- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigated cross-subject EEG seizure prediction under domain shift and proposes H-GSC, a hierarchical geometric framework with Structural Constraints for few-shot EEG adaptation. I like the motivation, but the experiment is far from solid. First, there is no baseline comparison; the main table is an ablation study. And it only tests on seizure detection tasks; for manifold-based domain adaptation methods for EEG, the community usually tests them on motor imagery, SSVEP, and emotion tasks. I did not see any motivation or design to focus on seizure tasks. I put 1 now; I am open to reconsider if I can see experimental improvements
Critical strengths
S1: Cross-subject decoding is a very related and practical powerful research topic in the field.
S2: The discussion between domain adaptation methods and foundation models for EEG decoding is meaningful.
Critical weaknesses
W1: The main experiment results table is an ablation study.
W2: No comparison with either domain adaptation or EEG decoding baselines in the main contexts. More comparison baselines are needed; the authors discussed these in related work but did not compare with them.
W3: Table 12 violates the ICLR format requirements.
W4: The propsoed framework studied the cross-subject decoding framework in EEG, but only tested on seizure prediction tasks. I did not see any motivation for this framework that is specialized for seizure prediction tasks.
W5: EEG-based manifold decoding is mainly used for motor imagery, SSVEP, and emotion. Very few have applied them to seizure prediction because it largely depends on temporal information. See [1][2][3] for examples.
References: [1] Kobler, Reinmar, et al. "SPD domain-specific batch normalization to crack interpretable unsupervised domain adaptation in EEG." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 35 (2022): 6219-6235. [2] Pan, Yue-Ting, Jing-Lun Chou, and Chun-Shu Wei. "MAtt: A manifold attention network for EEG decoding." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 35 (2022): 31116-31129.
Questions for authors
Seizure prediction tasks that segement EEG windows may introduce bias in few-shots adaptation setting.
I put a score of 1 now. I am open to reconsidering it if you can add more baselines and more EEG tasks. In addition to the domain adaptation (DA) methods discussed in the related work, [1] is the current SOTA DA framework. For the EEG decoding models, classical models like EEGNet [2] and EEGConformer [3] are necessary; for foundation models, [4] are good.
At least you should also test it on broader EEG tasks like motor imagery and SSVEP.
[1] Li et al. "HEEGNet: Hyperbolic embeddings for EEG." International Conference on Learning Representations. Vol. 2026. 2026. [2] Lawhern, Vernon J., et al. "EEGNet: a compact convolutional neural network for EEG-based brain–computer interfaces." Journal of neural engineering 15.5 (2018): 056013. [3] Song, Yonghao, et al. "EEG conformer: Convolutional transformer for EEG decoding and visualization." IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering 31 (2022): 710-719. [4] Jiang, Wei-Bang, Liming Zhao, and Bao-Liang Lu. "Large brain model for learning generic representations with tremendous EEG data in BCI." International Conference on Learning Representations. Vol. 2024. 2024.