- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper extends the EXAQC evolutionary framework to automate quantum circuit discovery within hybrid quantum-classical architectures for image classification tasks. It processes high-dimensional images by combining classical encoders, evolved parameterized quantum circuits, and classical decoders. Evaluated across MNIST, Fashion-MNIST, and CIFAR-10, the methodology demonstrates that automatically discovered quantum modules maintain competitive accuracy while using significantly fewer trainable parameters than pure classical baselines.
Critical strengths
- Automated discovery of PQC structure avoids hand-crafted ansatz bottlenecks, enabling hybrid networks to drastically compress trainable parameter count on CIFAR-10 compared with traditional CNNs without severe loss in accuracy. 2. Jointly optimizing classical feature extraction with rotation-based U3 encoding allows quantum layers to operate efficiently on compressed low-dimensional features, which is essential for scaling QML to complex computer vision tasks.
Critical weaknesses
- It is not fully clear which specific features of multi-channel spatial images make existing QAS frameworks designed for low-dimensional data unsuitable, as classical encoders handle all spatial compression before passing vectors to the quantum module. 2. The experimental comparisons in Table 1 mix drastically different dataset setups, numbers of classes, and downscaling protocols, which obscures direct quantitative baseline comparisons.
Questions for authors
- Can the methodology provide a top-level pseudocode/algorithm listing the exact steady-state evolutionary loop, specifying how mutation, crossover, and Lamarckian parameter inheritance operate during candidate selection in Section 2.3? 2. In Section 1 and Section 2.1, what specific domain features of image classification make prior QAS architectures designed for general low-dimensional datasets inefficient, given that classical CNN encoders compress raw pixels into feature vectors prior to quantum encoding? 3. Regarding Section 4.1 and Table 1, could the paper clarify how fairness is preserved when comparing EXAQC on 10-class benchmarks against prior works evaluated on 2-class or downscaled variants? 4. In Section 4.2 and Table 2, please provide a more detailed line-by-line discussion with bulleted observation points analyzing why U3 encoding scales better for complex data like CIFAR-10 despite requiring higher gate count and parameter complexity.
2 comments
I would like to thank the authors for the responses. In light of the rebuttal and other reviews, I keep my score.
Response to Reviewer
We thank the reviewer for their comments and address the questions raised.
Steady-state evolutionary loop. We have added a top-level algorithm to Section 2.3. It will show when parents are selected, how offspring inherit trained parameters, and how each completed evaluation updates the population.
Role of image structure after CNN compression. The CNN learns spatial patterns and relationships among input channels before the quantum circuit receives a feature vector. We agree that our experiments do not establish that these image properties make prior QAS methods inefficient. The question we study is how effectively circuit search can use a compact feature vector when the encoder, quantum circuit, and decoder are trained jointly. The qubit budget and encoding determine how many encoder outputs can enter the circuit and how they are represented. We will revise Sections 1 and 2.1 to make that distinction explicit.
Comparability of the results in Table 1. We agree that results on two-class or downscaled versions are not directly comparable with the full ten-class tasks. Table 1 was meant to show that EXAQC can solve the full ten-class problems that most earlier methods reduce to two classes, not to claim higher accuracy than them. It also represents a significant advancement over prior state of the art works -- EXAQC can solve the full problems while prior methods could not. In the revision, we split Table 1 into reduced-task and ten-class groups and compare accuracy within the two groups, where EXAQC is best on Fashion-MNIST and CIFAR-10 and close on MNIST. We have revised Section 4.1 accordingly. Most prior quantum architecture search methods reduce these datasets to two classes and downscaled images, because the field is still at an early stage. We do not expect current noisy intermediate-scale quantum machines to beat state of the art classical methods, and the question of advantage will need fault-tolerant, error corrected quantum computers. Before advantage can be studied on that hardware, the community needs search methods that work on the full problems.
Encoding results and the CIFAR-10 trade-off. U3 accepts three encoder outputs per encoded qubit, compared with one for RX or RY. This wider interface gives the encoder more ways to map learned features into quantum states, while the larger evolved circuit may contribute additional capacity. We have added a section to explain this within the given space constraints.