- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DMD-EEG, with independent branches for scalp spectral diagnosis and source-space representation learning, combined through decision-level fusion. The source branch uses healthy-dynamics pretraining and low-rank sparse iterative deformation and is evaluated on MDD, FEP, and PD.
Critical strengths
S1. The independent sensor/source branches preserve scalp-level diagnostic information while providing source-space representations with explicit anatomical and spectral coordinates.
S2. The evaluation covers three diseases, uses strict subject-level holdout, and includes module ablations, attribution stability checks, leakage controls, and external transfer analyses.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The link between the biological rationale and the computational assumptions underlying the healthy-dynamics prior and low-rank iterative deformation needs further analysis.
W2. The methodological contribution beyond existing methods needs clarification.
Questions for authors
Q1. Pretraining on healthy data and preserving spectral and temporal structure are well motivated. Could the authors clarify which properties of the healthy-dynamics prior are grounded in neurophysiological research while which are modeling choices? What features of neural activity are local prediction, cross-ROI prediction, and autocorrelation each intended to preserve?
Q2. Could the authors add a conceptual comparison with existing sensor–source fusion, EEG normative modeling, and sparse iterative representation methods?
Q3. Could the authors explain how the low-rank parameterization, with a shared disease direction and subject-specific amplitudes, balances regularization in small samples with individual variability?
2 comments
Thanks for the response and revisions, which have addressed my concerns regarding the healthy-dynamics prior, methodological positioning, and low-rank parameterization. I will raise my rating accordingly.
Response to X9pt: physiological grounding, related-work positioning, and low-rank parameterization
X9pt
We thank the reviewer for the three constructive questions on the physiological basis of the prior, its relation to existing methods, and the low-rank parameterization. We answer each below, with revisions(.pdf) for your points marked in green.
W1/Q1 : physiological grounding versus modeling choices in the healthy prior
Answer. Oscillatory activity and its temporal correlations are estimable EEG properties, while frequency-specific inter-regional interactions are well documented. The 46-ROI atlas, five-band partition, and four lags (τ=1,2,4,8) are modeling choices fixed before training, while each subject supplies the coordinate values. Each objective targets a distinct structure: local self-prediction preserves within-ROI short-time and cross-band dynamics, cross-ROI prediction preserves inter-regional predictive structure, and the ACF axis preserves each ROI–band correlation-decay timescale. Disease labels then fine-tune the encoder and train the deformation and readout.
Where changed. §3.3 "Oscillatory activity and its temporal correlations are estimable EEG properties..."; §2.2 (healthy-prior definition).
W2/Q2 : relation to sensor–source fusion, normative modeling, and sparse iterative representations
Answer. Unrolled sparse coding (LISTA) and EEG graph unrolling optimize a signal-processing quantity, not a disease state on anatomical coordinates (§2.1, §3.4). Mixing sensor and source features inside one feature vector leaves the source contribution ambiguous, whereas decision-level fusion keeps an inspectable ROI–frequency–lag deformation (§2.1, §3.1). Normative modeling quantifies deviation from a healthy reference, whereas we learn a disease-supervised deformation from a healthy-pretrained anchor (§2.3, §3.3). The modeled quantity and clinical target differ. Prior work models a connectivity deviation for treatment-response prediction, while ours models a structured deformation for disease classification.
Where changed. §2.1 (LISTA/graph unrolling; Shim sensor–source concatenation); §2.3 (Tong normative modeling).
Q3 : low-rank parameterization(regularization versus individual variability)
Answer. The parameterization separates what is shared from what is individual. Each disease learns one cohort-shared basis VD∈Rr×920, which defines r disease axes and fixes the directions all subjects move along. This provides the regularization. The number of free axes does not grow with the cohort, and only r directions are estimated from a small sample. Individual variability enters in the coordinates, not the axes. For each subject, a small amplitude network predicts per-step signed coefficients sk(x)∈Rr from the subject-conditioned anchor h0(x), and the update is Uk(x)=VD⊤sk(x), so subjects differ in how far and in which direction they move along the shared axes. The top-m support (m=460 of 920 coordinates) is ranked from the subject's current deformation and re-selected at every step, so the retained subset adapts per subject. We also test the capacity of the shared low-rank basis by varying only the rank r while holding solver depth and sparsity fixed for each disease (Table 10). Across all three tasks, holdout AUC is highest at a small rank (r≤2) and does not improve at larger ranks. On FEP the r=1 basis is strongest at AUC 0.794, and larger ranks do not recover the gap: r=2 reaches 0.717, r=4 falls to 0.694 (paired ΔAUC −0.137, 95% CI [−0.277,−0.011]), r=8 reaches 0.711, and a per-coordinate control without the shared basis reaches 0.722. The larger variants therefore add parameters without a resolved gain. On MDD, r=1 and r=2 tie at 0.622, so the higher rank brings no benefit. On PD, r=2 gives the best AUC (0.638), while r=1 is unstable (0.460±0.243) and r=4 drops to 0.393. Readability of the resulting state is not inferred from this sweep and is assessed separately through cross-seed stability and occlusion (§4.3).
Where changed. §3.4 "VD limits shared update capacity, while sk(x) and top-m retain individual variation..."; §4.4 "We also test the capacity of the shared low-rank basis..."; Table 10.