- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies the problem of the closest Gaussian to a given measure in Wasserstein geometry.
Critical strengths
I think that the writing is very clear and nice to follow. The goal is clear and interesting. The ideas are nicely illustrated.
Overall, I think that this is nice and well-rounded paper, focussing on relatively narrow, but interesting problem.
Critical weaknesses
The experimental validation is weak, but this is okay from my point of view. This is a theoretical contribution and the experiments sufficiently validate everything.
The scope is very narrow, but I still think that it is an interesting problem.
Appendix H relies on numerical optimization to establish a claim about the globally nearest Gaussian, which does not constitute a rigorous proof. Monte Carlo optimization does not rigorously establish that the globally W₂-nearest Gaussian has different eigenvectors and eigenvalues from the moment-matching Gaussian.
Busemann connection: The RW₂ projection length coincides with the negative Busemann function of Bonet et al. (2026) for radial Wasserstein rays. The novelty of the proposed angle and projection is therefore unclear. ("Busemann Functions in the Wasserstein Space: Existence, Closed-Forms, and Applications to Slicing", C Bonet, E Cazelles, L Drumetz, N Courty)
Questions for authors
Could one extend the closed-form projection results for general location–scale families to derive explicit Busemann function formulas, as in Bonet et al. (2026, see above)? Could these formulas also be used to construct new Busemann-based slicing procedures? Being able to derive slicing algorithms would make the insights of the paper more interesting for practical applications.
Minor remarks
-
Gap in Theorem 3.2 proof (Appendix B.4): Uniqueness of the optimal transport map does not immediately establish uniqueness of the proposed affine coordinates . Injectivity requires an additional argument.
-
Mismatch of assumptions: Theorem 3.2 assumes absolute continuity of at least one distribution, but the framework is applied to empirical distributions for which this condition need not hold.
-
Unjustified optimization reduction (Section 3.4): Imposing changes the optimization objective. Equivalence of the optimal covariance shapes after optimizing scale must be explicitly established.
-
Missing convergence guarantees (Algorithm 2): The numerical procedure provides no guarantee of convergence to a globally W₂-nearest Gaussian, despite the terminology used.