- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors introduce SelCell a novel method for calculating cell velocity from spatial transcriptomic snapshots. The authors propose to replace the implicit expression changes and physical motions with an explicit model. Under their assumptions, they can derive 3 certificates about the resulting velocities trustworthiness and the measurements. The authors evaluate SelCell on two synthetic benchmarks and 5 real transcriptomic snapshots against established velocity estimation methods.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
The empirical evidence is limited to small datasets.
Can the authors please add a simple example with synthetic data to illustrate their mechanism better.
No discussion about the validity and assumptions behind the observation model. Also while the proposed mechanisms for RNA readouts are sensible they are unlikely to reflect the whole biology and is neglecting important components such as some cells changing expression in response to cytokines, the differentiation of tissues and responses to external stimuli e.g. injury or inflammation. Hence, the certificate cannot provide explicit guarantees if these assumptions break which is not discussed much.
The article is not written clearly, several sections appear to be generated with extensive LLM usage and it the certification parts are repeated several times.
Questions for authors
I disagree with the notion that cell velocity must be observed from a single snapshot. While omics approaches are indeed destructive measurements there are plenty of methods to measure temporal samples from similar samples and align the snapshots using optimal transport and learn temporal models such as MOSCOT, CellBRIDGE, NicheFLow etc.
Can the authors please show an example of their learned velocities against gound truth that is easier to parse than Figure 7 and include it in the main text. I am also struggling to see in that image why selcell is performing better as both fields look quite different from ground truth.
The last sentence of the abstract is too strong of a claim for the evidence presented.
Why is the image in Fig 1 not a spatial transcriptomic image?
Limitation section does not discuss that the problem is fundamentally ill posed, it is impossible by definition to learn a velocity from a single snapshot, one can only estimate certain processes under assumptions about the cell expression and movement that can be biased.