W1. The core conceptual contribution is limited, and there is a lack of substantive connection between the formal analysis and the method design.
Sec 3.2 states that different noises correspond to the same clean-image target and describes noise statistics through conditional mean and variance. This statement is basically reasonable, but it does not explain why the same fixed denoiser should be effective across noises, nor does it derive principles for denoiser selection, conditional parameter settings, or judging performance degradation.
The authors have correctly noted that different noises do not necessarily share the same optimal denoising estimator. Therefore, “shared target” can currently only serve as motivation for empirical research and is not yet sufficient to constitute an independent theoretical or methodological contribution. Simple methods can have important value, but this paper needs more discriminative experimental findings to support this positioning.
W2. Key controls are missing, making it impossible to distinguish the contribution of the pretrained prior from the effect of general noise suppression.
The main experiments mainly compare original noisy inputs with DRUNet-preprocessed inputs. The lack of simple smoothing, median filtering, and other classical or low-cost denoising methods prevents readers from determining how much irreplaceable benefit the complex pretrained module actually brings. The comparison of DnCNN and FFDNet is only provided as aggregated results on Sample4Geo/CVUSA-C, which is insufficient to support conclusions about denoiser selection across models and datasets. For a paper whose main contribution is empirical, these controls are more important than further adding results under similar settings.
W3. Key implementation and selection protocols are not sufficiently disclosed, which affects reproducibility.
Equation (9) introduces a fixed conditional parameter γD, but the paper does not report the actual conditional values used by DRUNet and FFDNet, their units, or the basis for their selection. The specific checkpoint, DnCNN version, order of denoising and resizing, input/output ranges, and padding strategy are also insufficiently clear. In addition, the authors state that DRUNet was selected as the default method because of its highest empirical robustness, but they do not clarify which data were used for model and configuration selection and whether these data are independent of the final reported sets. This does not directly prove that test-set tuning occurred, but it needs clarification.
W4. The harm under mild noise cannot be ignored, and there is a lack of evaluation of clean inputs passed through denoising.
Sec 4.5 describes the degradation under the mildest noise as small, but in Table 3, Sample4Geo/CVUSA-C at Severity 1 drops from 97.43% to 93.26% in average R@1; in Table 5, the corresponding drops for GeoDTR+ on the two datasets are 6.61 and 6.37 percentage points, respectively. These results are directly relevant to a deployment strategy that enables preprocessing by default without identifying the noise state. The clean-input baseline in Figure 4 cannot replace the experiment of “clean inputs passed through the same denoiser.” The absence of this control prevents the paper from fully assessing the risk of fixed preprocessing for normal queries.
W5. The computational cost is high, and the practicality conclusion needs to be narrowed or supported with additional evidence.
In Figure 3, DRUNet increases the reported total computation from 61.1 to 545.7 GFLOPs, about 8.93 times the original, while the corresponding average R@1 improves by about 4.39 percentage points. The larger gains under severe noise may justify this cost, but the paper does not provide actual latency, throughput, peak memory usage, or a clear basis for online query computation. Therefore, "no retraining required" and "easy to integrate" are supported, but it cannot yet be directly inferred that the deployment cost is acceptable.
W6. The result analysis lacks uncertainty and sufficiently in-depth explanations of heterogeneity.
The paper does not report confidence intervals, nor does it state whether multiple independent noise realizations were evaluated. For small changes such as +0.44 percentage points on L2LTR/CVACT, the stability of the results is difficult to judge. The feature analysis in Appendix C is a useful supplement, but the retrieval margin lacks a clear mathematical definition, and the analysis covers only one model–dataset combination. It has not yet explained why the same denoising treatment produces significantly different effects on different models. The equally weighted average over five severity levels can serve as a benchmark metric, but it should not be directly equated with the expected benefit under real deployment distributions.