W1. The incremental contribution over existing adverse-weather CVGL research is insufficiently established, and comparisons with the closest prior work are missing.
The paper addresses an important problem, but its positioning does not sufficiently distinguish its contributions from existing adverse-weather and corruption-robust CVGL research. In particular, Benchmarking the Robustness of Cross-view Geo-localization Models (ECCV 2024) already introduced CVUSA/CVACT corruption benchmarks containing fog at multiple severity levels and investigated augmentation-based robustness improvements, yet this directly relevant benchmark is neither cited nor compared against. MuSe-Net also studies weather-dependent feature adaptation and includes synthetic adverse-weather experiments on street-to-satellite CVUSA, not only drone-to-satellite datasets. Thus, the ground–satellite setting alone does not distinguish the present work from existing weather-aware localization research.
At the methodological level, MRGeo directly addresses corrupted-image street-to-satellite CVGL through dynamically gated feature fusion, channel calibration, and geometric structural constraints. Although the manuscript cites MRGeo, it provides neither an experimental comparison nor a sufficiently detailed account of how WASA differs from this closely related approach. Comparisons with CBAM and Conv Adapter support WASA’s effectiveness relative to generic alternatives, but do not establish its competitiveness against methods specifically designed for robust CVGL.
The potentially meaningful distinctions, depth-dependent fog synthesis, a curated real-fog dataset, and a lightweight fog-oriented adapter, should therefore be established more explicitly. A particularly informative evaluation would compare the proposed synthesis pipeline with existing fog corruption/augmentation under matched training conditions and assess transfer to CVFog. The authors should also compare against the most relevant adaptable robust CVGL method under the same data splits and supervision, or clearly explain the technical constraints preventing a meaningful comparison.
W2. The experiments establish WASA’s utility more clearly than its proposed mechanism of degradation-aware structural calibration.
Combining established components is not inherently a weakness. The issue is whether the experiments isolate the capability introduced by the combination of Haar DWT, low-frequency statistics, Sobel responses, gating, and residual calibration. The results support the conclusion that WASA improves retrieval under the reported settings, but they provide less direct evidence that it specifically identifies and calibrates regions that are both fog-degraded and geographically discriminative.
First, the manuscript acknowledges that high low-frequency energy can also occur in naturally smooth regions. However, it does not directly demonstrate that the learned degradation cue distinguishes fog attenuation from scene smoothness or other forms of detail loss. The low-frequency haze prior itself has precedent in WDMamba, but transferring an image-domain observation to a learned shallow-feature statistic requires validation in the present setting. Second, Table 3 primarily ablates the inputs to the calibration gate: even the “DC Only” variant still uses the structural candidate Sg in the residual update. These results therefore should not be interpreted as independently isolating the full degradation and structural branches. Third, the heatmaps and response–retrieval-margin correlations are consistent with the proposed explanation, but do not rule out general structural enhancement or other learned attention effects; correlations pooled across fog intensities may also reflect severity as a common factor.
The generic-module comparisons and fixed-Sobel-versus-learnable-filter ablation provide useful supporting evidence, but do not fully resolve these alternatives. More diagnostic tests would include controlled clear/fog comparisons of the same scenes, analysis of degradation responses against known synthetic attenuation while controlling for scene content, and capacity-matched low-pass or generic-gating alternatives. Without such evidence, the mechanistic interpretation should be presented as a plausible explanation rather than an established account of the gains.
W3. The source of the semi-supervised gains and the scope of real-world generalization require further clarification.
- Semi-supervised adaptation.
Table 6 reports retained pseudo-pair precision of only 21.37%–22.82%. The authors appropriately acknowledge this substantial residual noise, so the concern is not undisclosed label unreliability, but the insufficiently explained usefulness of the retained supervision. In Table 7, adding weak-view consistency to margin filtering changes average precision from 22.12% to 21.68%, while increasing final R@1 from 30.67% to 34.75%. This does not contradict the reported improvement, but it indicates that pair correctness alone does not explain the gain. The contribution of stable sample selection, pseudo-pair identity information, and additional regularization from real-fog images remains unclear. Coverage-matched random selection, a consistency-only filtering variant, or an unpaired real-image consistency baseline would help distinguish these effects.
- The relationship to existing semi-supervised CVGL should also be clarified.
UCVGL (CVPR 2024) already studies ground–satellite pseudo-pair learning using mutual matching and Top-1–Top-2 similarity-margin filtering, yet is not discussed or compared against. The manuscript currently frames this component as a further study of real-fog adaptation, which is reasonable; its contribution should be stated accordingly. If methodological novelty is intended, the authors should identify and substantiate the advance over these existing strategies, preferably through a matched-budget comparison. The CVFog results and cross-dataset experiments provide useful evidence beyond within-dataset synthetic-fog evaluation. Nevertheless, both synthetic datasets use the same fog-generation pipeline, so cross-intensity and cross-dataset gains alone cannot separate robustness to fog more generally from adaptation to that generator’s characteristic degradation. CVFog offers a meaningful real-world check, but the breadth of that evidence is difficult to assess without clearer reporting of geographic coverage, route/sequence composition, scene categories, and ground-view field of view. Although the authors describe removing near-duplicates and overlapping satellite crops, the operational criteria and resulting split statistics are insufficiently specified to assess spatial independence.