- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper audits three distinct questions in VQC: whether circuit features improve a task model, whether a classical student can reproduce a trained map, and how circuits and classical maps compare when trained directly on the task, separately for one angle-encoded circuit family, primarily at q=6 under analytic-statevector simulation, on tabular benchmarks. The paper binds each result to a stated cohort, comparator, and decision rule, and finds that for this family and regime the observed gains trace to the classical front end and its nonlinear expansion, with no isolated gate-angle contribution detected.
Critical strengths
-
The paper provides a detailed illustration of the experiments, together with the anonymous code and appendix.
-
The authors discuss quantum training and inference costs in the paper, which is valuable for a QML paper.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper seems to rely heavily on AI during writing, especially with excessive use of dashes (—) and long, complex sentences. This makes the paper difficult to follow.
-
The experiments lack generality, especially as the circuit configurations are narrow. Although the paper presents extensive analysis, its conclusion is based solely on the tabular data for q=6, making the findings appear unrepresentative.
-
The structure of the paper seems unreasonable. The main text only consists of analysis, while all tables and experimental details/results are in the appendix. This structure makes the paper difficult to follow, especially with many cross-references across the paper. This makes the paper confusing to read back and forth between sections.
Questions for authors
Overall, the analysis and content of the paper are quite comprehensive. I think it’s just a matter of writing style, so I plan to review the revisions the author makes during the rebuttal period. If the revisions are well done, I’d be happy to accept the paper.
2 comments
Thank you for the revisions and clarifications. I appreciate the efforts to improve the presentation and clarify the scope. However, the additional experiments, mostly conducted with a single seed within the same circuit family, only partially address my concern about the narrow empirical scope. This remains a concern for my assessment, so I will maintain my rating of 2 and leave the final decision to the AC.
Thank you for the review and for the clear statement that the concern is the writing. We have rewritten the main text; the summary of changes is in our comment to all reviewers.
W1. Writing style: dashes and long, complex sentences. We agree that the text was hard to follow. The revised main text and the three statements use shorter sentences, one claim per sentence where we could, and no em-dashes. We also replaced our internal names with standard terms and use one term per concept. Our use of AI tools is disclosed in the AI-use statement; the authors take responsibility for the text.
W2. Generality: narrow circuit configurations, q = 6, tabular data. We agree that the scope is narrow, and Section 7 opens with this. Two things changed.
W3. Structure: analysis in the main text, tables and results in the appendix. We agree. The main results are now in the main text: Table 1 (the three questions and their answers), Table 2 (definitions of the methods), Table 3 (all ten methods and the comparisons), Table 4 (ablation), Table 5 (what the circuit adds to the compressed coordinates), Table 6 (surrogates and cost), and Figures 1 and 3. Sections 4 and 5 can be read with their own tables and Section 6 with Figure 3 (the full list of its 56 comparisons is in Appendix Q), and the results sections follow the order of the three questions. The appendix remains as the full experimental record, with a table at its start that maps its working names to the terms of the main text.
We hope the revision addresses your concerns, and we are glad to make further changes.