- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the reconstruction of cell population dynamics from single-cell gene expression snapshots collected at multiple time points, with a focus on predicting cell-state distributions at unobserved intermediate times. The method uses optimal-transport-based conditional flow matching: static OT couplings between consecutive observed time points define temporal cell tuples, from which reference paths and their velocity targets are constructed. Its main contribution is to incorporate an external TF–target regulatory prior to compute cell-level regulon activities, map their temporal changes into PCA space, and use the resulting directions to modulate the tangents of shape-preserving cubic-Hermite reference paths. The authors evaluate the method through temporal holdout experiments on three T-cell exhaustion datasets, alongside controls that permute cell–activity correspondence or TF activity channels. The results show lower mean prediction errors at earlier holdouts, whereas linear CFM or alternative transport methods often perform better at later holdouts.
Critical strengths
- The paper introduces an interesting way to guide flow matching reference paths using transcription-factor regulatory information. It maps temporal changes in regulon activity into latent-space tangents. This is a meaningful contribution because temporal snapshots alone do not uniquely determine the intermediate dynamics, and regulatory information offers an additional basis for choosing reference paths.
Critical weaknesses
-
The benefit of regulatory information remains unclear. TRACE maps the activities of 29 regulons into a 30-dimensional PCA space using ridge regression and uses the mapped activity derivatives to modify reference-path tangents. However, the PCA representation may capture gene expression changes that are not adequately represented by these regulons, and the paper does not quantify how much latent-state variation the activity representation explains. The directional alignment analysis in Table 9 provides some supporting evidence but does not resolve this concern. Furthermore, on Giles day 15 in Table 7, both permutation controls outperform TRACE in all five runs, indicating that preserving the correct regulatory correspondence does not provide an additional predictive benefit in this setting.
-
The predictive benefits have limited scope. TRACE achieves lower mean errors at earlier holdouts, but its mean does not improve over linear CFM at any of the three later holdouts and is consistently worse than moscot. Moreover, the largest improvement occurs on Gupta day 7, which was used to select the steering coefficient, whereas the improvement over cubic CFM on the external Giles day-8 holdout is small and inconsistent across runs. Although the authors acknowledge this stage dependence, the analysis does not adequately explain which properties of the data or dynamics determine whether regulatory guidance is beneficial, nor does it provide a way to assess its suitability using retained data. Consequently, the practical advantage of the additional regulatory information and reference-path construction remains limited.
Questions for authors
-
Should regulatory information also inform the static OT coupling? The current method determines cross-time cell correspondences using only squared Euclidean distances in PCA space, then uses regulatory information to adjust the reference paths connecting those cells. Given that regulatory information is intended to guide the dynamics, why do the authors use it only to modify paths rather than also to inform the coupling? Could matching cells solely by expression distance connect cells with incompatible regulatory changes, thereby limiting the effectiveness of subsequent tangent adjustments?
-
How well do the selected regulons represent changes in the PCA state space? Please clarify the overlap between the target genes used for regulon activity scoring and the genes used to construct the PCA representation. If these gene sets differ, how do the authors justify using changes in the selected regulon activities to guide dynamics in a PCA space that may also capture variation in genes outside those regulons? The directional alignment analysis in Table 9 provides some supporting evidence but does not establish how much of the overall latent-state variation these regulatory features explain.
-
Does the regulatory information provide an additional predictive benefit? On Giles day 15 in Table 7, both permutation controls outperform TRACE in all five runs. Could the authors explain why disrupting cell–activity correspondence or TF-channel alignment improves prediction in this setting? What evidence distinguishes the contribution of authentic regulatory information from the effects of feature aggregation and tangent modification?
Please Join the Discussion
Dear Reviewers,
The authors have submitted their responses. Please read them and provide your feedback. Thank you!
Best regards, Area Chair