- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper builds on Loc² for fine-grained cross-view localization. Stage I follows Loc² and adds a region loss that trains each ground token to match a small Gaussian region on the satellite image instead of a single point. Stage II uses monocular depth to turn each ground token into a region on the ground plane and places it on the satellite image using the coarse pose, then retrieves nearby candidates, and reranks them with a cross-attention module before a final weighted procrustes solve. The method shows the best mean errors on VIGOR and KITTI under unknown orientation but is weaker when orientation is known or heading noise is small.
Critical strengths
1- The refinement step is sensible and gives consistent gains under unknown orientation on both datasets which is the hardest and most practical setting.
2- The paper writing and overall presentations are clear.
Critical weaknesses
1- The main idea isn’t really supported by the paper’s own results. The paper argues that modeling the size, shape, and orientation of each token’s region is what improves matching. But in Table 8, replacing the region covariance with a simple circle gives the same final pose and even better candidate recall without any retraining. This means the gain comes mainly from searching near where the coarse pose predicts the match which is standard guided matching. The region loss, a large part of the total improvement, is also never compared with a simple isotropic target. Without this evidence the contribution looks like an extra refinement pass on top of Loc² than a new idea.
2- The paper doesn’t show that Stage II is worth its cost. Stage II reduces the mean error by about half a meter on VIGOR but it adds a full monocular depth model at test time and cross-attention over 1024 anchors with up to 32 candidates each. No runtime, memory, or FLOPs are reported either for Stage I alone or for the full model compared with Loc². The gains also show up mainly under unknown orientation. With known orientation or small heading noise, the method falls behind FG², Loc², or HC-Net, so I think this needs justifications. Also, part of the improvement may come from setup differences (a newer depth model, cubemap processing, RANSAC in the main results only), and this also needs to be checked to have a fair comparison with baselines.
Questions for authors
Clarifications:
1- What are the inference time, memory, and FLOPs of Stage I alone, the full model, and Loc² on the same hardware including the depth model? 2- In the known-orientation and ±10° settings, does the solver use the orientation prior, or is yaw estimated freely? This could explain the weaker results there. 3- How does your Stage I differ from Loc² (depth model, cubemap processing, RANSAC)? Your visual baseline doesn’t match Loc² reported numbers. 4- Since a simple circle works as well as the full covariance in Table 8, what evidence shows that region shape matters for reranking or for the region loss?
Suggestions:
1- An accuracy-runtime plot comparing Stage I, the full model, and prior methods would make the value of Stage II much clearer. 2- A simple guided-matching baseline such as rerunning Stage I matching within a window around the coarse-pose prediction would show what the learned reranker adds.
5 comments
Invitation to Continue the Discussion
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your valuable feedback on this submission. Since we are now in the discussion phase, I would be grateful if you could engage with the authors’ responses and continue the conversation if there are outstanding issues that would benefit from clarification. Your participation will help ensure a constructive and thorough evaluation.
Many thanks again for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
Area Chair
Thanks for the reply and the new experiments. They address my main concerns. One question first: your new ablations show the simple circle works as well as or better than the ellipse. So the gain seems to come from the region size and the reranker, not the shape. Can you justify this here and could you update the paper’s claims to reflect this?
Rebuttal to Reviewer Fw5A
Dear Reviewer,
We hope everything is going well for you. We are truly grateful for your thoughtful review and constructive comments on our work. We sincerely hope that our responses have helped address your concerns and would appreciate hearing whether any points still require clarification. If you have any further questions or suggestions, we would be delighted to discuss them with you. Thank you again for your valuable feedback and for the time and effort you have devoted to evaluating our manuscript.