- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors introduce a family of Deformed-Euclidean Metrics (DEMs) meant to be applied to normalized SPD (NSPD) matrices, where standard approaches such as the log-Euclidean metric fail to cover the whole real line and leave the upper boundary unhandled. By introducing a scalar diffeomorphism that maps the bounded NSPD eigenvalues to the entire real line, all presented DEMs have global geometry (flat and geodesically complete), bi-invariance (distances remains unchanged after group operations), and orthogonal and scale invariance (distances are robust to rotations and scaling). New geometric operators and eigendecomposition-free approximations are presented to make the new map computationally feasible and useful. Experiments on synthetic data, visual recognition, and neuroimaging show strong downstream utility and distributional fidelity against SPD-based diffeomorphism baselines.
Critical strengths
-
Strong Methodological Novelty: The authors present a non-trivial but well-founded and intuitive approach to address limitations in diffeomorphisms in the SPD cone applied to NSPD matrices, which are commonly used in neuroimaging and other applications. This enables an improved manifold for downstream machine learning tasks with convenient implementation properties.
-
Paper Clarity and Experiments: The method and experimental design are clear, with enough details presented for reproducibility. Results show reasonable gains against baselines, empirically showing the advantages of using the presented NSPD metrics across a wide range of popular datasets with diverse applications.
Critical weaknesses
-
Unclear Motivation in Writing: While the authors do a good job at explaining the method, explicitly mentioning the limitations of using LEM or other metrics on NSPD matrices (failure to cover the whole real line and unhandled upper bound) would be helpful for the reader to understand the motivation behind the DEM family.
-
Inconsistency of Best-Performing DEM: Results can appear inconsistent across datasets and metrics. While the five presented DEMs are all of valid utility, the best performance within these appears to be arbitrary, limiting the applicability of the method. More details on the leading DEM between protocols would be useful.
Questions for authors
- Could you add discussion on selecting an appropriate DEM? If I were to implement this myself on a new dataset, there is no clear guideline on which DEM I should use.