- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose wasserstein gradient flows for perturbation modelling. during inference the generated cells are translated towards ridge predicted mean. this method is evaluated on 4 datasets. the main idea is to combine fitted ridge estimator and JKO inspired distributional endpoint objective.
Critical strengths
The only strength i could say is the separation of distribution population mean and centered variation. beyond this decomposition i do not find the methodological or empirical contribution as substantial.
Critical weaknesses
the whole paper is a extremely close to scDFM (ICLR2025) which means conditional flow matching directly in gene-expression space combined with a population-level alignment loss
the only thing authors have changed is to use WGF and ridge estimator. I would call this paper a true representation of A+B research.
no controlled comparison of MMD vs sinkhorn vs WGF endpoint losses on identical backbones and training setup.
missing the most crucial metric which is de-spearman log fold change. cell-eval 2 metrics have also been released by ARC institute, but the authors are still using cell-eval 1. all results are shown with a single seed.
inference-time mean guidance can directly improve pearson delta , L2, MSE/ MAE, and even energy distance without demonstrating better perturbation dynamics. so none of the reported gains show improvement of perturbation specific transcriptional programs
biological validation is missing too like pathway enrichment GSEA or regulator level agreement against resources or databases such as TRRUST.
it is difficult to determine whether the gains correspond to perturbation-specific transcriptional programs rather than improved population-mean calibration.
Questions for authors
authors need to show identical architecture, mean predictor, source distribution, training protocol across same 3 fixed seeds for MMD, Sinkhorn, WGF endpoint losses with statistical tests using Holm corrected values.
report all metrics from cell-eval 2 including de-spearman log fold change for all methods and all ablations. this is needed because the current mean guidance can improve both mean metrics and energy distance without changing covariance.
I truly believe the authors need to make a more impactful contribution to the field rather than taking 2 well established ML concepts and plugging it into perturbation modelling.
perturbation modelling is a crowded field and these incremental changes are not at the level of ML contribution expected at a conference like ICLR.