- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work evaluates two so-called quantum implicit neural representations (QINRs). The central question that is being discussed here is that whether the performance reported by these hybrid models can be attributed to their trainable quantum parameters or whether the quantum component is working. After reading this work and the mentioned QINR works, I understand the argument of the authors. However, I did not find the contents interesting and I did not learn anything novel. I am also not fully convinced by the conclusion and therefore did not see it of high value to the community. I gave my reasons below in corresponding sections.
Critical strengths
I view this work as an evaluation of existing so-called quantum implicit neural representations. The experiments cover different areas that are of interest.
Critical weaknesses
Here I gave my reasoning and doubts on this work. They are mainly from the following perspective:
[i] the hyperparameter tuning for the quantum INR seems asymmetric. Some potentially important settings do not seem to be carefully controlled or varied. For example, I did not find a sensitivity study of the temperature factor used in the transformation for amplitude encoding. It seems to be an important factor as it directly concerns the prepared state. The positional encoding also seems to be fixed, despite the paper (from what I see) itself emphasizing the importance of the accessible frequency spectrum.
[ii] are the learning rates same and fixed for both the classical neural model and the quantum circuit in the experiments? Recent works such as [1,2] show that the lr. should be treated as separate hyperparameters; [2] further shows that their relative learning rates can affect which component dominates training. Since the paper shows that the optimization choices can change a quantum INR result by more than 10 dB, I believe a more systematic optimization study of the quantum component is needed to have stronger conclusions about how much the ansatz contributes.
- Benchmarking Quantum Reinforcement Learning, ICML 2025
- Parallel Hybrid Networks: An Interplay between Quantum and Classical Neural Networks,, Intelligent Computing 2023
[iii] I am not fully convinced that the claimed frozen identity-initialized model measures the contribution of the entire quantum circuit. Identity initialization followed by freezing makes the trainable unitary exact, i.e. . This is indeed a clean study of the trainable quantum transformation. However, the hybrid model still retains the learnable amplitude encoding and the measurement/readout structure. In particular, the amplitude encoder still learns the input-dependent state, while the ansatz can equivalently be viewed as transforming this state or changing the effective measurement observables. Freezing therefore removes only the latter transformation. Thus, the experiment more directly supports the conclusion that training the ansatz provides limited additional benefit in several settings, rather than that the broader quantum component contributes little.
[iv] The analysis is also not fully established for the second quantum INR evaluated. The frozen-ansatz test and the structural analysis are performed for the first quantum INR, whereas the second quantum INR experiment studies reproduction, learning-rate tuning, and simulation cost. I did not see analogous component-level ablation showing how much of QIREN's performance is attributable to its quantum circuit.
Most importantly, this work is an evaluation of existing works from which I did not learn anything.
Overall, I do not find the current manuscript of potential value to the community.
Questions for authors
See weakness. I do not have further questions.
I thank the authors for their responses but unfortunately I am still not convinced.
1. Comparison with INR baselines. It seems that these QINR architectures can accept different classical architectures in their framework instead of single MLPs. If the authors can present such results, I think it can be interesting. The reason is that: if we intepret quantum circuit from its spectral expressive power, its co-behavior with different classical neural models will be nice to see. A theoretical analysis will be beneficial. Also it seems that QVF discussed such options? They also tested integrating SIREN in the QVF flow and compared with classical SIREN. Such results are missing.
2. Related work and experimental fairness. Several relevant works on quantum implicit neural representations appear to be missing from the discussion, including:
Given these existing studies, I remain concerned that the experimental comparisons are insufficiently comprehensive and that the paper's positioning of its contributions is potentially misleading.
Unfortunately, the authors' responses have not resolved my main concerns or clarified what fundamentally new insights this work provides beyond the existing literature. I therefore maintain my original assessment.