- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes functional-group-guided soft tokenization for molecular property prediction. A predefined set of 53 functional-group patterns reweights molecular bonds in a graph-cut regularizer, guiding atom-to-token assignments between two graph encoders. The method reports improved performance across GOOD and DrugOOD distribution-shift settings.
Critical strengths
Using chemical substructures to guide learned graph coarsening is a reasonable inductive bias for molecular OOD prediction. The reported improvements cover multiple shift settings across GOOD and DrugOOD. The same-architecture comparison with zero cut-loss weight in Table 5 also provides useful evidence that the regularizer improves prediction on GOOD-ZINC, although it does not isolate the contribution of functional-group-specific weighting.
Critical weaknesses
-
There are inconsistencies in the chemical definitions underlying the method. In Tables 1 and 6, for example, benzene is associated with
C1CCCCC1, a cyclohexane pattern, rather than an aromatic pattern such asc1ccccc1. If these are limited to the tables, please clarify the patterns used in the implementation. -
The cut objective admits a degenerate solution, and it is unclear how this is avoided. For any strictly positive probability vector , let . This satisfies the row-wise softmax constraints. Since ,
.
Moreover, Eq. (9) gives for every token, so all pooled token node features are identical. Equation (13) includes only the task and cut losses and does not specify an anti-collapse term.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors clarify the patterns actually used for the entries in Table 1 and whether correcting the inconsistencies affects the reported results?
-
Is there an anti-collapse mechanism not described in the formulation? If the task loss alone is relied upon, could the authors provide quantitative evidence on assignment diversity and token redundancy to show that constant assignments are avoided in practice?
-
How are the 53 patterns selected, and what fraction of atoms and bonds receive effective FG guidance in training and test molecules? Table 9 reports occurrence counts, not coverage or performance on poorly covered molecules. Do the benefits persist for structures outside the predefined patterns? Have alternative priors been considered, such as BRICS-derived fragments or the ring/FG decomposition used in ReLMole?
-
Are ID/no-shift results available to assess whether the OOD gains incur a trade-off in ordinary predictive performance? The reported experiments cover GOOD/DrugOOD shift settings, without a separate conventional MoleculeNet evaluation beyond the HIV-derived GOOD setting.
-
The reference cited for GOOD-ZINC appears to omit several authors. Could the authors check the author list against the full citation below?
Rafael Gómez-Bombarelli, Jennifer N. Wei, David Duvenaud, José Miguel Hernández-Lobato, Benjamín Sánchez-Lengeling, Dennis Sheberla, Jorge Aguilera-Iparraguirre, Timothy D. Hirzel, Ryan P. Adams, Alán Aspuru-Guzik; Automatic Chemical Design Using a Data-Driven Continuous Representation of Molecules. ACS Cent. Sci. 28 February 2018; 4 (2): 268–276.