- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes that trial-to-trial variability in neural population activity reflects a single circuit whose flow field is continuously deformed by low-dimensional control parameters. The authors performed a synthetic validation, applied the model to mouse and monkey motor cortex recordings, and proposed a generative extension. They show that the model recovers ground-truth dynamics on synthetic data, identifies interpretable control axes in bias space on real data, and partially transfers across sessions and subjects.
Critical strengths
The paper is well motivated. The idea is clear and can be analyzed with existing low-rank theory. This makes the model more testable than methods that modulate weights.
The paper evaluates the model across different datasets and species. The transfer analysis includes a random control, and the reach-direction plane is tested on held-out angles rather than only on training trials.
Critical weaknesses
- “many flow fields” is only demonstrated on simulated data. On real data, there is no fixed-point or bifurcation analysis, so we can’t tell whether the disengaged regime is qualitatively different. A fixed-point analysis along the disengagement axis may help this.
- Although the paper compares reconstruction and decoding performance against other baselines, it does not compare alternative explanations of trial-to-trial variability in the mouse disengagement analysis, such as LFADS style models. Can these models reproduce the disengagement separation equally well?
- Table 2 lists only one session for the disengagement analysis. Replication across sessions would strengthen the biological conclusion.
- The cross-session transfer does not establish that the full latent dynamics are shared because part of the model is still trained. A stronger test may be needed.
Minor:
- In your figure 5 panel e, the text ‘remaining parameters’ on the figure has a typo.
- The cosine similarity is reported without a baseline.
Questions for authors
Please see weaknesses above.
3 comments
I thank all authors for answering my questions, I do not have more questions.
Thank you for the discussion
We thank the reviewer for the constructive discussion, and are glad that our responses addressed the reviewer's questions. These suggestions led to what we consider the most important additions to the paper: the bifurcation analysis of the ALM network and the cross-session validation. We would be grateful if the overall assessment could be updated accordingly.
Response to Reviewer EQ58
We thank the reviewer for acknowledging the utility of our method and for the constructive suggestions. The first led to what we consider the most important addition to the paper.
“Many flow fields" is only demonstrated on simulated data.
We performed the fixed-point analysis the reviewer suggested (Sec. 3.3.1). It shows that the disengaged regime of the fitted network is qualitatively different: along the disengagement axis, the choice attractors disappear through saddle-node bifurcations and the network can no longer hold a choice. Please see the general response for details.
Alternative explanations of trial-to-trial variability.
To address alternative explanations of trial-to-trial variability, we added a comparison with models in which trials differ in their initial state or in stochastic inputs (App. D.9). It is described in the general response and in our response to Reviewer FvK9 (point 2). On the specific question of whether other models reproduce the disengagement separation: an expressive model such as LFADS may well do so, but this is not what distinguishes our model. What distinguishes it is its mechanistic account. Because its units are the recorded neurons and the bias is an input current to them, a control axis inferred by our model is a concrete input pattern over identified neurons. For the disengagement axis, this pattern is predicted to switch the circuit between engaged and disengaged regimes (Sec. 3.3.1), a prediction that can be tested in vivo with targeted photostimulation.
Replication across sessions.
We have extended the disengagement analysis beyond a single session. In the new session-stitched model, all 72 sessions share one recurrent connectivity and one bias space (App. D.7), so disengagement axes from different recordings can be compared directly. An axis estimated from other sessions carries over to a session it was not estimated from (see the general response). The single-session analysis of Sec. 3.3 also gives consistent results in additional sessions, which we will include in the appendix of the final version.
Cross-session transfer.
The embedding U maps each session's recorded neurons onto the latent space. Because different sessions record different neurons, U must be learned separately for each one. We therefore transferred everything that can be shared: the latent dynamics and the distribution of biases, and compared the transfer against matched random models. We agree that, with U retrained, the transfer alone does not establish that the dynamics are shared. However, its success motivated a more demanding test, the session-stitched model (App. D.7). In that model, the latent dynamics and the bias space are shared by all 72 sessions from the start, so a single network must account for all of them. We show that it does, and a control axis estimated from some sessions carries over to a session that was left out (see the general response).
Minor points.
We thank the reviewer for catching these.