- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes learned representation selection for hybrid quantum–classical tabular classification. Under a fixed encoding budget, each input slot selects between a PCA coordinate and an NCA coordinate through a learned binary gate. Selection is trained jointly with the predictor, after which the mask is frozen and the predictor is reinitialized and retrained. Experiments on twenty binary classification datasets compare the method with tuned tree ensembles and variants of the representation, circuit topology, and encoding width. The results show competitive average predictive performance, although the reported pairwise comparisons do not establish statistically significant improvements after multiple-comparison correction.
Critical strengths
S1: The evaluation includes twenty datasets, tuned classical baselines, shared outer test folds, and preprocessing fitted within the corresponding training partitions. These choices make the reported predictive comparisons more informative than comparisons against weak or untuned baselines. The paper also provides useful diagnostics and candidly reports limitations, including substantial retention of initial selection masks, slightly higher average scores from NCA-only inputs, and the absence of evidence for quantum advantage.
Critical weaknesses
W1: The methodological contribution is insufficiently distinguished from existing differentiable feature selection and learned quantum encoding. Concrete Autoencoders already learn discrete feature selections and include experiments that retrain predictors on the selected features; Stochastic Gates jointly learns feature selection and prediction. Both are cited but receive no experimental comparison. Relevant quantum embedding approaches, including Neural Quantum Embedding and Q-FLAIR, are also absent from the comparisons. The specific restriction to one PCA/NCA choice per slot may be distinctive, but the experiments do not establish its benefit over adapted existing selectors under a matched encoding budget.
W2: The experiments do not convincingly isolate the value of learning the selection mask. Appendix E reports that only 13.3% of eligible source choices differ from initialization and that 52 of 100 final masks retain every initial choice on non-padded slots, yet no frozen random-mask baseline is evaluated. NCA-only inputs achieve slightly higher mean accuracy and macro-F1, and none of the twelve corrected comparisons against the ablation variants reaches the 0.05 significance threshold. Furthermore, Count-12 changes the fitted NCA representation, circuit grouping, and training procedure, so it does not isolate the selection mechanism. A matched random-mask comparison, an ablation of fresh refitting, and a classical-only predictor using the same selector are needed to establish which proposed components account for the observed performance. These gaps leave the central claimed contribution insufficiently supported.
Questions for authors
None.