- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the structural inductive biases of three low-capacity quantum sequence architectures: Quantum Recurrent Neural Networks (QRNNs), Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks (QCNNs), and Quantum Projected Attention (QPA) models. The evaluation encompasses controlled Boolean tasks, DisCoCat classification, the TALES synthetic language modeling benchmark, zero-shot execution on IBM quantum processors, and direct QPU optimization.
Critical strengths
The experiments in this paper are very thorough.
Critical weaknesses
- In my view, this paper fails to contribute new insights to the quantum machine learning community; instead, it resembles a set of experiments conducted on previously proposed quantum neural network architectures, accompanied by some rather obvious analyses. Consequently, I am inclined to recommend rejection.
- AI-assisted writing in the paper results in a text that appears overly defensive, making it difficult for readers to grasp the core ideas.
Questions for authors
- While the scope of the experiments is quite broad, the depth and attention to detail fall short of the standards expected for machine learning papers; for instance, could you explain the architectures and specific configurations used in these two hardware experiments? Since factors such as architecture, device noise, width, depth, and connectivity cannot be decoupled from one another, it is difficult to demonstrate that the difference in hardware trainability between QRNNs and QCNNs—which the paper aims to highlight—stems specifically from structural bias. Moreover, even if such a demonstration were possible, I believe it would hold little practical academic significance.
- I suggest reducing the amount of AI-generated experimental content and text in your paper, as this tends to result in an overly defensive tone, as well as theoretical proofs and experimental details that are superficial and limited in scope. While AI might appreciate a paper that is rich in content and honestly reports negative results, this particular paper offers little of value to readers in the quantum machine learning community.
2 comments
The response did not address my concerns. I am keeping my rating as is.
Response to Reviewer KTGK
We thank Reviewer KTGK for recognizing the thoroughness of our experimental scope across Boolean logic, DisCoCat, TALES, zero-shot QPU inference, and direct QPU training. The revision directly addresses both of your concerns by clarifying our hardware comparison and sharpening the presentation of our core findings.
Q1. What are the hardware configurations, and what does the physical comparison establish?
First, we summarize the exact circuit architectures and hardware configurations from §4.3 and App. E (Tables 7–11, Figs. 14–17):
ibm_strasbourgwith zero SWAP overhead: 322 native gates, 34 2Q gates, 2Q depth = 22, Table 11).ibm_brusselswith zero SWAP overhead: 579 native gates, 42 2Q gates, 2Q depth = 10, Table 11).The reviewer is correct that the two physical runs executed concurrently on
ibm_strasbourgandibm_brussels, with different widths, depths, and backend noise. This is consistent with the role of the hardware study in our evaluation: to establish end-to-end physical training feasibility and quantify the resource requirements of two distinct sequence-model implementations under realistic deployment conditions. The experiments demonstrate complete optimisation loops driven by finite-shot QPU measurements and provide auditable circuit width/depth, transpilation, wall-clock, and QPU-time accounting. Because architecture and backend vary together, we do not use the endpoint difference to claim intrinsic QRNN-versus-QCNN noise robustness.Architecture-level conclusions instead come from the controlled multi-seed simulations summarized in the General Response: the parameter-group interventions, restricted-QPA analysis and pooling ablation, and matched 256-shot QRNN clean/noisy controls.
Q2. How has the presentation been revised to make the contribution clearer?
We appreciate your candid feedback on the writing style. We agree that some repetitive AI-assisted formulations and defensive qualifiers, particularly at the ends of sections, obscured the main takeaways instead of clarifying their scope. In the revised manuscript, we removed this repetitive phrasing throughout §1–4, consolidated the relevant scope conditions and limitations in §5, and reorganized the presentation around three direct findings:
This revision makes the novelty, evidence, and scope of each result visible where it is introduced, while keeping limitations together rather than interrupting each experimental conclusion.