- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MolLedger, a graph neural network for ADME property prediction with atom-level attributions. The model combines atom representations with a global molecular context to produce additive atomic scores and uses Crippen and TPSA contributions as regularization anchors to encourage agreement with chemical priors. The authors evaluate predictive performance on 11 ADME tasks and assess attribution quality through concordance with physicochemical properties, attribution completeness, and matched molecular pair analysis.
Critical strengths
Understanding the contributions of individual atoms and fragments is an important challenge in molecular property prediction. In drug optimization, molecule-level predictions alone often provide insufficient guidance for structural modifications; understanding how particular atoms or functional groups relate to property changes is equally valuable. MolLedger incorporates atom-level attribution directly into the prediction process and uses global context to account for the influence of the molecular environment on local contributions. This approach addresses a relevant need in medicinal chemistry: interpreting structure–property relationships and formulating hypotheses for molecular modifications while retaining useful predictive performance.
Critical weaknesses
- The interpretability evaluation relies heavily on the chemical priors used during training. Although the authors use Crippen and TPSA as training anchors and deliberately evaluate different physicochemical properties, these properties are not independent of the anchors. More importantly, the loss function encourages atom attributions to align with these priors, thereby restricting the model's flexibility to learn other potential chemical effects. The authors aim to improve interpretability by encouraging agreement with the anchors, but if the model mainly follows these priors, what independent explanatory information do its attributions provide? Appendix E (Figure 10) even shows that the Crippen prior can lead to misleading attributions. 2.MolLedger shows improvements on some atom-level attribution metrics, but its performance in chemical property concordance and attribution localization varies across tasks. These results do not yet provide convincing evidence that its attributions are more accurate than those of existing methods. Moreover, the experiments mainly evaluate predictions of ADME properties, including LogD, solubility, clearance, permeability, and plasma protein binding, as well as how these properties change when a single side chain or local functional group is replaced. The model has not been sufficiently tested on complex cases, such as strongly non-additive property changes or interactions among multiple fragments. Whether it can preserve predictive accuracy and provide reliable atom-level explanations in these cases remains unclear.
Questions for authors
- What additional explanatory information do MolLedger’s attributions provide compared with directly using Crippen/TPSA atomic contributions? Do the interpretability gains persist after controlling for the information contained in the anchors?
- When the chemical priors conflict with experimental observations, can the model reliably correct those priors? Could the authors provide a systematic analysis of such cases rather than individual examples?
Significance of MolLedger's contributions
Thank you for reviewing our paper. Please see the comment we added above to demonstrate quantitatively how MolLedger is able to learn relevant information beyond the provided anchors. Our results show that MolLedger is significantly better at predicting and explaining the differences between pairs of molecules compared to other interpretable models or posthoc interpretability methods applied to a GNN. As medicinal chemists typically swap one fragment at a time during the lead optimization process and providing per-atom attributions for ADME predictions can help significantly with this process, the focus on evaluating the ADME properties in this paper and how to interpret the effects of fragment swaps is a significant contribution to the field. We hope that addresses your questions.