- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Geometry-Constrained Residual Projection, or GCRP, a framework that constrains scRNA-seq imputation to preserve cell-state geometry used in optimal transport-based progression analysis. Rather than developing a new imputation model, GCRP treats existing imputers as sources of candidate residuals and selectively accepts corrections based on neighborhood support, correction magnitude, cell-level displacement bounds, and population-level OT constraints. The paper derives Wasserstein-based bounds on population displacement and relative distance ordering. Experiments on CITE-seq datasets, controlled corruption, disease progression, and time-course data show that GCRP reduces geometric distortion compared with several existing imputers while retaining some expression recovery.
Critical strengths
GCRP separates candidate expression recovery from the decision of whether a correction should be accepted. By combining neighborhood support, cell-level displacement constraints, and population-level OT checks, the method can be applied to different existing imputers without retraining them. Propositions 1–3 further establish how bounded cell displacement limits changes in population Wasserstein distances and preserves sufficiently separated group-distance orderings relative to the observed geometry.
Critical weaknesses
- Propositions 2–3 establish bounds on pairwise Wasserstein distances and their relative orderings between cell populations, but these guarantees do not directly address the stability of OT couplings or inferred cell-state trajectories. In Appendix Table 22, GCRP only reduces the held-out zebrafish interpolation error from 0.887 to 0.886, while a simpler neighbor-mean correction achieves 0.882. It remains unclear whether preserving population-level distance geometry actually leads to more reliable progression inference.
- Propositions 1–3 establish geometric stability guarantees for fixed affine reference maps and unregularized Wasserstein distances, while the practical implementation also uses nonlinear reference maps and Sinkhorn costs computed in separately fitted embeddings. Appendix B acknowledges that the nonlinear displacement constraints are not guaranteed to hold under the proposed scaling procedure. It remains unclear to what extent the theoretical guarantees apply to the geometric constraints enforced by the actual implementation.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors provide stronger evidence that preserving population-level Wasserstein distances and their orderings improves the stability or accuracy of downstream progression inference, particularly compared with the simpler corrections evaluated in Appendix Table 22?
- Could the authors clarify which theoretical guarantees remain applicable to the nonlinear reference maps and Sinkhorn-based geometry checks used in practice? How do they verify whether the implemented algorithm satisfies the nonlinear displacement constraints?