- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a "circuit-frontier representation" for quantum architecture search: it constructs a DAG of operations based on logical-line dependencies, maintains a "frontier embedding" for each logical line, and forms a global summary. Circuit construction strategies utilize these representations to iteratively select operations.
Critical strengths
Table 2 separately discusses the comprehensive strategy, distinct profiles under shared mapping rules, and mapping interventions for fixed profiles, thereby avoiding the conflation of these different issues.
The authors did not misrepresent task-level mean improvements or pointwise confidence intervals as a generalized, calibrated advantage; they also retained the observed direction reversals and performance degradation associated with mixed deployment under S10.
Critical weaknesses
Existing experiments do not separately isolate the removal of line-by-line readout, the removal of port labels, or the integration of existing circuit DAG encoders into the same training pipeline. Comparisons involving standard GRUs, hardware MLPs, independent encoders, and gradient blocking are insufficient to isolate the effects of these specific design additions.
Table 9 shows that, under a shared heuristic mapping, the overall archive mean for all seven configurations outperforms their respective final policies. Since the CF-H variant still relies on the PPO constructor, the paper does not address whether a simple search combined with archive retention, within the same computational budget would have sufficed.
Questions for authors
Could you include a comparison of encoders, specifically "global-only," "port-label-free," and approaches similar to He et al., and report the results from the archive under both the strategy and the joint heuristic mapping?
Could you add random or local search baselines using the same 1,024 acquisitions and the same upper limit on parameter optimization, while retaining eight archive circuits? At the very least, for H₂, could you provide a reference based on enumeration or the reachable optimum?
Is the direction reversal observed in S1/S10 robust? Could you add independently trained blocks to directly estimate the paired difference-in-differences and their associated uncertainties?
Does the improvement in energy correspond to a better quantum state? Could you provide additional data on the "gate-only expectation" of the returned circuits, the ideal noise-free energy, and diagnostics for particle number and spin sectors? An objective function that incorporates readout distortion cannot, on its own, validate state accuracy.
Hello Reviewers,
As the discussion period is approaching its end, please take a moment to review the authors’ responses. If you have any further comments please share either to authors or privately to other reviewers and me. And if you feel your judgment is refreshed, please also update your assessment if necessary.
Thanks for your thoughtful reviews and discussion!
Bests, AC