- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes MVQAN-CORAL for cross-subject EEG classification. It combines multiple task-aware views, per-view quantum and classical residual encoders, shared attention, and class-conditional source alignment. Experiments on three binary EEG tasks report improvements over the evaluated baselines.
Critical strengths
- Preserving complementary EEG views and addressing class-conditional subject shifts is a reasonable design. The reported results improve over the evaluated baselines under subject-disjoint evaluation.
Critical weaknesses
Insufficient Quantum Motivation
- The motivation for introducing quantum encoding is insufficient. It is unclear why this component is needed for EEG. Although the paper includes an MLP-replacement ablation, it does not resolve this concern. A suitable ablation would compare quantum plus residual against residual alone, to establish the benefit of the quantum branch.
Inadequate Writing and Referencing
I think the author was writing in a rush:
- The Introduction and Method sections contain too few references, with only one citation in the entire Method section.
- The quantum component lacks sufficient background explanation, including in the appendix. Although Appendix E.1 lists the architecture, terms such as CNOT, RY/RZ gates, and Pauli-Z readout are not adequately introduced. This limits accessibility for readers outside quantum computing.
Limited Experimental Evaluation
- The baselines are largely older methods and omit important recent developments. The paper lacks comparisons with recent EEG work, such as foundation models [a, b, c], geometric neural networks [f, g, h, i], and EEG alignment methods [d, e].
- Evaluation is limited to three binary tasks, without larger-scale benchmarks such as TUAB/TUEV or any multiclass task.
References
[a] Large Brain Model for Learning Generic Representations with Tremendous EEG Data in BCI
[b] CBraMod: A Criss-Cross Brain Foundation Model for EEG Decoding
[c] REVE: A Foundation Model for EEG — Adapting to Any Setup with Large-Scale Pretraining on 25,000 Subjects
[d] SPDIM: Source-Free Unsupervised Conditional and Label Shift Adaptation in EEG
[e] HEEGNet: Hyperbolic Embeddings for EEG
[f] MAtt: A Manifold Attention Network for EEG Decoding
[g] Towards a General Attention Framework on Gyrovector Spaces for Matrix Manifolds
[h] Neural Networks on Symmetric Spaces of Noncompact Type
[i] Riemannian High-Order Pooling for Brain Foundation Models
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
4 comments
Thank you for the response. My main concern remains unresolved: the motivation for introducing the quantum component is still unclear. From the current experiments, I don't find enough practical advantages over EEG foundation models or geometric approaches. I therefore maintain my original score.
Part 1/2: VQC motivation and ablation evidence
Thank you for clarifying your concern. We use a shallow VQC to learn coupled interactions within complementary EEG views through a compact, constrained map when few source patients are available. Its embeddings also determine view weights shared with the residual branch. Encoder, periodic, alignment and branch controls assess this architecture's task-dependent benefits.
Motivation for limited-patient transfer. Many trials still come from few independent patients: UCL uses six training, one validation and one test patient per outer fold. Temporal evolution, channel–band power and covariance remain separate views, with interactions learned before fusion.
Each source-standardized view is projected to
=\pi\tanh\!\left(g_m(\widetilde{\mathbf x}_i^{(m)})\right) \in[-\pi,\pi]^{2Q}.$$ For $Q=6$, twelve angles feed RY/RZ encoding and two trainable RY/RZ layers with ring CNOTs. The circuit parameters jointly determine the coefficients of this finite trigonometric family, including coupled coordinate functions. Appendix G derives $\langle Z_2\rangle=\cos a_1\cos a_2$. Periodic controls test alternative parameterizations. Fourier-like terms concern encoded coordinates; EEG band power is computed during view construction. Each view has an independent six-qubit, two-layer circuit. Six bounded raw Pauli-Z expectations feed learned postprocessing to produce the per-view embedding. A width-16 residual encoder retains a wider representation. Raw-readout bounds need not hold after postprocessing. *Locations: Introduction, pp. 1–2; §3.2, pp. 3–4, Eq. (2) and raw readout on p. 4; §3.5, p. 5, Proposition 1; Appendices E.1, G, H and O, pp. 16, 18, 19 and 27.* In BNCI/UCL/EEGET order (B/U/E), nominal parameter totals are 18,775/20,951/16,651 versus MLP's 18,640/20,820/16,520: less than 1% apart. Appendix I specifies model-dependent recipes and distinguishes nominal size from effective capacity. Excluding inert terminal $R_Z$ angles leaves VQC–MLP count differences of 99/89/89, not active-parameter totals. *Locations: Table 3(b), p. 8; Appendices H–I, p. 19.* **Ablations.** VQC has higher mean Macro-F1 than MLP and periodic principal-encoder controls on all three datasets, including a positive encoder difference without alignment. All ten BNCI participants, eight UCL patients and six EEGET pairs are included. Scores are Macro-F1 (%), mean±sample SD across seeds {0,1,2} after averaging fixed outer folds within each seed. Δ is full-minus-comparator pp in B/U/E order; no significance stars are assigned. |Configuration|BNCI|UCL|EEGET|Δ B/U/E| |---|---:|---:|---:|---| |**MVQAN-CORAL**|**67.24±0.22**|**60.74±0.35**|**76.62±4.39**|Reference| |MLP, alignment on|61.10±0.30|54.20±0.28|67.80±1.14|+6.14/+6.54/+8.82| |TrigRing|60.45±0.27|53.85±0.25|66.90±1.08|+6.79/+6.89/+9.72| |Fourier MLP|60.25±0.26|53.50±0.24|66.45±1.02|+6.99/+7.24/+10.17| |RFF, D=64|59.75±0.32|53.15±0.31|66.10±1.15|+7.49/+7.59/+10.52| |VQC, alignment off|60.10±0.33|55.10±0.37|67.60±1.18|+7.14/+5.64/+9.02| |MLP, alignment off|58.10±0.28|53.80±0.32|65.10±1.12|+9.14/+6.94/+11.52| |Residual only|62.74±1.10|47.28±2.72|83.63±3.77|+4.50/+13.46/−7.01| |Residual only, nominally matched|64.27±1.06|45.10±5.72|87.78±5.97|+2.97/+15.64/−11.16| |Quantum only, no residual|61.40±0.29|56.20±0.30|68.80±1.10|+5.84/+4.54/+7.82| *Locations: Tables 3–5, pp. 8–9; Appendix J, Tables 10–12, pp. 20–21; K, Table 13, p. 22; L, Table 16, p. 23; M, Table 21, p. 26.* With views and separation retained, VQC–MLP is +2.00/+1.30/+2.50 without alignment and +6.14/+6.54/+8.82 with it. Alignment adds 7.14/5.64/9.02 to VQC and 3.00/0.40/2.70 to MLP; differences of increments are 4.14/5.24/6.32. These assess encoder–regularization interaction under Appendix I's recipes. *Locations: Table 5, p. 9; Appendix L.1, p. 23; Figure 6, p. 24.* All eight held-out UCL patient means favor VQC over MLP across the same three seeds: +6.20–7.00 pp, mean +6.54. This supports improvement distributed across the evaluated ALS imagery cohort, rather than concentrated in a few patients (Table 14; Figure 5, p. 22). Removing all VQC dependencies changes view scoring and the representation receiving auxiliary losses. The hybrid exceeds both single branches on BNCI/UCL; matched residual-only is stronger on EEGET, 87.78% versus 76.62%. We retain this task dependence, without claiming the VQC essential across tasks (§5, p. 10; Appendix M, Table 21, p. 26). Together, encoder and alignment comparisons support the VQC-containing configuration within this architecture. The branch results show that its benefit is task-specific.Part 2/2: Geometric and foundation-model comparisons
Full-cohort geometric comparisons. MVQAN-CORAL has higher mean Macro-F1 than the evaluated classical Riemannian pipelines on their corresponding full-cohort tasks. Scores below are Macro-F1 (%), mean±seed SD; parentheses give MVQAN-minus-comparator pp. — means not evaluated.
| Category | Model | BNCI, 10 folds | UCL, 8 folds | EEGET, 6 folds |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Proposed hybrid | MVQAN-CORAL | 67.24±0.22 | 60.74±0.35 | 76.62±4.39 |
| Riemannian tangent space | TS + SVM | 62.50±0.31 (+4.74) | 57.85±0.36 (+2.89) | 69.10±1.12 (+7.52) |
| Riemannian tangent | TS + LR | 60.80±0.28 (+6.44) | 56.10±0.33 (+4.64) | 67.40±1.05 (+9.22) |
| Riemannian covariance classifier | MDM | 56.40±0.25 (+10.84) | 53.20±0.30 (+7.54) | 62.80±0.95 (+13.82) |
| xDAWN+tangent space | xDAWN + TS + LR | 61.30±0.29 (+5.94) | — | — |
| xDAWN+covariance geometry | xDAWN + MDM | 57.80±0.26 (+9.44) | — | — |
| Combined-view classifier | All-view SVM | 64.80±0.45 (+2.44) | 58.40±0.31 (+2.34) | 73.15±0.98 (+3.47) |
Locations: Table 3(a), p. 8; Appendix J, Table 10, p. 20; Tables 11–12, p. 21.
Against TS + SVM, the strongest listed classical Riemannian pipeline, gains are 4.74/2.89/7.52 pp in BNCI/UCL/EEGET order. These compare complete pipelines; seed summaries alone do not establish paired participant-level significance.
Recent model families. LaBraM, CBraMod and REVE are EEG foundation models; MAtt/SPDNet are geometric neural networks. TSMNet combines SPD representations and domain-specific normalization. SPDIM-style and EA configurations provide additional adaptation/alignment comparisons. † uses unlabeled held-out observations; MVQAN-CORAL is source-only.
These additional methods use one selected held-out unit per dataset, averaged across three seeds, and cannot be ranked directly against MVQAN's full-cohort means above.
| Category | Model | BNCI | UCL | EEGET |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EEG foundation | LaBraM | 65.38±1.89 | 49.61±2.55 | 69.96±2.60 |
| EEG foundation | REVE | 67.01±0.84 | 47.90±2.25 | 89.12±5.27 |
| EEG foundation | CBraMod | 70.08±3.23 | 39.96±3.43 | 92.89±2.98 |
| Geometric NN | MAtt | 52.16±1.93 | 49.10±5.11 | 86.38±5.05 |
| Geometric NN | SPDNet | 46.02±0.70 | 48.48±4.34 | 78.89±10.15 |
| SPD/domain normalization | TSMNet (SPDDSMBN)† | 54.06±0.59 | 51.70±0.68 | 46.41±1.35 |
| Adaptation | SPDIM-style† | 45.45±0.00 | 44.94±0.83 | 36.58±4.11 |
| Alignment+NN | EA + EEGNet† | 68.52±2.87 | 48.69±2.32 | 44.67±6.21 |
| Alignment+tangent | EA + TS-LR† | 51.45±0.00 | 50.59±0.00 | 28.88±0.00 |
Scores are Macro-F1 (%), mean±sample SD across seeds for the selected unit. Foundation-model runs fine-tune public checkpoints on source participants using 200 Hz inputs and 1-s patches. SPDIM-style denotes the evaluated adaptation variant. Zero SD has Table 22's stated interpretation, not population-level certainty.
Locations: §2, p. 3; §4.2, p. 7; Appendix M, Table 22 and accompanying text, p. 26.
This panel broadens model coverage but establishes no matched full-cohort advantage over foundation models or modern geometric networks. Subtracting single-unit scores from cohort means is not a valid comparative margin; statistical testing cannot repair that mismatch. The scores also do not establish foundation-model overfitting to individual patients. Direct comparisons require matching held-out units and aggregation.
Complementary views. Geometry-only MVQAN scores 60.80/51.74/70.50% versus the full view set's 67.24/60.74/76.62%: differences of 6.44/9.00/6.12 pp. This supports combining geometry and other EEG summaries within the system; it is a view-set comparison, not an isolated quantum-effect test (Appendix N, Table 23, p. 27).
Clinical scope and practical contribution. UCL evaluates imagery transfer within eight ALS patients; BNCI is a complementary healthy-participant P300 task. EEGET predicts cohort-labeled windows, with ALS recorded at home and controls in a laboratory. This acquisition qualification applies to every model and does not identify which cues explain a particular model's score.
We substantiate a compact, source-trained hybrid representation with observed gains over the evaluated MLP/periodic configurations and full-cohort classical geometric pipelines. The Introduction and Method explain the VQC's motivation and architectural roles; the experiments show where it helps and where alternatives remain stronger. All circuits are analytically simulated. The contribution is architecture-specific, without universal encoder superiority or hardware quantum advantage.
Locations: §1, pp. 1–2; §3.2, pp. 3–4; §4.1, pp. 6–7; §5–6, pp. 7–10; Appendices Q–S, pp. 27–28. We respectfully ask that this experimental record and stated scope be considered in your final assessment.
Thank you for the specific suggestions. We have expanded the quantum explanation, added branch ablations and recent baselines, and clarified the study’s focus on EEG transfer with limited ALS patient data. The corrected implementation retains the same folds, seeds {0,1,2}, evaluation and selection settings.
W1. Quantum motivation and the residual-only comparison. The task-aware EEG views preserve ERP timing, band power and cross-channel structure. The VQC learns a compact trigonometric map with coupled coordinate terms before fusion; the primer derives z2=cosa1cosa2 in a two-qubit example. Its periodicity acts on learned angular coordinates, rather than directly representing EEG oscillation frequencies. The embeddings also determine the view weights shared with the residual branch. These representation and weighting functions are distinct from constructing views and aligning source distributions.
We test their contribution using encoder substitutions and the requested residual-only ablation. Residual-only removes every VQC dependency: its scorer and auxiliary losses use residual embeddings. The nominally matched variant adjusts the classical parameter budget.
Macro-F1 is mean ± sample SD across three seed-level fold averages (%):
The full model exceeds nominally matched residual-only by 2.97/15.64 points on BNCI/UCL; residual-only is stronger by 11.16 points on EEGET. With views and alignment retained, the VQC-containing configuration exceeds the MLP configuration by 6.14/6.54/8.82 points. These results support the evaluated hybrid integration, with task-dependent benefit.
Revision: §1, pp. 1–2; §3.2, pp. 3–4; §5, pp. 7–10; Appendix G, p. 18; Appendix M, p. 26, Table 21.
W2. Writing, references and quantum background. We have expanded the Introduction and Method citations and clarified the technical components at their use. The recommended works are cited as follows; letters follow your review:
The primer defines RY/RZ rotations, CNOT and Pauli-Z readout, with a worked two-qubit example. Appendix H includes the propositions’ proofs and terminal-phase lemma.
Revision: §§2–3, pp. 2–6; Appendix G, p. 18; Appendix H, p. 19.
W3. Recent baselines. We added the following evaluations. Values are mean Macro-F1 (%) across three seeds on one selected held-out unit per dataset; Table 22 includes seed SDs.
† uses unlabeled held-out observations; our primary method is source-only. SPDIM-style denotes the evaluated adaptation variant. These single-unit results are reported separately from full-cohort averages. HEEGNet, GyroAtt, symmetric-space networks and RHOP are discussed and cited; we do not claim experimental results for them.
Revision: §4.2, p. 7; Appendix M, p. 26, Table 22.
W4. Multiclass and larger-scale evaluation. We have revised the framing to focus on source-only transfer with the limited ALS patient cohorts evaluated here. UCL addresses left/right motor-imagery decoding in eight ALS patients. EEGET provides a secondary cohort-label window task involving six ALS participants, with its home/laboratory acquisition qualification retained. BNCI2014-009 supplies a complementary P300 benchmark in ten healthy participants.
The binary endpoints follow these specific study questions. We have aligned the Abstract, Introduction, endpoint rationale and Conclusion with this scope. The present evidence concerns source-only transfer for these ALS-related tasks and the complementary healthy-participant benchmark. Multiclass or TUAB/TUEV evaluation would examine generalization beyond these endpoints.
Revision: Abstract and §1, pp. 1–2; §4.1, pp. 6–7; §§6–7, p. 10; Appendix S, p. 28.