's careful consideration of our real-world evaluation and its theoretical grounding. We would like to clarify that our synthetic and real-world experiments serve complementary purposes: synthetic experiments directly evaluate structural recovery under known ground truth, while AMI examines whether the estimated roles provide useful information in real sequential interactions.
The connection to our theory follows naturally from the grouped temporal structure of meetings. Participants define meaningful observation groups (L430–431, L460-463), while conversational variation and temporal interactions motivate the variability and influence conditions. Faithfulness and minimality further characterize when these structural influences are distinguishable. Although AMI does not provide ground-truth latent roles to directly verify identifiability, our framework applies to a broader class of grouped sequential systems (L35-39), with weaker identification requirements (L224-L226, L270-277, Appendix A.5) and extensions to higher-order temporal dependencies (Appendix B). We hope this clarifies how the AMI study supports the practical relevance of our framework and complements the theoretical and synthetic results. Thank you for encouraging us to elaborate on this important aspect.
W2. Quantitative comparisons.
A2. Thanks for your thoughtful feedback. We would like to clarify that the main quantitative comparisons are already presented in Tables 1 and 2 of the main text. Table 1 directly evaluates structural-role recovery, where RoleTrace achieves 0.854 Joint accuracy versus 0.708 for the closest baselines, an improvement of 14.6 percentage points. Table 2 compares AMI next-speaker prediction at matched latent budgets using the same representation and downstream classifier. Appendix Table 4 (In the latest revised version, it is Table 10) provides supplementary comparisons with conventional predictors using different input dimensions, while Table 2 offers the more direct, matched-budget comparison, where the learned representation, latent budget, and downstream classifier are shared. This isolates the contribution of structural role selection. We appreciate the opportunity to clarify these points.
W3. Computational complexity.
A3. We sincerely appreciate your great suggestion. For latent dimension N and observation dimension dx, the decoder Jacobian contains O(dxN) entries, while each transition cross-Hessian contains O(N2) entries. Our implementation computes only the required mixed derivative block through automatic differentiation. For the conditional Gaussian transition, the same block can also be expressed through first-order network Jacobians.
W4. Related Work.
A4. Thank you for this constructive suggestion on the paper's organization. We compared the most relevant literature in the introduction (L52-79). In the revision, we have included this section in the main text (Section 6).
Q1. Is there additional evidence or analysis demonstrating that the synthetic data generation process reflects the structural properties of real-world settings?
A5. We appreciate this thoughtful question about the realism of our synthetic setting. Our synthetic DGP is designed to capture the structural properties underlying grouped sequential interactions (L1465-1503). Specifically,
Moreover, the mechanisms are randomly generated and exhibit substantial structural diversity. Among the 16 retained mechanisms, all have distinct group-incidence patterns and labeled delayed graphs, spanning 14 directed graph isomorphism classes. Each mechanism contains 3–5 latents shared across multiple groups and 1–3 coordinates with overlapping incoming or outgoing activity.
We have also examined the structural assumptions of these synthetic mechanisms. Further quantitative diagnostics on the fitted models are provided in our response to oQyj's Q1, which we hope will be helpful here as well.