- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
this work proposed a distribution aware effective connectivity measure based on channel capacity and a dual normalizing flow estimator that models empirical residuals while optimizing the input distribution.
Critical strengths
the comparison to the matched gaussian provides an ablation of whether non-gaussian residual structure matters. The simulations cover hidden drivers, feedback, heterogeneous hemodynamics, and multiple network sizes.
Critical weaknesses
Capacity remains on a locally linear FIR channel with additive noise, so the resulting score doesn't explain the direct neural causation under omitted variables or model misspecification. One needs to restrict the assumptions in settings where nonlinear or temporally structured brain dynamics are important.
Questions for authors
- How would the conclusions change with multivariate conditioning that explicitly accounts for common drivers?
- Do authors think this paper is the right for ICLR? or ICLR reviewers have the capacity to judge the correctness in terms of the neuroscience?
3 comments
Response to Question 2: ICLR relevance, neuroscience/neuroimaging motivation, and applications
Relevance to ICLR
Do authors think this paper is the right for ICLR?
Response. Thank you. Our contribution is a novel learning algorithm for estimating effective connectivity, with neuroscience and neuroimaging providing the motivation and application. The machine-learning contribution is a min–max framework that learns a power-constrained input distribution while fitting flow-based entropy estimators to generated channel outputs and empirical residual samples. The entropy/KL identity, GCap recovery and known-target experiments validate the estimator; simulations assess connectivity recovery against specified ground truth.
Accepted ICLR papers address fMRI effective connectivity, functional-connectivity analysis and functional-network learning:
- Spike-based Digital Brain: a novel fundamental model for brain activity analysis (ICLR 2026): infers effective connectivity through virtual perturbations of an fMRI-trained model.
- BrainLM: A foundation model for brain activity recordings (ICLR 2024): learns intrinsic fMRI functional networks without network labels.
- BrainOOD: Out-of-distribution Generalizable Brain Network Analysis (ICLR 2025): analyzes Pearson-correlation BOLD networks from ABIDE and ADNI.
- Biologically Plausible Brain Graph Transformer (ICLR 2025): learns fMRI functional-connectivity graphs in ABIDE, ADNI and ADHD-200.
- Accelerating Benchmarking of Functional Connectivity Modeling via Structure-aware Core-set Selection (ICLR 2026): benchmarks functional-connectivity operators on resting-state fMRI.
- A Brain Graph Foundation Model: Pre-Training and Prompt-Tuning across Broad Atlases and Disorders (ICLR 2026): pretrains on fMRI-derived Pearson-correlation brain graphs.
Broader neural-recording precedents include:
- Learning dynamic representations of the functional connectome in neurobiological networks (ICLR 2024): learns dynamic neuronal communities and functional connections from calcium recordings.
- NetFormer: An interpretable model for recovering dynamical connectivity in neuronal population dynamics (ICLR 2025): estimates state-dependent neuronal connectivity from activity recordings.
- Nonlinear multiregion neural dynamics with parametric impulse response communication channels (ICLR 2025): learns within-region dynamics and communication channels between neural populations.
- Inferring brain plasticity rule under long-term stimulation with structured recurrent dynamics (ICLR 2026): learns stimulation-dependent recurrent connectivity and plasticity.
Assessing the neuroscience interpretation
Do ICLR reviewers have the capacity to judge the correctness in terms of the neuroscience?
Response. We provide supporting neuroscience literature, including Manto et al. (2012) for cerebellar motor control and Thompson et al. (2013) for LFP–BOLD correspondence. Our real-data studies test practical relevance; their interpretation rests on this literature. The contribution is methodological rather than a new neuroscience discovery.
In neuroscience, functional connectivity describes statistical dependence; effective connectivity estimates directed influence under a model (Smith et al., 2011). These estimates alone do not establish neural causation or synaptic connections (Friston, 2011; Valdés-Sosa et al., 2011). As discussed in Appendix A.1, our capacity measure is conditional on the fitted model and observed variables. Our HCP analysis concerns directed BOLD interactions, interpreted using the well-established physiology literature cited in the paper.
score increased from 2 to 3
I thank authors for the replies
Response to Weakness / Question 1: Channel assumptions and common-driver comparisons
Linear-channel assumption
Response. Thank you. Our FIR model describes relationships at the measured BOLD scale. Nozari et al., Nature Biomedical Engineering (2024) reported that their best-performing linear autoregressive models matched or exceeded the tested nonlinear models in cross-validated one-step-ahead prediction for both resting-state fMRI and resting-state intracranial EEG. Their analysis shows how spatial and temporal averaging can reduce or mask microscopic nonlinearities, providing empirical motivation for linear modeling of macroscopic brain recordings. Such recordings are widely used to study effective connectivity between brain regions (Smith et al., 2011). We have added this empirical motivation in Appendix A.1. GC, VAR-LiNGAM and GIMME also use linear models. Our simulations test recovery after a nonlinear Balloon–Windkessel transformation from neural activity to BOLD. Linearity and Gaussian residuals are separate assumptions; Dual-flow retains the linear channel while modeling residual structure beyond variance. Strongly nonlinear interactions remain a limitation (Appendix C.1).
Temporal structure
Response. Thank you. As discussed above, linear modeling is motivated by evidence from resting-state fMRI and intracranial EEG. For the continuous LFP–BOLD recordings, we refit the FIR channel and estimate its residual distribution in 50-s sliding windows with 25-s steps, allowing estimated connectivity to vary across the scan (Section 3.4; Appendix D.3). Our simulation benchmark also tests directed-edge recovery with temporally correlated AR(1) measurement noise (ρ = 0.4; Appendix E.1). Strong temporal dependence in the fitted residuals remains a limitation of the current estimator (Appendix C.1).
Causal interpretation
Response. Thank you for raising this concern. As already explained in Appendix A.1, effective connectivity (EC) denotes a model-based directed interaction, conditional on the fitted model and observed variables. Shared latent inputs or model misspecification can affect our estimate; it does not by itself establish direct anatomical connectivity or neural causation (Valdés-Sosa et al., 2011). Following established practice in EC analysis, we evaluate recovery of known directed connectivity using the benchmark simulation framework (Smith et al., 2011).
Explicit multivariate conditioning and common drivers
Response. Thank you. Our simulations already test robustness to common and hidden drivers. CD-e/CD-u contain observed common drivers; Hidden Diamond omits the driver from analysis; Comp12 combines two hidden drivers, feedback, indirect paths and heterogeneous HRFs. Explicit conditioning could change fitted channels, residuals and edge rankings by accounting for other observed regions; its quantitative effect on Dual-flow remains unmeasured.
We compare against multivariable linear network models: VAR-LiNGAM combines vector autoregression with contemporaneous relations; GIMME estimates group- and individual-level network paths. Both model multiple observed regions jointly. Dual-flow achieves higher mean AUROC and AUPRC than both comparators in these conditions:
Entries are mean AUROC/AUPRC across 50 realizations from Table 5. Expanded lag/pruning and GIMME cutoff searches retain this ranking (Appendix G.1); tuned GIMME improves Comp12 to .599/.356, below Dual-flow's .879/.724.
The simulator defines present and absent edges before estimation. Table 5 reports sensitivity (recovered fraction of true edges), precision (true fraction of detected edges), and FPR (falsely detected fraction of absent edges), with thresholds calibrated on the other 49 realizations. Dual-flow FPRs in these four conditions are .070, .040, .022 and .066. Existing tests therefore quantify both recovery and false positives under these confounds. Explicitly conditioned Dual-flow remains a model extension.