- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents SPIRE, a method that decomposes continuous multi-region local field potentials (LFPs) into shared (cross-regional) and private (region-specific) latent trajectories. SPIRE employs a separate GRU encoder for each region, whose latent representation is split into shared and private components: the shared component is designed to capture information in brain activity that is transferable across regions, while the private component captures region-specific information. To induce this separation, the shared latents of different regions are trained to align with one another, the shared and private latents within each region are trained to be de-correlated, and an additional objective reconstructs the signal of another region from the shared latents alone.
The authors first evaluate SPIRE on synthetic LFP data with known ground-truth factors and report that SPIRE outperforms the baselines under each nonlinear mixing, time-varying inter-regional delays, and spectral confounding condition. They then apply SPIRE to real GPi-STN recordings from pediatric dystonia patients. Because the true shared and private factors are unknown in real data, they validate the model by testing whether the latents of one region can predict those of another, and show that shared latents support cross-regional prediction beyond a structured temporal null, whereas private latents do not. Finally, the authors train SPIRE only on stimulation-free data and apply it to recordings acquired during deep brain stimulation (DBS). In this experiment, stimulation shifts the shared latents more than the private latents, and the stimulation frequency is also decoded more accurately from the shared latents. Based on these results, the authors argue that DBS effects are expressed more strongly in shared brain activity than in region-specific activity.
Critical strengths
A well-designed synthetic data experiment : To evalute that the shared and private factors are actually separated and assigned to the shared and private latent components as intended, the authors construct synthetic LFP data with known ground truth (known shared and private factors), train the model and evaluate how well the learned latents predict each intended factor using a 2 2 recovery matrix (SS, SP, PP, PS) as the evaluation metric. Specifically, they assess whether the shared latents predict the shared factors well (high SS) but not the private factors (low SP), and whether the private latents likewise exhibit high PP and low PS. In particular, the synthetic data span a range of settings, from a relatively easy linear setting to settings that incorporate characteristics of real LFP data, such as nonlinear mixing, time-varying inter-regional delays, and spectral confounding. These results show that SPIRE performs better than the baselines in the more challenging settings, implying evidence that SPIRE could achieve the intended separation training effects even under LFP-like data settings. Moreover, since the shared and private factors are generally not clearly known in real LFP data, directly verifying whether the intended separation occurs on synthetic data that reflect the properties of LFPs makes this a well-designed experiment and I think this is a key experiment which supports the strengths of SPIRE.
Critical weaknesses
Limited methodological novelty : As the authors themselves acknowledge, learning shared and private representations with separate encoders while encouraging joint reconstruction, shared-private decorrelation, and alignment among shared representations are well-established approaches in representation learning, and SPIRE appears to be a framework that appropriately combines them, which leaves its methodological novelty considerably limited. For example, CTAE [1], one of the main baselines in the paper, already learns region-wise shared and private latent trajectories from multi-region electrophysiology data, and already proposes encouraging alignment among shared latents, reconstruction from shared latents alone, and shared-private decorrelation. Therefore, SPIRE does not appear to make a new methodological contribution over CTAE, but rather to replace some of its components (using a GRU encoder instead of a transformer, or using VICReg [2] for aligning the shared latents). ConvAlign addresses inter-regional temporal misalignment, but the problem of inter-regional delays has already been addressed in prior work, such as DLAG [3], the other baseline, and it remains unclear what new methodological insight ConvAlign provides beyond existing approaches to resolve temporal misalignments. Since the core components of the SPIRE framework thus appear to be largely covered by prior work, in my opinion, the authors should provide stronger justification for the methodological novelty of their approach. I believe this is the most critical point the authors needs to address and I consider this weakness as the most consequential.
[1] Sristi et al., Coupled Transformer Autoencoder for Disentangling Multi-Region Neural Latent Dynamics, 2025.
[2] Bardes et al., VICReg: Variance-Invariance-Covariance Regularization for Self-Supervised Learning, 2021.
[3] Gokcen et al., Disentangling the flow of signals between populations of neurons, 2022.
Questions for authors
-
Methodological novelty : Could the authors justify the core methodological novelty or contributions of SPIRE? If the methodological contributions of SPIRE’s key design choices can be justified, it would help in reassessing the paper’s core contribution. As mentioned earlier, I think this is the critical point, so I'm very open to discuss it further with the authors.
-
More extensive empirical validation : Even if the methodological novelty is limited, the contribution within the LFP domain could be recognized if it were validated that SPIRE’s design choices, which combine several components for the LFP data domain, yield clear performance gains. However, the current level of empirical validation seems insufficient to support such a claim. First, only CTAE and DLAG are presented as baselines, and given that CTAE shows low recovery even in the approximately linear D0 setting, I wonder whether the baselines were tuned sufficiently and fairly. Although the appendix describes tuning configurations, could the authors provide further clarification on whether the baselines were tuned enough? If so, could the authors explain the low performance of CTAE even in the approximately linear D0 setting? Also, I would like to know whether SPIRE’s performance advantages in the LFP domain can be clearly demonstrated against a broader set of sufficiently strong baselines, such as other multi-view models. In addition, just as the authors constructed separate synthetic data to verify this separation, are there real datasets in other domains that would allow the effect of this separation to be validated more directly, and if so, could such experiments be included? If these points are addressed with more extensive empirical validation, the paper’s contribution could be recognized even if its methodological novelty is limited.
-
Neuroscientific interpretation of the DBS finding : In the DBS experiment, the authors show that stimulation shifts the shared representation more than the private representation and that the stimulation frequency is decoded more accurately from the shared representation. Is it possible to conduct analyses that provide deeper neuroscientific understandings of these results, beyond the interpretation that DBS acts across multiple regions? Alternatively, beyond DBS, are there other experiments in which the separation of shared and private factors yields results consistent with established neuroscientific findings? If such experiments and analyses enable a deeper neuroscientific understanding, the paper’s contribution would be substantially strengthened.
Response to author comments
I thank the authors for their detailed response. My concerns regarding CTAE’s failure remain unresolved, as I still cannot determine whether it reflects a limitation of CTAE or implementation or training issues made by the authors of this paper. However, the additional baselines help address my main concern about the lack of a strong nonlinear baseline. The authors have also partly addressed my other concerns, and I understand that completing all the requested experiments may be difficult within the limited discussion period. Taking these improvements into account, I will raise my score to 3.