- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Cross-view geo-localisation (CVGL) has attracted considerable attention due to its research value in cross-modal feature matching and its practical applications in visual localisation and vehicle navigation.
This paper addresses a key limitation of existing generalisable CVGL methods , namely, relying primarily on view-invariant visual features may lead to ambiguous matching when different locations share similar visual semantics. The authors propose GeoCore, a framework that combines semantic and structural cues to improve cross-domain localisation. GeoCore consists of two complementary branches. The Textually Anchored Semantic Core branch aligns image-level features with textual descriptions generated offline by a vision-language model (VLM) to learn transferable scene semantics. The Reliability-Aware Structural Learning branch aggregates spatial features into anchored regions, models their spatial arrangements through rotation-symmetric structural refinement, and estimates regional reliability under appearance variations.
The authors evaluated GeoCore on five UAV- and ground-view localisation benchmarks and reports improvements over existing methods, with strong results in cross-dataset generalisation.The resulting descriptor is trained using cross-view alignment and auxiliary semantic and reliability objectives.
Critical strengths
-
Well-motivated problem formulation: Combining transferable scene semantics with fine-grained spatial structure is sensible. The two branches are complementary. Semantic features provide coarse geographic discrimination, while structural features help distinguish locations with similar scene-level semantics. I find Fig-5 which provides CAM visualisations of these complementary cues is convincing.
-
Explicit modelling of regional reliability: Estimating the geographic discriminability of local regions under appearance variations is useful. Rather than simply aggregating local features, the method aims to identify regions that remain discriminative across different environmental conditions. This is a promising direction for improving robustness in cross-view localisation.
Critical weaknesses
--- . Limited technical novelty: Combining semantic and structural information is interesting, but the individual components, including CLIP-based semantic alignment, regional aggregation, 4-rotation-symmetry based invariances, and reliability prediction, are mostly established techniques. The paper does not clearly demonstrate what is technically novel beyond combining them in one framework. As shown in Figure 1, the design also involves considerable engineering designs and multiple components, which obscures the core idea. The authors should clarify the key insight that distinguishes GeoCore from existing methods.
---. The dependence on VLM-generated descriptions in training is unclear: The semantic branch relies on offline-generated textual descriptions during training, but their quality and consistency are not sufficiently discussed. The authors should examine in inference how sensitive the method is to description quality, different VLMs, and dataset-specific cues. They should also clarify how much improvement comes from textual supervision rather than the visual backbone itself.
Questions for authors
-
What invariance does the four-rotation in RSSR provide? Can it handle arbitrary rotations, such as roads that are not aligned with the four 90-degree orientations?
-
Textual supervision: How sensitive is GeoCore to noisy or incomplete VLM-generated descriptions? Do the results remain consistent when using different VLM models or simpler than CLIP descriptions? If possible within ICLR rule, can the authors provide additional experiments to show this ?
-
There are some related relevant references missing: e.g.
- From Satellite to Ground: Satellite Assisted Visual Localization with Cross-view Semantic Matching (ICRA 2024).
- VGA: Empowering Aerial-Ground Localization by Visual Geometry Alignment (CVPR 2026).
- Optimal Feature Transport for Cross-View Image Geo-Localization_ (AAAI 2020).
4 comments
Response to Reviewer gpCP (2/4)
W2/Q2: Effectiveness of textual supervision
1. The quality control of the text-generation pipeline: Appendix A.2.4 describes our pipeline of text-generation quality control, which integrates cross-view verification and retrieval-oriented prompting. Rather than independently captioning images, we generate location-level descriptions from paired views, retaining shared scene elements and coarse spatial relations while filtering unsupported or view-specific cues (e.g., illumination). A consistent three-field format further standardizes the generated descriptions across different datasets. As clarified in 3.3, text is generated and encoded offline using a frozen CLIP text encoder, serving only as training supervision. GeoCore performs image-only retrieval at inference, without requiring extra textual descriptions.
2. Sensitivity analysis on textual descriptions: To evaluate sensitivity to imperfect textual descriptions, we introduce controlled text perturbations involving noise and incompleteness at different levels. In Table R1, both noisy and incomplete descriptions reduce image-text relevance (Column Sim: 0.6531 for University-1652→SUES-200 and 0.6241 for CVACT→CVUSA with the original descriptions), with stronger degradation under noise. Specifically, Sim decreases from 0.6531 to 0.4641 under 90% noise and to 0.5299 under 90% dropping on University → SUES, with consistent trends on CVACT → CVUSA. Despite the reduced quality, GeoCore maintains strong retrieval performance, achieving over 93% R@1 and 94% AP across all perturbation settings on University → SUES. These results demonstrate GeoCore's robustness to noisy and incomplete textual anchors, indicating that partially correct semantic information remains effective for learning geographic discrimination and supporting its practical applicability in real-world scenarios.
Table R1: Ablation results (%) on the qualities of perturbatant text anchor
| Method | University-1652 → SUES-200 (R@1 / AP / Sim) | CVACT → CVUSA (R@1 / R@1% / Sim) |
|---|---|---|
| Noisy 50% | 94.71 / 95.65 / 0.5687 | 68.73 / 97.75 / 0.5140 |
| Noisy 90% | 93.25 / 94.26 / 0.4641 | 68.28 / 97.58 / 0.4291 |
| Drop 50% | 95.45 / 96.24 / 0.6074 | 68.66 / 97.87 / 0.5698 |
| Drop 90% | 93.54 / 94.49 / 0.5299 | 68.09 / 97.46 / 0.5028 |
Notes on Table R1: (1) Perturbation protocol: We randomly select 50% or 90% of semantics (e.g., elements in Appendix A.2.4) across training locations and either remove the selected textual items (Drop/Incomplete) or replace them with randomly sampled items from other locations (Noisy). For Drop, at least one semantic item is retained per location. (2) Sim: The score measures cross-view image-text consistency. We use Qwen3-VL-Reranker-2B to assess the relevance of each description to its paired UAV and satellite images, computing the score as σ(logit_yes − logit_no) and averaging it across both views and all locations.
3. Dependence of text supervision: In HfHm's Table R2, removing reduces R@1 from 96.61% to 92.25% on University → SUES and from 72.60% to 70.43% on CVACT → CVUSA for GeoCore, confirming that textual guidance can promote semantic–structural complementarity and geographic discrimination. Furthermore, we evaluate alternative VLMs in Table R2. GeoCore consistently maintains competitive retrieval performance across different VLMs, including the smaller-scale Qwen3-VL-2B, demonstrating the effectiveness and transferability of textual supervision without relying on a specific VLM generator.
Table R2: Ablations results (%) on different VLMs for text anchor
| VLM | University-1652 → SUES-200 (R@1 / AP) | CVACT → CVUSA (R@1 / R@1%) |
|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-VL-2B | 95.91 / 96.64 | 70.80 / 98.05 |
| DeepSeek-V4.1 | 96.51 / 97.09 | 72.70 / 98.18 |
The additional results and corresponding analysis are now included in the supplementary material (Appendix A.3.7(a), Table 14, page 30, and Tables 15-16, page 31).
Response to Reviewer gpCP (3/4)
Q1: More analyses on RSSR
RSSR applies a shared nonlinear readout to four quarter-turn permutations of the encoded regional grid and averages the outputs. As established in Appendix A.1.2 (Lemma 3), RSSR ensures invariance to discrete quarter-turn permutations of the regional grid, rather than arbitrary input-image rotations. Importantly, these permutations do not constrain road orientations: roads at arbitrary angles remain representable through local visual features and their spatial arrangements, without requiring alignment to the four canonical directions.
As shown in Appendix Table 11, RSSR improves R@1 over ordered readout (without rotation averaging) by 0.69 and 0.25 points on University → SUES and CVACT → CVUSA, respectively. Conversely, shuffling regional arrangements (permuting region features before RSSR) reduces R@1 by 1.47 and 1.18 points. Overall, Lemma 3 and these ablations support that RSSR reduces sensitivity to grid orientation while preserving spatial organization for geographic discrimination.
Response to Reviewer gpCP (4/4)
Q3: More relevant works
We thank the reviewer for the helpful suggestion and have incorporated these studies into our discussion in the revised manuscript (Related Work, page 2).
Response to Reviewer gpCP (1/4)
We sincerely appreciate your valuable and constructive suggestions. Our point-by-point responses are provided below.
Most existing CVGL methods emphasize cross-view invariance. However, Fig. 1 reveals two limitations: invariant cues differ in geographic discriminability, and semantically similar locations can still cause ambiguous matches. This indicates that view consistency alone is insufficient, motivating complementary geographic evidence that is both transferable and discriminative.
GeoCore addresses the challenges through complementary semantic and structural learning. The semantic branch supplements visual cues with textual guidance to capture view-shared and transferable scene-level semantics. To resolve residual ambiguity among semantically similar places, the structural branch extracts fine-grained discriminative spatial features. SAR organizes spatial tokens into spatially anchored regions through content-spatial affinity, preserving regional relationships. Then, RSSR applies a shared nonlinear readout to four quarter-turn grid permutations and averages the outputs, reducing grid-orientation sensitivity while retaining spatial arrangements. And CRR promotes geographic discrimination across environments through training-only regional reliability supervision based on positive–hard-negative margins, without introducing additional modules during inference. Compared with prior methods, this branch learns more explicitly structured and orientation-robust regional representations. Overall, GeoCore learns transferable and geographically discriminative representations, supporting both UAV and Ground-view generalizable CVGL scenarios.
The experiments in Table 5 and Table 12 verify the complementary contributions of the two branches, while Table 11 and Reviewer HfHm's Table R2 support the effectiveness of RSSR and discrimination-aware CRR supervision. Importantly, Table 3 highlights the efficiency of image-only retrieval, demonstrating GeoCore’s practical applicability and deployment potential.