- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors provide a first attempt to define and characterize conservation laws in parameterized quantum circuits. They take three types of quantum circuits and derive theoretical results and verify them experimentally.
Critical strengths
Characterizing PQC behaviour is a very timely topic, as it is generally not understood well. Conservation laws are commonly studied in classical ML and have not yet been transported to QML, thus, it is an interesting research question and motivation.
Critical weaknesses
I am not certain about the relevance and scope of this work. As mentioned in the questions, I am uncertain about the contribution of Theorem 4.4 (which would be the practically relevant circuits), and the extension to the broader class of circuits is the class of 2 layer Clifford circuits, which are not commonly employed in practice (otherwise I would ask the authors to provide a reference) and additionally are classically simulable. I am thus not convinced about the practical implications of these results.
Futher, I think the experimental section is quite limited. The authors state that the motivation for their approach is to reduce dimensionality and gradient measurement costs, however, for the problem instances they consider (2 and 3 qubits), this is not an issue. Since it is also easily possible to simulate 8-10 qubits on a standard laptop, I do not understand why the experiments were not scaled to reasonable problem sizes. Considering the limited scope of the experiments, I do not think the results are particularly informative.
As this is the first work on quantum conservation laws, I would also expect some more background from the classical side in the main part of the paper. I only found this afterwards in the appendix, but it is never referenced in the main text.
As a minor comment, there are several inconsistent usages of citep and cite in the paper. Further, I would encourage the authors to rewrite the statement in the experimental results in the main part that states "deeper circuits are provided in the appendix". I think this is an exaggerated statement considering that the results go from 2 to 3 qubits.
Questions for authors
- Have you considered how the data encoding affects the conservation laws? I am aware and fully agree with the data-agnostic approach, however, the data encoding can also induce symmetries independently of the exact angles that might merit a discussion here. I also believe that this should be mentioned in the inroduction and background more prominently.
- For the strong PQC definition, you note , I assume that this should be modulo the number of qubits? Could you clarify the notation?
- Can you clarify the notation of , used in Def 2.1?
- In Remark 2.2 you mention that the conservation laws can be characterized similarly for different losses. Can you elaborate on this and provide some sentence on the applicability of the quantum setting compared to the classical one? The same holds for Remark 2.3. I think this would be very to put in a background section, as mentioned in the weaknesses above.
- I am struggling to see how Theorem 4.4 is not trivial. For case (i) if the two commute, by definition of the factor cancel, and the last layer has no effect on the output of j. (ii) The same goes here, if the last layer has no effect on qubit j, then evidently I can remove the gates by definition in both cases. Am I missing something? Could the authors clarify?
- When and how is training stopped?
- Why was training only started from one specific parameter initialization and not tested with different ones?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer z1K3 (Part II)
Q1. Have you considered how the data encoding affects the conservation laws?
Answer. We agree that the choice of data encoding can introduce additional symmetries and additional laws. However, our work only focuses on data-independent conservation laws that hold for arbitrary input quantum states, allowing us to isolate invariants induced by the circuit architecture and measurement observable. We agree that this deserve more emphasis and we will revise the introduction and background accordingly.
Q2. For the strong PQC definition, you note [...] Could you clarify the notation?
Answer. Thank you the reviewer for raising this issue, the correct notation should be instead of only . We have corrected this in the revised manuscript.
Q3. Can you clarify the notation of , used in Def 2.1
Answer. The notation denotes the space of continuously differentiable real-valued functions on , as is standard in real analysis.
Q4. In Remark 2.2 you mention that the conservation laws can be characterized similarly for different losses. Can you elaborate on this and provide some sentence on the applicability of the quantum setting compared to the classical one? The same holds for Remark 2.3. I think this would be very to put in a background section, as mentioned in the weaknesses above.
Answer. We thank the reviewer for this comment. Regarding Remark 2.2, the extension to other loss functions follows from Assumption 2.4 and Corollary 2.5 in [Marcotte et al., 2025]. For a scalar-output QNN and any differentiable loss satisfying where , we have Thus, our conservation-law characterization remains valid, including for squared-error and cross-entropy losses. This result applies to quantum predictors because the underlying characterization concerns general smooth parametric models.
We clarify that the framework of [Marcotte et al, 2024] applies to general smooth parametric predictors, including our QNN model . [Marcotte et al., 2024, Propositions 2.8-2.9] address momentum-based dynamics, while Proposition 2.12 characterizes generalized gradient flows. The additional zero-gradient-dataset assumption required by Proposition 2.9 is satisfied in our setting by choosing the maximally mixed state which gives , and therefore
Furthermore, Theorem 2.1 in [Marcotte et al., 2025] establish a structural relationship between conservation laws with and without weight decay under the same zero-gradient-dataset assumption. Thus, these general results apply to our QNN setting without quantum-specific modifications. We emphasize that applicability of these frameworks does not imply that the original conservation laws remain unchanged under alternative training dynamics. Our analysis is restricted to Euclidean gradient flow without weight decay. We have revised Remark 2.2 and 2.3 to clarify these extensions and include the relevant references.
Reference.
[Marcotte et al., 2024] Keep the momentum: Conservation laws beyond euclidean gradient flows. arXiv preprint arXiv:2405.12888, 2024
[Marcotte et al., 2025] Transformative or conservative? conservation laws for resnets and transformers. arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.06194, 2025
Response to Reviewer z1K3 (Part III)
Q5: I am struggling to see how Theorem 4.4 is not trivial. For case (i) if the two commute, by definition of the factor cancel, and the last layer has no effect on the output of j. (ii) The same goes here, if the last layer has no effect on qubit j, then evidently I can remove the gates by definition in both cases. Am I missing something? Could the authors clarify?
Answer. We thank the reviewer for this question. We agree that the cancellations in cases (i) and (ii) follow directly from the stated commutation and support conditions. However, the two cases have different consequences. In case (i), commutation with removes the dependence on , while and may still affect the output. In case (ii), the effective observable acts as the identity on qubit , so the entire local Euler block has no effect on the measured output.
The role of Theorem 4.4 is to give explicit, readout-dependent criteria for identifying these coordinate laws at arbitrary depth, without computing the Lie closure. Since the cancellations hold at the operator level, the corresponding derivatives vanish for every input state. Thus, the identified parameters remain fixed under unregularized Euclidean gradient flow and exact-gradient SGD, independently of the dataset. In particular, an effective observable gives one coordinate law for each and three for each , yielding independent coordinate laws. Their updates and derivative measurements can therefore be omitted.
The proof of Theorem 4.4 in Appendix B.3.3 also establishes a single-layer completeness result that is not stated explicitly in the main text. When and , the identified coordinates form a complete set of independent local smooth conservation laws on the open dense set where for every . Indeed, the derivatives of the measurement map with respect to and , , are nonzero and pairwise Hilbert--Schmidt orthogonal. Therefore, with and , we have and Theorem 3.5 gives local completeness. Thus, in this single-layer setting, the analysis also excludes additional independent local smooth laws, a conclusion that does not follow from cancellation alone. For , the identified laws need not be complete, since additional cross-layer laws may arise. We will make this single-layer completeness result explicit in the discussion following Theorem 4.4.
Q6. When and how is training stopped?
Answer. Thank you for your question. We agree that the stopping criterion was not clearly specified in the experimental setup. Specifically, training is conducted for a fixed budget of 3,000 stochastic gradient descent (SGD) updates, with a batch size of 32, a constant learning rate of 0.01, and no weight decay. The training process terminates upon reaching the prescribed number of updates, without employing any early stopping criteria. We will explicitly clarify this stopping criterion in the revised manuscript.
Q7. Why was training only started from one specific parameter initialization and not tested with different ones?
Answer. We thank the reviewer for this question. For each configuration in Figure 1, we use a single parameter initialization sampled from , independently of the ground-truth parameter used to generate synthetic labels. We present one trajectory per configuration to clearly illustrate the evolution of individual parameters and their conserved combinations.
Importantly, the conservation laws hold for arbitrary initializations. Specifically, for each identified linear law , the exact-gradient SGD updates satisfy at every iteration, as established analytically in Lemma B.5. Thus, different initializations may yield different values of the conserved quantities without affecting their preservation. The random initialization in Figure 1 is therefore chosen solely for visualization and does not restrict our theoretical guarantees.
Response to Reviewer z1K3 (Part I)
Dear Reviewer z1K3,
Thanks for your constructive and valuable feedback. Below are our responses to your questions. We hope that we have addressed your concerns regarding our paper and will ultimately convince you to raise your score.
Answer. We thank the reviewer for this comment. Our results include complete characterizations for Basic PQCs at arbitrary width and depth (Theorems 4.1, 4.2), final-layer laws for Strong PQCs at arbitrary depth (Theorem 4.4), and completeness for the stated two-layer families (Example 4.5 and Theorem 4.6). For Theorem 4.4, we address the specific role by answering Q5 below.
The circuits in Theorem 4.6 contain arbitrary-angle RY and RZ rotations; the Clifford assumption concerns E1, not the full trainable circuit. Strongly Entangling architectures are used in quantum learning, for example by [R1]. Our theorem covers two-layer configurations satisfying its readout and distinct-support assumptions, including the range-one CNOT ring of Corollary 4.7(i) for every n≥3 and the three-qubit default configuration described in our response to Reviewer XA1X (Q3).
For product-state inputs, this family's observable structure permits efficient classical evaluation. Our contribution concerns which parameter combinations remain conserved and whether further independent laws exist. These questions are not resolved by the ability to simulate the circuit.
The results also reduce optimization variables and gradient-measurement settings. The linear laws allow unregularized Euclidean gradient flow and exact-gradient SGD to be represented in fewer variables. For the three-qubit default configuration, eight independent laws reduce the derivative settings from 36 to 20; on the regular set ΩC, Proposition B.9 further reduces this number to 18. Our additional experiments for Corollary 4.7(iii), with n=3,…,8, give a reduction from 96 to 38 settings at n=8. The finite-shot results reported in W2 support these measurement savings.
Answer. We thank the Reviewer for this comment. We emphasize that our theoretical results are not restricted to small numbers of qubits. Specifically, for Basic PQC, Theorem 4.2 establishes the complete set of independent conservation laws for arbitrary numbers of qubits and layers. For Strong PQC, Theorem 4.4 identifies conservation laws associated with the parameters in the last layer, while Theorem 4.6 provides a complete characterization for the two-layer architecture with an arbitrary number of qubits.
In Figure 1 and Appendix C, we use configurations with n=L∈2,3 to numerically illustrate these theoretical findings. Our choice of small-scale circuits is primarily motivated by visualization and interpretability rather than theoretical limitations on the number of qubits. Larger circuits would involve substantially more conserved functions, making their visualization considerably more complex without necessarily providing additional insight into the theoretical results.
To further address the reviewer's concern, we conducted additional experiments on the maximal-rank-gap family of two-layer n-qubit Clifford circuits in Corollary 4.7(iii), extending the evaluation to n∈3,…,8. As detailed in Appendix C.2 in the revised manuscript, we compared standard parameter-shift estimation with our gradient reconstruction method under finite-shot noise, using Nsh∈128,256 shots per setting. Our estimator consistently achieves lower gradient estimation error across all circuit widths while remaining below the theoretical bound in Proposition B.9. These results extend our numerical evaluation beyond the original small-scale experiments and support the predicted measurement efficiency as the number of qubits increases.
Answer. We have include the relevant result from the classical side in the Subsection 2.2 Conservation Laws in Gradient Flows. We suggest the reviewer refer to the revised manuscript for more detail.
Answer. We have revised the manuscript to ensure consistent usage of citep and cite. We have also rephrased the statement in the experimental results section to explicitly refer to additional experiments with 3-layer circuits.
Reference.
[R1] Patrick Holzer and Ivica Turkalj. Spectral invariance and maximality properties of the frequency spectrum of quantum neural networks. Quantum Machine Intelligence, 8(1):33, 2026.