- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes correlation sliced-Wasserstein (CorSW) on full-rank correlation matrices. It instantiates four pullback-flat geometries (ECM, LECM, OLM, and LSM), constructs Log and Busemann slices on the PHCM (Poly-hyperbolic-Cholesky metrics) product of hyperbolic factors, and introduces a joint Lorentz representation, PHCML-HCat. It distinguishes its closed-form Product-Geodesic surrogate from exact nearest-product-geodesic projection and establishes route-specific metric or pseudometric properties. Validation includes controlled distribution transport, SPD classification, EEG transfer, graph learning, covariance-correlation fusion, and native loss-module timing. The results indicate task-dependent advantages of correlation alignment and complementary behavior of the product and HCat representations.
Critical strengths
- Removing marginal channel scale is well motivated when amplitude is a nuisance. This paper compares correlation-only and covariance-correlation alignment under shared backbones and seven seeds across several task families. Its RawCorr and Corr-SPD controls help distinguish correlation normalization from the subsequent geometry choice.
- This paper explicitly distinguishes the original PHCM product geometry from the constant curvature PHCML pullback metric. It also identifies Product Geodesic as a surrogate, derives the exact nearest-geodesic optimization problem, and explains a sufficient condition for coincidence.
Critical weaknesses
- The significance of the correlation-specific extension needs a sharper case beyond established constructions. The pullback-flat reduction and projection identity follow the framework of Bonet et al. (2025), particularly Proposition 7 and Lemma 25. The Product-Busemann weighted-sum identity is already Proposition 16 of that work, and Lorentz direct concatenation is an existing operation in Bdeir et al. (2024). The authors acknoledge these papers, so the most distinctive components appear to be the PHCML metric choice, the product-geodesic analysis, and the empirical comparison. The paper would be more persuasive if it established what practical insight the new metric provides relative to its strong flat variants.
- The general-parameter theory contains inconsistencies. In Corollary 3.2, Eq. (7) uses in the OLM inner product, whereas the OLM coordinate is . Dropping the diagonal is harmless for the canonical Frobenius pairing with a hollow direction, but not for the general pairing in Eq. (56). For example, take Here denotes a matrix unit and is a unit direction for the stated metric. The correct coordinate is approximately , whereas substituting into Eq. (7) gives .
- I'm not familiar with this area, so I would like to take into account the comments of other reviewers.
Questions for authors
Same as weakness.