- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper builds, for each image, a trajectory of neighborhood covariance matrices over time (EEG/MEG) or over layers (Llama-3-8B, DINOv2). It compares systems through the angles between per-image velocity directions, without fitting any map between them. Brain and both models share angle structure, and only Llama shows a rate-free time-to-depth ordering.
Critical strengths
- The method needs no cross-system mapping and comes with invariance proofs.
- It is tested on both EEG and MEG and 2 models across modalities (language and vision)
- The controls are honest. Category partialling and the noise-feature scaffold show how much of the effect comes from the setup.
Critical weaknesses
- The headline ordering result is weak. The “Llama carries the time-depth order” claim rests on one test in half the subjects, peak depths flip between EEG and MEG, why?
- It is not shown what the velocity view adds over simple RSA on the states.
Questions for authors
- The order results are weak and do not replicate across EEG and MEG, can you analyse this further?
- The added value over simpler methods is unclear. Can you compare directly to RSA on states (same images, same pair subsets) and show results across k, d and window size?
- The shared CLIP graph builds in part of the match. Can you define neighborhoods from each system’s own responses, or from a different embedding, and report how much of the effect remains?