- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Recorrupted to Noise (R2N), a framework for self supervised image denoising. Instead of predicting a clean image from a recorrupted observation, R2N trains a network to estimate the added recorruption noise. The method is built on the Conditional Projective Equivalence (CPE) condition, under which the estimated recorruption noise can be rescaled to recover the posterior mean of the clean image. The authors show that the framework covers general additive noise, natural exponential family models, and certain multiplicative noise models. They also connect R2N with existing recorruption methods such as R2R and GR2R, analyze the effect of the recorruption coefficient, and introduce a strategy to estimate this coefficient when the exact noise level is unknown. Experiments on synthetic noise settings and microscopy data are used to validate the theoretical analysis and denoising performance.
Critical strengths
1.The paper provides a clear theoretical formulation for recorruption based denoising through the CPE condition. This formulation covers several noise models within a common framework and gives a useful interpretation of existing methods such as R2R and GR2R.
- The theoretical discussion is supported by targeted experiments. In particular, the experiments on the recorruption coefficient agree with the predicted error trends, and the additional analysis examines coefficient estimation and robustness under observation model mismatch.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty relative to existing recorruption methods. The proposed framework is closely related to R2R and especially GR2R. The paper itself shows that the GR2R objective can be rewritten as the R2N objective up to a constant scaling factor. Therefore, in the settings already supported by GR2R, the practical distinction between the two formulations appears limited. The main novelty lies in the CPE interpretation and its extension to a broader set of noise models. I am not fully convinced that this represents a sufficiently large methodological advance for ICLR. 25127_Recorrupted_to_Noise_A_U
- The experimental evidence is not broad enough to support some of the general claims. The main comparisons rely on PURE, Noise2Score, Neighbor2Neighbor, and GR2R, with GR2R being the main recent baseline. Several experiments involve noise settings where many competing methods are not applicable, so R2N is sometimes mainly compared with Neighbor2Neighbor. In addition, the experiments on unknown noise still assume knowledge of the average noise level or the general noise model. Therefore, the claims about broad applicability and unknown noise conditions appear stronger than what is directly demonstrated by the experiments.
Questions for authors
1.Since the paper shows that the GR2R objective can be transformed into the R2N objective up to a constant factor, could the authors clarify what fundamentally new learning principle R2N introduces beyond this reformulation?
-
Could the authors provide comparisons with more recent self supervised denoising methods, especially methods published after 2025? This would help determine whether the empirical advantage remains under a broader set of competitive baselines.
-
For the unknown noise setting, the experiments still assume that the average noise level or the general noise model is available. How would R2N behave when both the noise distribution and its scale are unknown?
-
The CPE analysis supports general additive noise and certain multiplicative models under specific assumptions. Could the authors clarify the practical failure cases when these assumptions are violated, and provide empirical results under stronger model mismatch?
2 comments
The authors have added comparisons with recent methods and conducted additional experiments on CPE violations, addressing some of my previous concerns and strengthening the experimental evidence. I acknowledge these improvements and am willing to raise my score accordingly. However, concerns remain regarding the methodological novelty of R2N over GR2R and its applicability under unknown noise conditions.
Thank you very much for your invaluable comments and constructive suggestions. Here are answers to your questions.
(1) Our framework makes three contributions. First, we formulate a conditional proportionality criterion and construct recorruption models beyond the NEF settings of GR2R, including composite additive, clipped Cauchy, and multiplicative Beta noise. Second, we estimate decoding coefficients from noisy observations, reducing reliance on known noise parameters within the assumed model. We will clarify the additional assumptions this requires. Third, our error decomposition separates recorruption uncertainty from prediction-error amplification, clarifying the role of the recorruption parameter and guiding its selection.
(2) We have conducted additional comparisons with ZS-HPD (CVPR 2026), AdaReNet-N2V (CVPR 2025), TTAD (ICCV 2025), and TBSN (AAAI 2025). These cover zero-shot denoising, test-time adaptation, masking-based learning, and Transformer-based blind-spot networks.
For multiplicative noise, AdaReNet-N2V, ZS-HPD, TTAD, and TBSN receive known-mean normalization of their noisy inputs and targets. For each noise condition, we report the highest measured PSNR among the tested configurations of each baseline.
These results support R2N’s competitiveness against recent methods, with advantages depending on the noise model.
(3) Our "unknown-noise" experiments address uncertainty within an assumed noise family or with approximate scale information.
When both the noise distribution and its scale are unknown, R2N can still be trained using a chosen surrogate recorruption process, such as additive Gaussian noise. The decoding coefficient can then be estimated from noisy observations. However, successful prediction of the added noise alone does not guarantee accurate recovery of the underlying signal: the conditional proportionality relation may no longer hold, and empirical coefficient calibration cannot eliminate arbitrary distribution mismatch. Recorruption strength remains a hyperparameter. Thus, R2N is not an assumption-free solution to jointly unknown distributions and scales.
The real fluorescence microscopy experiment in the appendix provides one practical example. We apply Gaussian recorruption to observations with mixed Poisson–Gaussian noise and obtain 31.15 dB PSNR and 0.821 SSIM (Table 8). Here, the chosen Gaussian perturbation level is a hyperparameter, rather than a measurement of the true acquisition noise. This result illustrates that useful denoising is possible without an exact observation-noise model. It does not establish automatic noise-model identification.
(4) When CPE is violated, minimizing noise-prediction loss can yield biased reconstruction. Matching the noise mean and variance alone does not guarantee the required conditional relationship.
We isolated this failure in a controlled numerical experiment with multiplicative Beta observations. We replaced the compatible Beta recorruption multiplier with a two-point distribution having exactly the same mean and variance. We computed the optimal conditional noise predictors analytically and evaluated their reconstruction risks by numerical integration.