- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed a framework, RAVEL, which models time-varying neural communication as the dynamic recruitment of fixed propagation components. The proposed model is evaluated on both synthetic and real mouse electrophysiological recording datasets. The results tries to domanstrate parameter recovery, cross-animal transfer and neural activity prediction.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides an interesting perspective of time-varying effective delays in neural communication.
- The decomposition into fixed propagation components and dynamic recruitment coefficients is intuitive reasonable and potentially useful in further understanding of neural communication mechnism.
- The experimental results cover boardly with both synthetic and real mouse electrophysiological recording datasets.
Critical weaknesses
- Lack of comparison of existing LTI methods. Although the proposed method might be a good option for understanding the neural communication mechnism, the advantages over general LTI methods are not clearly demonstrated.
- Insufficient justification of the proposed factorization of the proposed propagation. The comparisons in the paper mainly focus on static-recruitment and dynamic-delay variant, but it lacks a matched capacity comparison with general LTV models using learnable LTI components. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the reported benefits caused by the specific propagation parameterizaiton or simply from dynamic basis recruitment.
- Limited evidence. In the synthetic experiments, RAVEL achieves an NMSE of 0.212, compared with 0.217 for the dynamic-delay model under fixed-delay generation. Since the difference is really small, it does not establish that the proposed method can reliably outperform alternative mechanisms. While the cross-animal experiments show similar held-out NLL gains for pooled and independently fitted dictionaries (0.025 vs. 0.028), but the spatial coupling and recruitment parameters remain recording-specific. It could support the predictive ability, but could not sufficiently support the inferred components correspond to conserved propagation mechanisms.
- Statistical evidence to support the claims of generalization ability is not enough. For example, for VISam←VISp, the improvement over MRM-GP is not statistically significant after correction (p=0.1406). And the multi-hop experiment reports a relatively modest spectral residual R square equals to 0.172 and is evaluated on only 36 held-out events from a single recording session.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors compare the proposed framework against existing LTV model with general learnable LTI components?
- Could the authors provide more evidence to support the proposed propagation factorization shows stable mechanisms shared across animals, given to the similar predictive performance between the pooled and independently fitted dictionaries?
- Could the authors further discuss the generalizability of the multi-hop results, given the limited evaluation across recording sessions, and the relatively modest improvements over MRM-GP?