- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
For molecular property prediction, the authors propose an edge-aware VQC attention mechanism that extends the existing QGAT framework. Specifically, the proposed method incorporates bond attributes, which are not explicitly modeled in the original QGAT, into the quantum attention scorer. Compared with the classical GATv2, the proposed model achieves broadly comparable performance with slightly fewer parameters and outperforms GATv2 on several tasks. In addition, it exhibits attention attribution patterns that differ from those of GATv2. In several chemical case studies, these patterns are consistent with known structure–activity relationships (SARs).
Critical strengths
- Incorporating bond attributes into quantum attention is well motivated for molecular graphs, where edge types have chemically meaningful information.
Critical weaknesses
- The manuscript states that it adapts the existing QGAT framework of Ning et al. (2025), but it is not sufficiently clear which components are inherited from prior QGAT and which are newly introduced. As far as I can understand from the current presentation, the main methodological modification appears to be Eq. (7), namely the addition of the edge term . If this is indeed the primary architectural novelty, I find the methodological advance rather limited for an ICLR paper.
- The main motivation of the paper is that prior QGAT formulations do not explicitly incorporate molecular bond attributes into the quantum attention computation. However, the manuscript does not include an otherwise identical QGAT baseline without the edge term . Consequently, it is unclear whether incorporating bond attributes into the quantum attention computation provides any benefit over the corresponding node-only QGAT formulation
Questions for authors
- Which components are inherited from Ning et al. (2025), and which are newly introduced in this work?
- Could the authors provide an ablation comparing the proposed edge-aware QGAT against an otherwise identical QGAT without the term?
3 comments
Thank you for conducting the additional ablation requested in my second question.
Regarding my first concern, if the main contribution is the systematic study of quantum attention in molecular graph learning and drug discovery rather than a new architecture, I think the paper should go beyond showing a few qualitative differences from GATv2. In particular, the differences in prediction and attribution behavior should be characterized more comprehensively, together with controlled empirical studies or theoretical analysis that help establish when, how, and why quantum attention differs from its classical counterpart.
Thank you for your constructive feedback. We agree that more comprehensive characterization of when and why quantum attention differs from classical attention would be valuable.
Our primary contribution is an application oriented investigation of quantum attention in molecular graph learning and drug discovery, rather than the proposal of a fundamentally new attention architecture. To this end, we evaluate predictive performance across five molecular datasets and investigate molecular attributions using SME and experimentally reported SARs. These experiments provide an initial empirical characterization of quantum attention in this application domain, while a systematic theoretical explanation of its differences from classical attention remains beyond the scope of the present study. We appreciate the suggestion and will clarify the scope and limitations of our contribution in the revised manuscript.
We thank the reviewer for this question. We would like to clarify that our primary objective is not to propose a new quantum graph attention architecture, but rather to investigate the new application of quantum attention to molecular graph learning and drug discovery. The main contribution of our study lie in the application and systematic of quantum attention for molecular property and bioactivity prediction, including investigating attention and attribution patterns in relation to experimentally reported structure-activity relationships.
For second question. We conducted an additional ablation study by removing the edge feature term Weeuv from Equation (7). The results show that incorporating edge features improves predictive performance on four of the five tasks, including BACE, BBBP, FreeSolv and ESOL. In particular, AUC of BBBP improves fro, 0.6882 to 0.7157, while ESOL RMSE decreases from 1.0016 to 0.9103.
However, the node only variant performs slightly better on ChEMBL-BACE, achieving a Spearman of 0.7399 with 0.7357 for edge-aware model. These results suggest that incorporating bond features into quantum attention is beneficial for several molecular prediction tasks, although the advantage is task dependent rather than universal.